Carleton is strong in political science and philosophy, I believe. Have you tried schools with strong English programs or creative writing? Schools like Grinnell, Wesleyan?
Colorado College, Kenyon College, Mt Holyoke, Macalester (in the Twin Cities) might be a good fit, as well.
For more scholarship aid, you might try schools that are not in the top 40. My son and daughter have loved their time at small liberal arts colleges, getting an excellent education, and earning great scholarships.
Good luck in all you’re doing!