All 3 are great school which will provide a wonderful education. Given that they can all provide what you are looking for in terms of academics, what school is the best fit for you. Have you visited all of them? Davidson will have the best weather, for sure, and is closer to a city (if that is important to you in terms of activity and coming/going to school). I am familiar with Middlebury - remote and outdoorsy with great access to skiing. A wonderful FL program. I don’t know as much about Carleton, but I think it is somewhat similar to Middlebury in terms of location.
3 Likes