Career ending injury - need to redo my entire college list

I’m m hoping someone can help me with my college list. I’m really nervous and not sure if I’m doing it right. Here’s my story

I’m a senior and I go to one of the prep boarding schools in New England. My GPA is 3.4 (I know it’s low). I moved from Cali my junior year and it was a hard move for me. Before my move, my GPA was 3.8. My ACT is 31 (English 30, Math 29, Reading 31 and Science 32). I was a recruited athlete until I suffered my career ending injury. I don’t play anymore and evrything I worked so hard on is now gone. I’ve recovered mentally and emotionally and now focusing on going to a good college!

here are my extra-curriculars:

  • club soccer for 12 years - team captain for 3 years
  • selected for ODP for 3 years and competed for the state
  • Varsity soccer for 3 years until my injury (MVP my sophomore year)
  • major career ending injury my junior year (I don't play anymore... yes it was a tough year!)
  • formed a non profit org to help kids stay off drugs and play after school sports. Funded 40 scholarships through fund raising.
  • organized volunteer events, over 1,000 hours counting all participants

Here’s my school list

FAR REACH
Columbia
Wash u

REACH
BC
Colgate

POSSIBLE
BU
Northeastern
NYU
UCSD
GW

SAFETY ???
Fordham
UCI
USF

By the way, here are some additional info

Female, Asian
Cost is not an issue (luckily, my grandmother pays for my schooling)
Trying to go a school for pre-med that will help me get ready for med school
I’ve been told that I interview very well. My counselor said that I should go to as many interviews as possible

I’m so worried its making me sick! I thought I would have my soccer to help me but now I don’t. I should have studied harder but I was playing for 15 hours a week and doing my community work (it sounds so bad and such an excuse)…

Any advice would be very helpful! Any other colleges I should be thinking about?

Thank you in advance!!!

What is your home state? With your stats, I don’t think you have a chance for your far reaches.

Hi - my home state is MA but one of my parents live in CA and I basically move back and forth between both states. I think my far reaches are basically a lottery! What about my reaches and possibles? Is it a good list?

It is reachy. You might want to add in UMass Amherst. Your only objective for med school is a high GPA. You need a school that helps you achieve that. Your grandma will pay but will that strain her if you are paying a quarter of a million just for undergrad. @NEPatsGirl Chances with those stats and Massachusetts home state.

Don’t be nervous, you’ll do great. Fortunately, there are many, many outstanding schools out there. You have good grades and a strong test score. You have performed at a high level in sports. You have financial resources to pay for school. Those are all great positives, and something to be thankful for.

As for your list, it seems reasonable. Wash U and Columbia in particular are going to be challenges in terms of admissions. Wash U is very stats oriented (see current CC thread) and really wants students to show a strong interest (by visiting). ED helps a lot there too. Acceptance rates are much lower in RD. Columbia is Ivy League and challenging of course.

I think NYU, Colgate, and Northeastern, and maybe BU might be more high matches. Northeastern has sort of famously become much more popular in recent years. But you are certainly a reasonable candidate at all of them and can succeed if you attend.

Your safeties seem like reasonable safeties. The real question: would you be happy to attend them if they were your choices?

Some others that might seem like possibilities to me include Wake Forest. It has a brand-new bio/health sciences research/teaching center in downtown Winston-Salem (Wake Downtown) and great pre-med advising. It does put a lot of weight on grades and interest though. And ED is a definite plus. So it would probably be a reach (especially RD). Also Denison, very beautiful campus not too far from Columbus, OH, a surprisingly (to me) large city with a big time health/medical industry (internship opportunities). I think you could do well there. Also, maybe Oberlin, which is outside Cleveland (a cold but underrated city). I’d think they’d be matches.

http://wakedowntown.wfu.edu

Most importantly, though, be very positive and confident in your applications (and in life). You have a lot going for you. People respond positively to positive people. Admissions reps want positive, confident people on their campuses. They want to know what applicants hope to achieve and what they can bring to the college community. For example, you had a big transition junior year. That’s a challenge. You had a significant injury that impacted a big part of your life. That’s a challenge. You might emphasize overcoming these challenges, and what you learned about yourself in the process. Going to college, after all, is another big transition. Another challenge. Many students don’t navigate it successfully. Colleges want students who they think can overcome the challenges of this transition, and graduate in four years (or so). So focusing on this in a positive way can offer some explanation for the decline in grades and inspire confidence that you will be better prepared for the next phase of your education/life. Good luck!

THank you TTG and Gearmom - really appreciate your advice. I’m writing my essay now - I’m getting mixed advice though. I was thinking of writing about my junior year and how it changed me. But some people I’ve talked to, though they are not experts, say that it’s an old story and no one is interested to hear another sports story. Do,you have any advice on this?

