Biomedical Engineering

<p>so i am going to be a senior in high school this year. I decided that i want to go into Biomedical Engineering. I was doing more research and im quite confused about the Fundamentals of Engineering and Principles of Engineering exam . On Ehow.com it says i have to take both of these exams. Although i read all the types of tests that are offered and they </p>

<p>Agricultural
Architectural
Chemical
Civil: Construction
Civil: Geotechnical
Civil: Structural
Civil: Transportation
Civil: Water Resources and Environmental
Control Systems
Electrical and Computer: Computer Engineering
Electrical and Computer: Electrical and Electronics
Electrical and Computer: Power
Environmental
Fire Protection
Industrial
Mechanical: HVAC and Refrigeration
Mechanical: Mechanical Systems and Materials
Mechanical: Thermal and Fluids Systems
Metallurgical and Materials
Mining and Mineral Processing
Naval Architecture and Marine
Nuclear
Petroleum
Structural I (through October 2010)
Structural II (through October 2010)</p>

<p>which one would i take or is it even necessary to take the PE exam. If i want to pursue a career as a Biomedical Engineer. I would appreciate your answers</p>

<p>Biomedical engineers don’t have to worry about becoming a professional engineer. Biomedical engineering is not very useful at the undergraduate level. It is best to pursue at the graduate level.</p>

<p>There is no specific PE exam in BME but if you are well versed in electrical or mechanical engineering you could take the PE exam in one of those and still become a Professional engineer working as a Biomedical engineer because the specific category you take it in doesn’t really effect the actual licence.</p>

<p>Fundamentals of Engineering exam is mandatory and best taken after college.
But the professional engineer exam is optional and not needed for many disciplines like civil or BME. You still have excellent job opportunities even if you don’t take it for most disciplines except civil.</p>

<p>Only in USA usually though.</p>

<p>If you want to do BME, a much better path is to major in ME or EE as an undergraduate and then go to graduate school for BME. This will give you a much, much better fall back plan if you decide you don’t want to go to graduate school and you will learn one field in substantially more depth than if you majored in BME and just learned a little bit of everything.</p>

<p>I’m thinking of doing BME as well. I’m planning on applying to the top BME schools (MIT, JHU, Duke, GT, etc.) for undergrad. I have to wonder - why the advice to pursue some other discipline in undergrad, and then BME? If I get into some of those top schools (let’s say, top 5), wouldn’t majoring in BME be best? Oh, for more context, I’m planning on going to graduate school for BME, or possibly med school (some of my friends who are doing BME at one of the schools mentioned talked about this); I won’t be trying to get a job right after undergrad.</p>

<p>Jobs available to those with undergraduate BME degrees are not ideal. The field really wants you to have a MS or PhD for a decent job. While I don’t know the numbers, I’m sure many people who have plans to get a MS or PhD never end up getting them. Or they have their employers pay for it and earn a MS at night after working for a while. Of course, I’m sure these people all said the same thing going into college “it won’t happen to me, I’ll go straight through and get my MS/PhD.” And then it happened.</p>

<p>Fundamentals of Engineering exam is optional, unless your school in particular requires it.</p>

<p>There is no point in becoming a professional engineer in the biomedical engineering field unless you foresee yourself becoming an expert witness in court.</p>

<p>@PurdueEE</p>

<p>It seems that a BS in BME is only less preferable to a BS in ME/EE if you don’t plan on going for a MS or PhD in BME. ME/EE is a better “backup,” sure. I’m not stopping at a BS though. For whatever reasons, your personal experience is that many people plan to get a MS or PhD, but never do. Well, many people plan to get a BA or BS, but never do. Assuming you’re at Purdue, Purdue’s graduation rate isn’t stellar (<a href="http://www./ViewCollege_GraduationRates.aspx?uid=243780%5B/url%5D">http://www./ViewCollege_GraduationRates.aspx?uid=243780</a>) so that likely influenced your views (people aren’t as driven, etc.). Purdue is also poor for BME (23rd for undergrad, not ranked for graduate) but strong for ME/EE (7th and 10th for undergrad) so most people you know would do the smart thing - major in ME/EE for undergrad, again, influencing your views. On the flip side, I don’t think many JHU/MIT/Duke/GT students would pick ME/EE over BME/BE for undergrad if they planned on going to graduate school for BME.</p>

