The elite LACs enroll rather small numbers of black students. As a result, these figures are likely to fluctuate noticeably from year to year.
Additionally, the performance of a single student can make quite a lot of difference. 6 of 7 students graduating at Scripps drops the graduation rate from 100% to 85%. 11 of 12 students at Mudd drops the rate to 91%. 48 of 49 students at Amherst, on the other hand, is 98%.
Number of black students in the freshman class, per 2017-18 CDS
7 Scripps
11 Washington & Lee
12 Harvey Mudd
13 Claremont McKenna
15 Kenyon
16 Bryn Mawr
22 Vassar
25 Mount Holyoke
26 Hamilton / Macalester
27 Swarthmore
28 Bates / Grinnell / Middlebury
30 Colgate
32 Bucknell
33 Davidson / Williams
36 Barnard
37 Bowdoin
38 Oberlin
40 Wellesley
42 Pomona
43 Smith
44 Lafayette / Trinity
47 Wesleyan
49 Amherst
@TomSrOfBoston: With examples of two colleges that appear near the top and bottom of the center of the above list, Amherst reports graduation rates for black or AA students identical to overall rates (95%/95%), while Bowdoin reports black or AA rates that are 7 percentage points lower than overall rates (88%/95%).