Career ending injury - need to redo my entire college list

I think UMass will be a safety depending on major.

Given that you are as a selective BS, your CC is likely to be better able to chance you than the knowledgeable posters here. We can tell you about the environment at the schools you’re considering, etc. , but your CC knows best how your academic record will be viewed at the schools you’re considering.

As for the essay, I would avoid one about the injury but think that something you learned about yourself through the process of addressing the hole it left in your life could be interesting. Remember that AOs most want to know who you are today, and “former elite soccer player” informed that, but that you are undisputedly more interesting than that label alone would imply.

UMass
UVermont - relatively small state school with out of state merit aid and a med school. Very old- “Ivy look and feel”

Small research universities with strong bio/premed and some merit aid
Brandeis
URochester
Tulane

Clark University really more of a LAC with research near UMass medical school in Worcester some merit aid
Wheaton (Norton, Ma.)- cross enrollment with Brown summer research at Harvard MIT Tufts some merit aid

Unfortunately UCI and Fordham wouldn’t be considered safeties with a 3.4, so maybe replace those with cal states?

“UVermont - relatively small state school with out of state merit aid and a med school.”

Very good school. Very nice location. Burlington is a lovely small city. I would think like UMass Amherst a low match but maybe not quite a safety.

“Unfortunately UCI and Fordham wouldn’t be considered safeties with a 3.4, so maybe replace those with cal states?”

The problem with this is that we are not sure whether she is still in-state for California. If she is in-state in California then yes. If not, she might want a safety where she isn’t OOS full pay such as some form of UMass (since she apparently is in-state in Massachusetts).

IMHO she has solid matches. One strategy would be to just go ahead and apply to her most recent list (with or without a few changes). She will probably get in somewhere and probably at more than one school. If not, UMass Lowell is a true safety with her numbers, and will accept applications quite late (up to Feb 1 with the common application, but up to June 1 with their own web application). The odds are very high that she will be in at several schools before May 1. If not, she has May to at least get one last application into UMass Lowell. I really don’t think that it will come to this, but it is a possibility if needed.

DadTwoGirls - can you let me know what you consider solid matches? It doesn’t have to be UC and also I talked to my grandma, and she said she doesn’t care if I’m OOS in CA for tuition. She’s in CA and wants me there more often. I’m her only granddaughter and she wants me close to her. But if I am so lucky to get into the other schools, then she said that’s okay too! Thank you again!!!

More realistic UCs with a 3.4 GPA would be UCM, UCR, and UCSC.

But if you do not have CA residency, the high cost and distance from MA medical school interviews are disadvantageous for a premed.

@caligirlsd Where in California is she? People could work from there for suggestions.

She is in Irvine

I was really hoping for UCI or UCSD or UCLA

I agree with all the suggestions. It is crazy to come to California as an OOS for premed. With ACT 31 and lowish GPA, your chances at those reachey Ivies are slim to none. Better come down to the earth and look at IS public, IMHO, Umass Amherst at the best is a match for you, you need lot more safeties.

“DadTwoGirls - can you let me know what you consider solid matches?”

I think that UMass is a very good school (I toured it twice, with both of my daughters) and that you will probably get accepted. Being in-state it will also be affordable.

I see from Google that the average incoming GPA at Fordham is 3.64. You are a bit below this, but at a very competitive high school and your ACT is higher than their average incoming ACT. Thus I think that it is probably a match.

Someone else suggested UVM. If you add it to your list then it is probably a match. I have visited it several times and it also seems like quite a good school in an attractive location. I see it as academically comparable to UMass Amherst. Getting a merit scholarship might however be a stretch.

I don’t know as much about the California schools. I do agree with others who have said that UCI is probably a reach, but I don’t really know the California schools well enough to have commented.

To me the rest of your list look like reaches. Nothing looks like a true safety.

I think UVM would be a safety for you. I think UMass Amherst would be a bit better for academics though. UVM is a public ivy in a nice college town. I don’t think you’d like UMass Lowell. @MYOS1634 had some good LAC suggestions in #31 We have friends at St. Olaf’s who are very happy. But there must be other California options also.

You need to carefully check CA residency challenges. Read the whole UCOP documents, not just how one or two phrase it.

Even if you maintained the 3.8, Cornell or WUSTL, some others, would be tough reaches. It also matters which courses brought the gpa down. Plus top schools can like premeds to have some sort of hands on vol work with healthcare delivery. And more than just sports in the hs setting.

@caligirlsd Finalize your list first, before deciding on an early application strategy. Some of the schools in your list in post #22 have EA rather than ED.

About the essay. “Most importantly, though, it’s what means the most to you.”

Well, yes, when you submit, you should be satisfied. But since this is for a college admit, “most important” is what it means to adcoms.

Know your targets well enough to know what matters to them.

As for the injury, it’s how you rebounded, somehow went on to make the most, despite the setback. I don’t know that we see this yet, in what OP has told us.

Btw, big fundraising isn’t a tip.

If you go with EA. Please send your app to UMass Amherst by October 15. They had a quick turnaround with the early apps when we applied. It is in a lovely college town. #4 https://www.bestcollegereviews.org/50-best-college-towns-america/ After freshman year, you could get a lovely apartment in Amherst.

And with the 5 college consortium, you can take classes at elite colleges like Amherst https://www.fivecolleges.edu/

Also go ahead and put in the UVM app as a safety. Wealthier kids from our area who can’t get into posh options go there. Should provide a nice experience.

I used to always say to myself - I wish OPs would revert back to their posts to let others reading know the outcome! So here is my post and here is my outcome! I ended up applying to 6 schools out of my original list. I’ve had lots of discussions with my GC and we agreed on this:

NYU - ED
Northeastern - EA
UMass Amherst - EA
USF - EA
Fordham - EA
USD - regular

Most are reaches. I thought to myself that my safeties would be USF and USD. Matches are Fordham and Umass.

I am sooooo happy today! I got accepted to NYU ED!!! I know it was a high match and many would say a reach, but I’m just so incredible lucky and so grateful. My grandma wasn’t too thrilled that I won’t be attending in Cali, but she said it’s a good school so she’s happy for me.

I can’t believe it!

Congrats and thanks for following up!

Thanks - NYU CAS 2022 - OMG! Did it with 31 act and 3.4 GPA… it’s possible!