<p>@ken285</p>

<p>Could you elaborate? Do people with PhDs (both those in BME and those in other engineering disciplines) bother with the “professional engineer” certification?</p>

<p>Edit: Link is <a href=“http://www.scholarships%5B/url%5D%5Bdot%5Dcom/ViewCollege_GraduationRates.aspx?uid=243780”>http://www.scholarships[dot]com/ViewCollege_GraduationRates.aspx?uid=243780</a>.</p>

<p>Actually, most of my research into BME had little to do with Purdue, if any at all. I researched BME around the time I graduated because I started hearing about all these people majoring in it. I was open to the potential of graduate school if I could not find a job I thought I would somewhat enjoy and gave BME a glance. I looked at it as more than just a graduate program, I was a bit curious about it.</p>

<p>Most of the people I know who had big plans (PhD/MD) did not go to Purdue with me or I did not really talk to them very much. Lots were from high school and others I met along the way through various things. From my high school, one of the best in the state, I cannot think of a single person who had very lofty goals who actually achieved them. And these were all people who 100% certain they would become CEO/senator/president someday. I can, however, think of many who dropped out of school for various reasons or earned some worthless degree and now have crappy jobs making little money. Most of the people I keep in contact with from Purdue have good jobs and are having their employers pay for their master’s degree and really had no interest in BME.</p>

<p>Anyways, what I found was that most of the “interesting” jobs required a MS or PhD (and often a good amount of work experience). Jobs that were open to BS BMEs were often open to anyone with an engineering or science degree and frequently involved QA or something else not too terribly exciting. There were some good jobs open to those with just a BS but it really took a lot of searching. Contrast that to EE, for example, where I can be looking at hundreds of jobs for new graduates in a matter of minutes. Of course, I would classify many of those jobs as also being less than desirable but at least there through the sheer volume of jobs you will be able to find good ones. A lot of these companies are also stable and know how to bring in someone with less experience and turn them into productive employees, whereas the BME companies were usually quite a bit smaller and probably wanted people who could perform on day one.</p>

<p>Having a PhD has nothing to do with being a P.E. (professional engineer). Those who typically need to be licensed are those who practice engineering in fields which impact infrastructure and public safety. That means the vast majority of civil engineers and those involved in the design of buildings in other disciplines (such as mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems).</p>

<p>@PurdueEE</p>

<p>Actually, most of my research into BME had little to do with Purdue, if any at all. I researched BME around the time I graduated because I started hearing about all these people majoring in it. I was open to the potential of graduate school if I could not find a job I thought I would somewhat enjoy and gave BME a glance. I looked at it as more than just a graduate program, I was a bit curious about it.</p>

<p>You’re talking about when you graduated from HS, right? How did you do your job searches? Sounds like something I should look into.</p>

<p>Anyways, what I found was that most of the “interesting” jobs required a MS or PhD (and often a good amount of work experience). Jobs that were open to BS BMEs were often open to anyone with an engineering or science degree and frequently involved QA or something else not too terribly exciting. There were some good jobs open to those with just a BS but it really took a lot of searching. Contrast that to EE, for example, where I can be looking at hundreds of jobs for new graduates in a matter of minutes. Of course, I would classify many of those jobs as also being less than desirable but at least there through the sheer volume of jobs you will be able to find good ones. A lot of these companies are also stable and know how to bring in someone with less experience and turn them into productive employees, whereas the BME companies were usually quite a bit smaller and probably wanted people who could perform on day one.</p>

