Hi, my D25 has a list of possible topics - is it possible to get feedback on that list itself from the Essay Feedback group, or only on a completed essay?
The thing is you can’t tell a lot from a topic alone. Pretty much ANY topic can have potential. It’s all about what you DO with the topic.
In the past I have DM’d with students who asked about different essay topics and gave me an outline/gist of how they would approach each. I think that can be useful to help them focus. Don’t know if the Essay Feedback on CC is set up for that, but that may be more helpful in many cases.
I have also PM’d with students to brainstorm ideas before reading a complete essay. I’m happy to help your student if they’d like to PM me.
She can put a request in here FOLLOW These Instructions to Get Essay Help! - College Essays / Essay Feedback - College Confidential Forums
There is no problem asking for help with topics but it would be better to do it through the essay reader request system