The list is a good start. So Colby and Middlebury you would be full pay (they offer no merit)? Have you run the net price calculators?
Colby and Midd are reaches. Colby has a sub 10% acceptance rate, that is a reach for all…no way chances are 50/50. Midd acceptance rate was in the mid teen’s this year so a reach for all too.
Vermont is a highly likely and she will get merit, the rest are matches.
Lehigh and Colgate have pretty significant Greek Life component to their schools, so not sure those are fits…will you be able to visit?
I would also recommend many of the rest of the NESCACs (all reaches…Bowdoin, Bates, Hamilton, Williams), Bucknell (match…there is Greek Life, but no housing for women so a bit more subdued than you will find at Lehigh), Carleton (reach), Whitman (match), UNH (highly likely), Oberlin (match), Kenyon (match).