<p>I’m going to graduate school, so I’m not worried about, well, finding a job with just a BS under my belt. You did note earlier that you knew some people who planned on getting a MS/PhD, but ultimately didn’t. Where’d they end up, and with what? Do you know why? Familial pressures, financial reasons, etc.?</p>

<p>Most of the people I know who had big plans (PhD/MD) did not go to Purdue with me or I did not really talk to them very much. Lots were from high school and others I met along the way through various things. From my high school, one of the best in the state, I cannot think of a single person who had very lofty goals who actually achieved them. And these were all people who 100% certain they would become CEO/senator/president someday.</p>

<p>First of all, my earlier post shouldn’t be seen as an attack on Purdue. I was just noting its low graduation rate (it’s public, doesn’t mean it’s bad) and weakness in BME (relatively new field, often depends on a strong hospital nearby, etc.).</p>

<p>Anyways, that’s pretty depressing that you don’t know anyone from your high school who achieved their lofty goals - but on the other hand, anyone who 100% plans on being President or a Senator or a CEO of a major company isn’t being realistic (and might very well be stupid), so I can’t say I’m not surprised. Almost everyone has big dreams; only some have the intelligence (or otherwise innate ability, like acting or athleticism) and drive to achieve them. What state was your HS in, and how do you know it’s “one of the best?” To me, past the notable schools (Exeter, Andover, special “state-level” magnet schools, etc.), most high schools (like mine) are often just a big mishmash of different kids (potential-wise). Where did these PhD/MD kids go, what’d they major in, and how many are we talking about (a handful, 10 of 'em?)?</p>

<p>I can, however, think of many who dropped out of school for various reasons or earned some worthless degree and now have crappy jobs making little money.</p>

<p>Are you talking about the BME majors you knew (if so, where’d they go?), because it seems like you’re just talking about high school kids in general. I’m sure many kids from high school drop out or pursue less marketable majors. “Kids from high school” is a very broad category, after all.</p>

<p>Most of the people I keep in contact with from Purdue have good jobs and are having their employers pay for their master’s degree and really had no interest in BME.</p>

<p>Heh, again, I’m not slamming Purdue. Just going from graduation rates, though, it’s just more likely that a higher graduation rate will entail better employment on average. Again, Purdue’s public, so it can’t be as selective as private schools. There’ll still be very smart and capable kids there, but I’ll bet there are more slackers/dumbos/etc. than at a good private school. I’d also bet that “most of the people [you] keep in contact with” aren’t part of that group that really shouldn’t have been admitted, so your experiences (as most people’s are - mine included, obviously) are subject to sampling bias. That’s why getting different perspectives from different people (and trying to learn about their environment to adjust for the aforementioned bias) is useful :)</p>

<p>Back on topic, though, I think a BS in BME at a top BME school is better than or at least on par with a BS in EE/ME at a top EE/ME school for the purposes of BME grad school. Maybe if I get into MIT I won’t have to worry :wink: I feel Duke’s a match, and anything higher is a reach (MIT and JHU), though. And, I might end up pursuing medical school in the end anyways.</p>

<p>In this post, I’ve of course taken the assumption that I do indeed have the intelligence and drive to get a PhD in BME or MD (at a good school, too), and while I’m sure everyone believes the best of themselves, I’ve objectively done quite well. This isn’t a stats/chances thread of course, but a 2360 SAT score single-sitting with just a little self-study (and a 235 PSAT, so I should make National Merit), a 4.0 UW (HS is easy, though), 5’s on 9/9 AP exams taken so far (AP exams are curved to all hell, though, sure) and good ECs & writing skills (won’t list or describe, as those’re much less objective, but they’re decent by CC’s elevated standards) while managing to have enough time to play far, far too many videogames and plow through hundreds of gigs of movies and TV series (sidenote: I love HBO original series!) probably means I have the requisite intelligence and drive. Hah, I feel like such a boastful kid - good thing my username is “ccuser12345!” So anyways, with that context, since I plan on going to graduate school, it seems to me that a BS in BME is probably best for me, heh. This is not sarcasm: do you know anyone with my “stats” (hey, I don’t really like that term either) who failed/burned out? If so, do you know why? I’ll know what to avoid, then.</p>

