@caligirlsd I AM SO HAPPY FOR YOU!!! Give your grandma a big hug. Enjoy your new life in NYC. This is so awesome. You’ve been through alot. So glad for you.
Err… Is your grandmother truly a millonaire?
Can she pay this WITHOUT TAKING LOANS?
300k in loans is just crazy and, most importantly, it’s almost certain your grandmother would not qualify all four years, meaning you wouldn’t graduate from NYU and would end up with enormous debt to pay off. I know you’re giddy at being admitted but “don’t worry about it” IS NOT good enough. Yes, you SHOULD worry about such enormous amounts of money because they can sinknypur grandmother if she doesn’t have that amount in investments, bonds, savings, etc. You want to know where thr money will come from - “don’t worry about it” is what well meaning parents tell their kids when they don’t want to burst their proud, happy bubble. Nobody wants to tell their high achieving kid who just got into their dream college…that it’s not going to happen. They hope they’ll find a way. And they look and look but in the spring they come to the conclusion they can’t. Then it’s too late for the kid to apply elsewhere and they have nowhere to go beside a local commuter school or a community college and all people feel horrible. Long time posters will tell you this happens, over and over, every spring, andbirs heart breaking because for six month the kid thought S/he was going to Dream School and the parents were under tremendous stress…and it all falls apart.
What’s your EFC?
You don’t have to accept an ED offer that only contains loans. That financial aid package is so bad it allows you to get out of the ED agreement.
(Typically, this sort of financial package is called an admit/deny: they admit you for academics but deny you financially.)
@caligirlsd : you want to listen to this, too https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/15/podcasts/the-daily/student-loan-debt-licenses.html
@caligirlsd, it sounds like your grandmother understands the cost and has the assets to manage the cost either way, so yes she may be thinking that the interest expense of the Plus Loan is less than the investment potential of those dollars - I know there are a lot of alarms going on this thread, but everyone’s situation is different.
Hi everyone, thanks for all your advice. I know NYU is very expensive and without any scholarships and aid, it just seems so crazy to pay that kind of money. I really love NYU and I visited New York in Oct and knew I wanted to be there. My situation is different. My mom and I live in MA. My dad is in CA. They are not divorced but I guess you could say they live separate lives but still together. I know it’s hard to explain. I go back and forth between states. My grandma pays for my schooling. Sometimes I think it’s because she feels sorry for me coz of my injury.
I had a serious talk with her and asked her if she is really paying for my schooling and all 4years. She said yes, and she will pay for everything.
I know there’s lots of concern here about the cost, but she told me she is not taking any loans and for me to decline the loan offer. She laughlingly said she made a lot of money with a certain company’s stock (the fruit company, starts with A)… I was crying so hard… I feel like the luckiest girl in the world!
@caligirlsd I’m sure grandma wants to pay not because she feels sorry but because she loves you so much. She made money like Forrest Gump did.
Enjoy your time in NYC and make her proud. When a door shuts, a window opens. Congratulations!!!
Your grandmother said she can afford it without loans, but you should decide if you think it is worth it to pay $300,000 for college. Even if it doesn’t cost YOU anything, it’s still a boatload of money to spend on anything - college, house, vacation. It’s a lot of money.
That’s really not true. The PLUS loans do not consider debt to income ratio, so if you qualify for it one year, and your (parent/grandparent’s) financial picture remains the same, it is likely you (parent) will qualify for additional years, even for multiple kids to go through college. To qualify you have to be current on all major debts, not have declared bankruptcy, and not have defaulted on debts. That is as likely to be true in year one as in year four since the PLUS loan is just off to the side, not needing to be paid every month, just growing with interest being added.
Thank you @gearmom and @twoinanddone
@Chembiodad - I just checked my common app application again and ther was no question about whether you are requesting need based aid. I looked at it two time so and this question is not there.
So I’ve been told that the only way you can back out of an ED (not that I’m planning to until @twoinanddone made the comment about spending 300k on a college degree) is if you can demonstrate that you can’t afford it financially. If that’s the case, how do they actually determine that… by your EFC?
@caligirlsd, I think any school would accept your word that upon further review with your parents you’ve determined that its not affordable; if you chose that path, you then can’t pick another $60k+ school to attend as it could get back to them - it’s not likely, but that’s the ethical part of the ED agreement.
@caligirlsd Everyone else is spending 250-280k on private education. NYU is ranked #30 so it is a top school. You may go and change majors and still be at a place with a lot of opportunity. If grandma is a millionaire, this is her gift to you.
Why are we causing havoc with @caligirlsd when she has already been accepted ED to a favorite school and her family has a plan in place to pay?
Very true, for those that have saved for a $250,000+ education and want a big city environment it’s a great option. That said, it would be very hard to beat UCB as an instate if achievable.
YOU determine if you can afford it. If not, you simply tell them that you are not accepting the spot because of financial reasons.
We have friends whose grandparents generously pay tuition and have from K-12 and now for college. They are so lucky. But this grandfather made over $7M per year in salary and I’m sure has stocks and other savings on top of that. They are not spending the retirement money -just a million dollars of it! (but that’s on 6 g’kids).
Really talk this out with your grandmother and parents. Is this an expense your grandmother can (and wants to) afford? There are plenty of good colleges that are cheaper than NYU. Don’t get swept up in the excitement. Think about it, talk about it. It might be the right school for you and your family, but might not be.
^She has already had a serious conversation with grandma who wants to pay and has made money with that A fruit stock.
@Chembiodad - I really think I have a problem with my EFC - is is a bit high, higher than 75k so I think this will be an issue
@Gearmom - thank you. I know many people who are paying full tuition. My dad went to USC and my grandma paid for the entire thing without any loans. Of course back then it was not 50k per year, but it was still a lot of money. I feel guilty taking this much but like you said, this is a gift, and I’m just so grateful. I think she really is genuinely offering it as a gift, because she can afford it and she wants to help me. She always said to me that she wants me to have a good education so I don’t have to rely on my future husband. That I can make it on my own. Maybe she’s looking st my mom. Omg, I hope my mom doesn’t read CC.
@caligirlsd, as a father of DD’s that are both attending a top-LAC, I am happy to pay the full amount as we were fortunate enough to be able to save for it and they both did their part to be able to be accepted. So, be proud about the hard work you’ve done and being accepted to NYU, give your grandma a big hug, and good luck!
Thank you!!! Good night CC
This is excellent. Don’t feel guilty - you got into the school you wanted and your grandmother loves you AND can pay for the school… There’s nothing to feel bad about. (Thank your grandmother many times and with a nice homemade present for the holidays).
I was just making sure you had really talked with your grandmother about actual costs and affordability ‘out of pocket’. You wouldn’t believe how many parents intend on taking loans for their child when they say they can pay, and how many realize too late they can’t/really shouldn’t.
Congratulations

Turn down all the loans and accept your ED admission …then celebrate with your grandmother!
Hi CC - I just thought I would post here again - I’m now at NYU and love it. Thanks to CC and for everyone who replied to my posts and questions. CC helped me a lot.