For the brand name snobs it certainly will. But for those who are interested in fit, this idea is brilliant. But unfortunately there are too many kids (largely influenced by their parents IMHO), who are more interested in a “good name” than a “good match”.
The biggest problem with this approach is that they were not comparing the top colleges with the lesser known colleges as the “elites” were not even there (e.g. Harvard). The author’s analogy was comparing Coke to Pepsi but the college fair was more like comparing RC Cola to TAB and Pepsi and Coke were not given a seat at the table.
IMO, this college fair approach would be much more compelling and enlightening if they had a good mixture of top, elite, and prestigious colleges and compared them anonymously with good but lesser known colleges and see if the students would be compelled to consider and choose the lower recognized ones? My guess is if the students asked the “right” questions such as 4 year graduation rates, need-blind admissions, internships oppos, research opportunities, average graduate pay, average grads/test scores of freshman class, number of world-class faculty, top programs / majors, etc. that the “cream of the crop” would rise to the top.
With that said, at the end of the day students should try to take an open mind approach to selecting which colleges to apply to but I think this article is much ado about nothing.
For many students and parents, “fit” is defined by prestige or selectivity.
The actual most important “fit” factor for most students and parents (cost, financial aid, scholarships) tends to be ignored in initial college searches.
It should be irrelevant to domestic applicants if a school is need aware or need blind; meeting full need is what’s important. Would you rather attend a need-blind school that doesn’t meet full need, or a need-aware school that does? A school’s being need blind or aware doesn’t affect how much you like a school, but rather only the chance of admission (usually just for those on the cusp). If you like a school, the NPC suggests it’s affordable, and it’s a good academic match, apply!
I like the idea in theory. I just don’t know how practical it would be. “Mom, I want to go to” X" school State. "… Mother reply : No you don’t!
But yes we all get hooked on name brand. But after looking at schools for two kids one wanting a small Lac and the other completely opposite with a Big Ten school we saw and got to talk to many great schools. There is a school for everyone.
“Meeting full need” means less than what people think it means, because colleges define “need” differently from each other. Better to use the colleges’ net price calculators to net price estimates for comparison.
It goes to show just how effective brand marketing can be. Colleges use every psychological trick in the book to get kids hooked on their brand name. It’s so effective, that kids will co-sign mountains of student debt so they can go to their “dream school.” It’s extremely manipulative, when you think about it. Many of these kids are so brainwashed that they ignore perfectly good scholarships right in front of them. I wish parents would spend more time teaching their kids about facts. That’s the idea behind higher education.