<p>@ken285</p>

<p>Right, I thought P.E. was something that made you seem more employable (and it is, but generally isn’t worth it except for those involved with the things you mentioned) so I was wondering if people who went for a PhD (definitely “worth it” for BME, and for other fields too) also went for P.E. certification. Just the ones involved with infrastructure and public safety, I guess. Thanks!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Sometimes life happens buddy and there’s absolutely nothing you can do about it.</p>

<p>I have a quick question for everybody. I have a BS in BMET and about to start on a BS in EE. I thought I was working on an engineering degree with my ET but soon discovered by my second year that its more of a maintenece/hands on degree. Dont get me wrong I did learn alot about electronics but I do not know the theory behind engineering. Which is where I am at now. My general courses transferred over and I will start in the Fall. So for now my plan is BS in EE and MS either in BME or CS. The reason why my MS is between these two is that my interests are growing towards surgical robotics or medical devices. </p>

<p>What I found interesting is what Purdue said - Anyways, what I found was that most of the “interesting” jobs required a MS or PhD (and often a good amount of work experience). Jobs that were open to BS BMEs were often open to anyone with an engineering or science degree and frequently involved QA or something else not too terribly exciting. There were some good jobs open to those with just a BS but it really took a lot of searching. Contrast that to EE, for example, where I can be looking at hundreds of jobs for new graduates in a matter of minutes. Of course, I would classify many of those jobs as also being less than desirable but at least there through the sheer volume of jobs you will be able to find good ones. A lot of these companies are also stable and know how to bring in someone with less experience and turn them into productive employees, whereas the BME companies were usually quite a bit smaller and probably wanted people who could perform on day one. </p>

<p>Im a disabled veteran so my education is paid for all the way to an MS. What Im confused about is if I should try to get work experience during this time or just go to school full time and get it over with. Would my BS in BMET be considered experience? What would be my best options?</p>

<p>Sometimes life happens buddy and there’s absolutely nothing you can do about it.</p>

<p>Yeah, I actually wrote:</p>

<p>Of course, there’s always the chance I’ll get hooked on crack and turn to a life of deviancy. Or, my pop will win the lottery, and I won’t have to worry about finding employment in (not that it should be hard if I have a PhD or MD) - I’ll be worrying about whether I want my solid-gold toilet to be encrusted with diamonds or rubys!</p>

<p>I edited it out earlier since it seemed… off. Always stay positive, though, broski.</p>

<p>I can see why you edited it out, but at the same time I’m not trying to be negative. I’m just being real with you. Even the best can fail, and it sometimes just isn’t their fault.</p>

<p>It sounds like you know exactly what you want to do so just go for it.</p>

<p>To ccuser:</p>

<p>Biological engineering and biomedical engineering are two different things, although often they’re used synonymously. Bioengineering is at the cellular level – it includes topics such as cell biomechanics. Biomedical engineering deals more with the engineering of medical devices, such as artificial hearts. </p>

<p>MIT does not have a biomedical eng. major, but it does have a bioengineering major (which I’m doing right now and thinking of switching out). MIT, however, has a BME minor. Even if you’re at MIT, I think you might have to worry about the fact that a B.S. in bioengineering might not have a very wide job market. </p>

<p>Though you might be set on going to grad school, one’s thinking changes a LOT in college. I was dead set on majoring in biology and going to grad school when I was in high school; now I’m thinking of majoring in EECS and doing neither.</p>

<p>Hmm…so did I do a BME no-no? I’m a sophomore BME major and plan on going to grad school for BME. But now I see that I should be majoring in mech e or ee instead? I think it’s too late to change my major. Does it help that my concentration for undergrad will be on the ee side of BME?</p>