Hey @scotlandcalling I respect your perspective, but my perception is different. In full disclosure, my D is a student and while I do see @eyemgh being very active, it always felt to me that he tried his best to be upfront, balanced and backing himself with good objective data in everything he said about the school and being respectful on any other poster. As you indicate, there are good things and bad things about any school and a given school can be perfect for one student, while it can be hell for others, and I haven’t seen him ever stating the school is perfect for everyone. In most situations, I did see him asking, in what appeared to me polite way, for specific data when others stated what appeared to facts. To me, with all due respect, the characterization that he is engaging in over-marketing is a stretch, which borders on personal attack.
I find a parent that spend so much time on such a forum, on the manner he is engaging in, very useful for providing the right context.