@Starrystarrynight What you are basing your comment on when you stated that Emerson & CalArts are a bit easier to get into than some of the other programs?
@minnesnowtagal -Have you communicated with Guthrie that they are your first choice and would accept if they took you from the WL? You should definitely do this. Send a LOCI, also see if you can arrange a visit. I don’t know this first hand, but I heard on last year’s boards that they only accept the number of people that they want in the program. So for every denial they get from their offers, they go to the WL. If you make it clear that you want them, they might just move you to the top of the WL. Good luck!
And the final two rejections for my D were Pace and BU. Pace was one I thought she’d get (at least in the beginning of this process last year). But just shows the how the assumptions we make don’t mean much. BU was the real surprise. My wife is a BU alumnus… AND my wife’s mother was a professor at BU for years. D felt like her BU audition at Chicago Unifieds was one of her best. Only thing we can think of is that BU has two rounds of Early Decision before the final RD decisions, and that possibly they had filled up a lot of her type by then. No matter, D got the school she wanted at the end of all this!
@MomofJ5@minnesnowtagal I can’t say I agree about the visit. Any student who is waitlisted has already visited since they have a callback weekend. My daughter got off the waitlist without another visit or an email to them. They did email her at one point and ask if she wanted to stay on the waitlist and she said yes, but that was the extent of it.
We got an email from Cal Arts tonight, sadly it was a no. Our son is fine about it though. Not really sure it was his top choice, although it was up there!! Two more to go!
I agree @CaMom13 about legacy status probably didn’t matter. Although they did acknowledge it in the decline email. I do think type matters in a lot of BFA programs. Maybe not at BU because they take such a large BFA freshman cohort?
Well, they have a very unique program @SoCalPops and I think they really look for fit - that was what was emphasized in our session, anyway. They do have a large acting class but they also have a high yield so their acceptance numbers aren’t that much larger than some small programs. I think they have to accept fewer each year because too many of the kids accept! The kids who are there from the class of 22 all seem over the moon so I think overall they seem to choose well. It’s funny - these decisions do seem so arbitrary and unfair when you’re in the midst and afterwards you say “well of course it worked out that way! Of course!”. :). My D was heartbroken by her rejection at BU but when NYU came through for her we wondered why she’d applied anywhere else.
@MomofJ5 I sent an email the next day confirming my continued interest and that they were my top school so now I’ve just been waiting. I’ve contemplated emailing again but I don’t know what to say and how not to annoy them lol