Buying A New (or Used) Car Experience During Supply Chain Shortages

Are these new or used cars?

We have used the same type of guy/service in my area for a number of years now for the used cars we buy.

Hi! We’ve always gotten new cars from him - I know for sure he does purchases and leases - but he may deal in used cars as well? Not sure.

Contact Reid! He is the nicest guy - ask if he has any colleagues in your area. He may not, but I have always found him to be super helpful and friendly, even if he isn’t able to help with what you need.

S19 graduated this year and he is moving away for his first job and we need a car for him.(we have only 1 1/2 weeks!) He is a hestitant driver. Car shopping has been a cluster! I will say that at least the Suburu dealership near me is not upcharging new cars similar to other dealerships. Noone has anything on the lots (at least affordable). Used cars are worse (newer year models needed as Apple Car play is a must). We are looking at leasing as it seems to make the most sense, as we likely will get a great car from a family member in a few years. I have thought about giving him my car, and getting the new one for myself, potentially I could rent for a few months, but I dont think this is getting better soon.!
lots of false advertising abound as well. So frustrated. And the idea of him ubering everywhere in the location he is going is not going to work.

1 Like

Talked w a luxury car salesperson last night. Only 26 pre-owned cars and seven new ones on the lot. Most cars are pre-ordered. EVs and hybrids are hot. Caravan and CarMax are overpaying. For example if this dealership pays $35k off lease, Carvana will pay $38-$39k, change the oil and sell it for $40k. The luxury dealer will do a full inspection/overhaul for $2500 and sell it for $41k.

Dealers are making more money per car but lately the traffic has dropped substantially as people put off big purchases that are nice to have.

2 Likes

I really need a new (or new to me) car. Mine is on its last legs. I really want a hybrid, but the selection in my price range is really scant and I can’t bear to pay thousands over MSRP just because the dealer feels they can charge it. I’m just trying to nurse my car along until things loosen up again, hopefully not longer than next year.

2 Likes

I agree with what you’re saying. I cannot believe how much over-the-top companies were paying to get relatively recent low mileage used cars. We sold two and did very well. But that’ was late last year.

I would think that unless you absolutely had to have a car, most people would just wait until things (and prices) stabilize. People are being cautious these days.

I would assume that CarMax has a huge inventory now that’s not moving.

The benefit is that CarMax has immediate inventory while other lots have very little.

My friend said that his dealership usually received 50+ inquiries over the weekend to work through on Monday. It has recently slowed to around 30.

A few years ago, we bought a low mileage late model Ford Flex. The dealer bought it at auction specifically to sell to me, I was on the phone with him when he was buying it.

We sold it back to them last month. I don’t know what he paid on the auction, but I suspect that when you account for the fact that I gave it to him with bald tires and a $500 (retail) repair that needed done before he could sell it, he probably paid more me more last month than he paid in 2019. I put 50,000 miles on it during the 3 years I owned it.

Someone will pay them more for a car with 70,000 miles than I paid them when the same vehicle only had 20,000. It’s crazy right now.

Grid has been acquired by The Messenger has a chart of CPI index for new and used cars, and also describes some of the reasons for the price increases.

However, it does not mention something else that happened recently, which is that many car companies have discontinued many of their lower cost offerings in the US. Want to buy a Toyota Yaris, Honda Fit, Ford Fiesta or Focus, Chevrolet Sonic or Cruze? Sorry, no longer offered new in the US. So buyers who wanted such cars must either add to the competition in the used car market, or buy more expensive new cars than they preferred.

Interesting. And sad as well.

I’ve owned a Ford Fusion, and currently have 2 Ford Focuses. I’ve had good experiences, and just as importantly have a dealer I trust. But my son just bought a Honda, because Ford doesn’t have a product in that segment anymore.

https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/16/business/used-car-prices/index.html

2 Likes

A luxury car salesman told me that in the fourth quarter CarMax, Carvana, etc. would pay a few thousand more for trade-ins than they could. They wanted inventory and took a hit on margins.

2 Likes

Both of my DC will need to buy cars this fall, so I have been watching prices and hoping they continue to fall!

I hate haggling over car prices. I went to look at a new model at the local dealership, and the dreaded dance started with the salesperson. Nice guy, but clearly not on my side. I decided to give the Costco program a try and it was a better experience. I submitted the make/model I wanted, and the approved dealership reached out to me within minutes. No haggling as it’s a set price for the program. Emailed me the offer. Decent price. Indeed, I asked the local dealership if they’d match it and they said it was too low for them to match. The downside is that the approved dealership was 50 minutes away, but worth the drive. Upfront Costco pricing as promised. I took the car home yesterday.

6 Likes

I have been off and on trying to buy a new car for a year. I thought the Costco program was sort of not in effect because of all of the shortage issues, so I haven’t thought about it in a while. I’m glad you were able to use it and show us that it is still a thing! Congratuations!

1 Like

It depends on the model. Popular cars in short supply are still not available under the program. I happened to choose a model with relatively decent inventory/supply. You might have seen some dealership commercials advertising sales on certain models. The Costco program just joins that process when there is availability, and eliminates the haggling aspect. The dealership was already offering discounts off MSRP, and the Costco price was an even better discount than that.

1 Like

glad to find this thread! need to deal with the dreaded car buying

True, every car I’m looking at would be considered high demand. But good for you. I need to hear hopeful stories like yours!