My D1 has to decide between Muhlenberg with $27k per year merit, vs Bucknell with $2500 merit. Is undecided for major, and a dancer. The total difference over 4 years is $126k due to Bucknell being more expensive. We know it is higher ranked but should ranking be worth that much $ ? We all loved the two schools, but Muhlenberg had a friendlier and less frenetic party vibe…
Muhlenberg despite it’s lower ranking is well respected. Bucknell is not worth $126000, especially when you seem to prefer the Mule’s vibe.
Unless you can pay the additional $126,000 with no loans/no hardship I’d opt for Muhlenberg.
FWIW Muhlenberg has a strong theater dept. so I wonder if they might have a strong dance program as well – may be worth looking into.
Yes, she will be dancing at either college; we know that Muhlenberg has an amazing dance program; not sure about Bucknell’s but from what we could see it looked strong as well.
If the Muhlenberg vibe felt better, take Bucknell out of consideration. It’s between Vassar and Muhlenberg. If money were no object, I would choose Vassar because of its academics but that’s me.
Muhlenberg and Bucknell definitely have different vibes. Would agree Muhlenberg has the friendlier small feel to it. Since she preferred that feel, and it’s so much cheaper, I say it’s hands down Muhlenberg. Plus as a dance major, it’s not like she’ll get her first job after college and be making crazy high money. Could take a very long time to pay back those loans. Not worth it at all in my opinion. And I think Muhlenberg has a solid reputation, perhaps not ranked as high as Bucknell, but still up there as far as smaller private school in PA. To me it’s a no brainer to go with Muhlenberg.
The real choice is Muhlenberg v. Vassar.
Is Vassar full cost affordable without parental loans? Would it require doable belt-tightening (ie., no new car, no dining out) or would it require to keep fingers crossed for no catastrophe (ie., pray that old car doesn’t drop dead by side of the road and roof doesn’t start leaking again?)
Agree with @MYOS1634- Vassar doesn’t do merit, but they do meet need. Is it affordable?
I agree with the others- Bucknells ‘rank’ isn’t $126,000 better than Muhlenberg- and also agree that the two schools are different enough in ‘feel’ or ‘culture’ that if your daughter clicks better at one than the other I would respect that.
If affordable, Vassar could be worth its cost: https://www.forbes.com/sites/nataliesportelli/2017/04/26/10-expensive-colleges-worth-every-penny-2017/. Based partly on your daughter’s experiences there, Muhlenberg seems like a good fit too, though.
Re #6, it appears that the OP’s daughter has not decided on a major.
Any PHD worth undertaking will be funded.
So, the question becomes, is she serious about getting a master’s in a professional discipline (OT, PT…) or does she want to go to Law School?
If either possibility is nebulous at this point, don’t factor it in.
Questions to ask both colleges:
What kind of extracurriculars are available on campus/near campus to students with dance as a major EC - choregraphy for kids, ballet coaching, MT sub at the HS, shadowing a PT…?