Better chances?

So let’s say that two students go to the same school with the same classes to choose from. Which student will colleges like?

Student 1: 4.0 UW GPA with a couple honor classes but no AP classes.

Student 2: 3.7 UW GPA with mainly honor and AP classes.

Student 2, because they had an opportunity to challenge themselves and took it

MODERATOR’S NOTE: We do not allow hypothetical questions.