I really feel super lucky that my family can pay for any school that I can get into. They want the best for me and willing to support me! :slight_smile:

@caligirlsd My middle son, now 17, had a career ending (soccer also) sports injury. I know how painful that is. That’s a lot to go through especially emotionally. My youngest is in Massachusetts right now playing with his soccer club team. It is hard all round. Our friend’s daughter lost her college scholarship with a torn Achilles. And they couldn’t afford the school without it. So looking at the glass half full, you can afford college and you will be a better doctor because of what you have gone through. I’m sure grandma would do anything for you but be careful with her finances. Oodles and I mean oodles of doctors graduate with a BS from UMass. They are trying to save for medical school. If grandma is outrageously wealthy, 240k on an undergrad when there is so much more to pay for is fine. It isn’t like business or law where your undergrad status counts. Medical is different. Don’t beat yourself up. You’re doing a great job recovering and will find a school to achieve those goals.

“I don’t play anymore and everything I worked so hard on is now gone. I’ve recovered mentally and emotionally and now focusing on going to a good college!”

I am glad to hear you recovered mentally and emotionally. I agree with TTG. You are a very accomplished person, and will do great.

I like your list. I would substitute Columbia and WUSTL with Cornell, Brown and Michigan.

Cornell’s statutory colleges (Agriculture or Human Ecology in particular) may have interesting majors and they do not require subject tests. For example, the College of Agriculture offers a major in Genetics, Genomics and Development, and another in Biochemistry, and yet another in Microbiology. The College of Human Ecology offers a major in Global and Public Health Sciences and another major in Human Biology, Health and Society and yet another major in Human Development. All of those options are ideal for a premed student.

At the University of Michigan-Ann Arbor, I would check out the School of Kinesiology. They may find your profile very appealing.

As a target, I would check out Wisconsin-Madison. Great school in the life sciences.

I also agree that UMass-Amherst is a great safety for you.

Thank you! I’m adding UMass Amherst and Wake Forest on my list.

Thank you all for your great advice! I was looking at Cornell and even visited the campus. Im going to look st it again, and also U Mich and Brown. Thanks so much Alexandre!!!

In terms of pre-med support, you might want to consider more LACs.

A school or two from the NESCAC, such as Bates, might make good reaches.

Seconding Denison, but as a high match. St. Lawrence might also fit this category.

Wheaton (MA) could be a relatively safer option.

Since you already have two Jesuit schools on your list, add College of the Holy Cross. Excellent for sciences/pre med and they like kids who interview there. GPA may be a tad low, but ACT is a match.
Good luck!

If you are pre-med, you may want to consider Trinity College in CT. They have good med school advising and it may be a match/safety for you.

Since you are at a good prep school, your advisor should have fairly good relationships with many adcoms. She would have a better idea how schools like Colgate, NYU would view your stats. NYU likes wealthy schools who could afford their tuitions. Colgate likes athletes, even for intramural.
I am a bit surprised by your counselor remark about interviews. Most schools do not take interviews into consideration, unless if an applicant completely blows it.
As others have posted, when it comes to med school, it is the GPA that matters. You would be better off in going to an easier school and get higher GPA than to go to higher ranking schools. On the hand, many students change their minds about what they want to do when they go to college, so I would generally advise students not to pick a school over a major (career).

You have CA publics on your list as matches and safeties – is your home state California? If not, those do not make sense financially, even with a relative paying for school, since those med school costs will add up.

Start with your safeties, and build from there. For med school, you want the highest gpa possible plus strong experience in shadowing/research etc. to fill out your application. Your instate public is likely your first safety, unless it is a Michigan, Cal, Virginia, North Carolina. So if you identify your home state (and I apologize if I missed it), that will help folks here identify suggestions for your list.

Wake Forest is a great suggestion, more of a reach than a match. We know pre-med kids there who have gotten the super competitive merit awards, and they have amazing opportunities in terms of research etc. GW and American might be solid matches. U Pittsburgh might be another one. If you will consider small liberal arts colleges, Rhodes is seems to be a strong pre-med school. I seem to recall Skidmore has an exercise science/kinesiology major, which you might find interesting.

I’ve read admissions files for law school, and even there, saw endless variations of either (1) the sports injury which re-defined me and (2) the international travel which showed me that people are people, no matter where they call home. It is very hard to do the sports injury essay in an interesting, compelling way. It is absolutely a big part of you, and perhaps your guidance counselor can address that in their recommendation, about how your focus had to change after the injury. Or it makes a good anecdote to jump off from in an interview. For the Common App essay, think about what you want to communicate about what makes you tick, what kind of person you are. If you are applying to big research universities, it may be your independence and ability to pursue opportunities. If you are applying to smaller schools, where community matters because there are only 1500-2500 students, then maybe its tolerance, open-mindedness, reaching across the “aisle” to collaborate. Then, figure out stories that illustrate the qualities you want to emphasize, and look for a way to connect them.

