@Starrystarrynight - some programs are harder to get into that others. It’s a fact but it’s also a fact that makes many people on cc get on the defensive. I don’t understand it. When you look at academic colleges it’s really easy to say - “Hey MIT and RPI are both great programs but MIT admits 4% of their applicants whereas RPI admits 40%.” Just as with the BFA apps - getting into an exclusive program is great. Getting into a less exclusive program is great. Getting into ANY program you can afford that will give your kid the training they crave is GREAT! But let’s be honest that not all programs are the same and not all are as difficult for admission. I don’t get why that is so hard. If you like a program, you like it - who cares how many other people do or don’t?
I would also like to say - diversity is really not a “casting trend”. That was a huge deal for my D - finding a diverse (in many ways, not just racial) BFA Acting/MT program can be difficult and that’s kind of a shame, imo.
@CaMom13 I was actually surprised by how little racial diversity there was among the auditioners, given that I was in California. (Though we didn’t do Unifieds, so what I saw was limited to specific programs) I wonder if the tendency to pick types at the conservatory-style programs gets in the way of other kinds of diversity, even as there’s a clear effort for more racial diversity. Or maybe it starts to happen earlier. I think we’ve all seen situations where a director sees someone who fits his or her image of a role and really tries to make that actor work. Some kids get breaks and get more confidence as a result. Others get discouraged.
I think any program where your kid gets a chance to learn, perform and expand is a good program for your kid. By the same token, any program that completely undermines your kid’s confidence and leaves them off worse than when they started is bad for your kid, no matter what the connections and name recognition. As a parent, it’s hard to tell which is which, so we just have to hope the colleges and conservatories are getting it right on their end.
It’s a huge leap of faith @Starrystarrynight - but so far the class of 2022 has been pretty darned happy and they went to many different programs so I have high hopes for the class of 2023! A lot of programs are getting it right. I can’t agree with you more on the mental health aspect - to me, that is #1.
In terms of diversity - it’s easier in University programs, especially if the Uni already attracts a broad cross-section of the world. Rutgers, for instance, is one of the most ethnically diverse Universities in the US - who knew? Conservatories have it tougher because their applicant base isn’t broadly diverse ethically or socio-economically. I do honor the ones that try to create a diverse class because it has to be difficult. But I’ve noticed some programs don’t even seem to try - in some classes it seems like almost all the kids look alike and I personally think that’s a shame… but I’ll get off my soapbox.
@CaMom13 – in fairness to some of the non-diverse programs, there might be something out of their control that produces that result. Last year, there was a mom of a super talented African American boy (was WL to Julliard!) who explained to us that there were cities that her son just didn’t feel comfortable living in as a black man. So he only applied to schools that were in locations where he’d feel comfortable living. Given that he was so talented, this worked for him, but my point is that schools in the cities he rejected didn’t have a chance. One other thing-- there is a financial aspect to this which can also reduce the competition for kids of color who don’t have means. Think of the cost of private lessons, the opportunity cost of not being able to have an after school job, etc. Fortunately PA public high schools (or financial aid at private ones) can get the kid past the financial barrier, but I don’t think that’s available to everyone with talent. So these barriers can result in a non-diverse applicant pool (or non-diverse group of students that accept the offers of acceptance) at some programs. Hard to fault the programs in these cases.
Well that was my point about conservatory programs and their applicant base, @MomofJ5. But I remember a picture of one of the classes from last year of a very popular small program and almost all of the boys looked alike - same ethnicity, same body type, similar features. Diversity comes in many flavors but you have to want it - all programs should, but not all programs do.
More on topic - Hoping for lots of positive news for NYU today for everyone waiting! (And their program’s diversity is unparallelled, lol). Crossing fingers and toes!
Hmm, interesting, just saw on Twitter: Q: “Do Tisch studio placements for freshman come out today w/ admission decisions?” Answer by MeetNYU: “Yes you should also receive that information with your decision”. Not sure if this would be new (as in the past studio placement has been announced about two weeks later, right?) or just misunderstanding between admissions and Tisch. Guess we shall see!
Huh - yes, that would be a change @NYDreammom ! I kind of liked it the other way because we were stunned with happiness at admission and again at studio admission but kids with multiple acceptances will hate waiting 2 more weeks for the final “word” and it is more efficient to get them all out at once.
Admission + studio all at once would be new - but I think it would be great! The more info , the better! If I recall, financials were included with decision in 2014
Well, now they have posted the following under the same Twitter response: Q from same person who asked initially about the studio placements, “If I got accepted ED will I still find out my studio today?” Answer by NYU Admissions: “They’ll likely be sent out on a rolling basis over the next few weeks”.
In other words - NYU admissions doesn’t know the Tisch process as well as we do. LOL. Studio assignments will likely be emailed out two weeks from now…
I am an extreme-dad. I am prone to gregariousness, helicopterishness, and bad dad-jokes. Consequently, I decided not to post until all of my daughter’s decisions are in. NYU is her last, and I think that technically, that decision is “in,” even if we can’t view it until 5:00 pm. Any other helicopter parents (my wife says it’s more like a gunship with me) out there with similar “keep it down” instructions from their kids?
NYU is a yes here too. It’s in the portal but not in his email yet. I’m staying quiet and letting him find out on his own … but I’m smiling, and turns out I happen to be dressed all in purple today!!