Congrats to you for moving forward, it must have been a very difficult time.

With a 3.40-3.79 HS GPA (UC recalculated), UCI and UCSD are reaches with 13% and 8% admit rates for 2016 respectively. See http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/what-my-chances/1903428-faq-uc-historical-frosh-admit-rates-by-hs-gpa-p1.html . However, it is disadvantageous to attend a school distant from your state of residency for pre-med, since cross country trips to in-state public medical school interviews will be expensive and inconvenient.

I hope that your recovery from your sports injury is going well, and that you are well in “normal life” even if you can’t do soccer anymore.

I strongly agree with others who have suggested UMass Amherst. It has a very good premed program. This is nearly four years too soon but UMass Worcester is a good medical school also. Also going in-state might help you leave some $$ in the bank for medical school.

I am wondering whether UMass Amherst is a match or a safety. This might depend upon whether your GPA is weighted or unweighted. You might want to consider UMass Lowell as a true safety.

I would be very surprised if you could get into Columbia or Cornell or WUSTL with a 3.4. Do plan on getting a higher GPA in undergrad in order help you get into medical school (obviously your high school GPA won’t matter at that point).

@DadTwoGirls Yeah not sure UMass is a safety. Wanted @NEPatsGirl input. She is already a senior. The GPA is what it is. UMass Lowell is probably a safety but at that point she’d probably prefer an LAC.

Massachusetts home state @Midwestmomofboys

Hi everyone - thanks so much for all your comments. I’d like to answer some of the questions.

I live in MA now, but my dad is in CA and from my research, it seems I can still qualify as a CA resident. We have a home there, I lived there till the end of my sophomore year, and my dad files his taxes there, and I am intending to return there (my bank, my car, my driver’s license and other things are all there). I hope I’m making sense but from what I read, this is how UC defines in state for out of state residents.

I’m working really hard on my essay. I’m not an exceptional writer but not horrible (scored 9 on my ACT writing). I’m going to spend more time with my counselor and get his advice on my essay. My counselor said that I “show” really well, and if a college provides interviews, I should definitely take it as I can expand on myself that may not show on paper. I’ve gone to 3 interviews. i don’t know that it helped, at least I didn’t feel that way.

The other thing I’d like to highlight is that I founded my own non profit. Through talking to people and fund raising edforts, I’ve raised over $75,000 and provided scholarships for kids to play after school club soccer. My club (very respected well know club) wrote a very good recommendation letter for me about how my work was valued and helped kids.

I definitely think Columbia, Cornell and WashU are lotteries - but I would do anything (well almost anything) to be admitted there!!! But I think getting a high GPA is going to be very hard for me which will be needed for med school so it sounds like I should pass on those.

@caligirlsd I’m not sure about that. You will be graduating from a Mass high school. This is an important point and California is very difficult on this. Lots of people hear knowledgeable on California residency. Maybe post another thread titled California residency? How much do you live at your dad’s time wise?

I’m so sorry you had a terrible Junior year, between the move and the injury. That’s very traumatic and I would spend a lot of time on the essay to show how even though you went through this traumatic time, you’ve gained new found resilience. It could be that some of your extra-curricular helped pull you through. If that’s the case, tell them that on the essay. It will show what you’re passionate about. This should help offset your lower grades; without that explanation I’d think the difference in grades is due to the higher expectations of your new BS.

Honestly, I think your 31 is too low for Columbia, Cornell, U Mich and Brown (I’ll call them the Hail Marys). Since you go to an elite BS, I’d hope your GC would be good. Listen to his/her opinion. I see you’ve listed 12 schools, but now you’re getting recommendations for other schools too and it’s going to be tempting to keep adding to your numbers. You need to carefully think how much time you have to devote to this process and carefully limit the number of schools you apply to. My D’s GC said she worries whenever someone applies to more than 10 schools unless some of them don’t have essays/short answers. So if it were me, I’d do 1 Hail Mary (hey, you never know), 2 safeties that I’d visited and really researched to know I’d be fine going there, 2 reaches and the 5 targets.

In looking at your list, I think Wash U, BC and Northeastern might all be reaches: I think BC would ding you for lack of geographic diversity and Northeastern has seen a huge rise in popularity. BU has also come way up in the rankings in recent years, and I wonder if they would ding you because you’re Asian since they have so many international Asian students and I’m sure they want to maintain some ethnic diversity. I also know, though, that some colleges really like kids from certain HS, and that could make a big difference. Your GC would know that. The rest of your possible and safety list looks accurate. But I’m just a parent who has done a ton of research and don’t do this for a living.

On a different note, since you had so many negative things impact you Junior year, I think colleges are going to really look hard at your Senior year grades.

Good luck to you and all the best. Where you go to college isn’t going to be everything. Your positive attitude and ability to readjust are, and you already have that. Be proud of yourself!