Chance for HYPSM + Caltech, Match anywhere. C/O 2027 student from CA, 3.95 UW, 1540 SAT

Demographics (location, residency, HS type, legacy, US or Int’l, gender, etc):

  • US Citizen

  • Southern California public high school

  • Female

  • Class of 2027

Cost Constraints / Budget:

Middle class. I will need scholarships, but I want to apply to anywhere regardless of potential tuition cost, just to see.

Intended Major(s): Biomedical engineering (maybe EE for colleges that don’t have biomed, might change if these majors are too competitive?)

UW GPA, Rank, and Test Scores (also weighted GPA for systems like UC/CSU):
UW: 3.95

W: 4.69 (+1 for AP/CC, +.5 for honors, note about this at the bottom of the post)

Class rank: 1/360 (moving schools next year, so idk how that will work)

SAT: 1540

Community college GPA (so far 24 units): 4.0

Coursework (including planned):

  • English: Honors English 9 and 10 (HS), English Composition (AP Lang equivalent) and Critical Thinking and Composition through Lit (AP Lit equivalent) at CC

  • Math: Honors Math 1, 2, and 3 (HS), Calc/Analytic Geometry I, Calc/Analytic Geometry II, and Linear Algebra at CC

  • Science: Honors Biology and Chemistry, AP Comp Sci P (only 1 semester), AP Biology, AP Chemistry, AP Physics 1(?)

  • History and Social Science: AP European History, AP United States History, AP US Gov and Pol, AP Microeconomics

  • Language other than English: German I (HS), Elementary Chinese at CC

  • Visual or Performing Arts: 3-D Art (HS), History of Photography at CC

  • Other academic courses: Developmental Psychology, Forensic Anthropology, Criminal Justice, and Primate Behavior at CC

Awards:

Basically nothing LOL

Outstanding Witness at County Mock Trial Competition

1st Place Academic Bowl (regional, highest level of competition, not putting real competition name as not to dox myself)

Extracurriculars (incl. summer activities, competitions, volunteering, and work experience):

Science communication club - treasurer, but all of the cabinet pretty much helped out equally/didn’t have very defined roles, very active club. I may write an essay about this

Founded my school’s HOSA chapter - president, but the club was fairly inactive due to advisor issues
Member of my school’s academic bowl team - selective

Worked a seasonal job, averaging 10 hrs/wk for about 8 weeks

Mock Trial team captain/club cabinet

Shadowed a doctor at county hospital (8 hrs/wk, 1 wk)

Some other stuff, but not really worth mentioning

Essays/LORs/Other:

Rec letter from AP Gov teacher/Academic Bowl advisor and a science or math teacher (still finding one).

Schools including Safety, Match, Reach (include ED/EA when applicable):
Not fully sure yet, and unsure how to classify schools as match/reach. Will apply to UCLA, Occidental College, Cal Poly SLO, Cooper Union, and maybe Olin. I want to apply to Caltech (REA), MIT, and Princeton, but I feel like it would be silly given my ECs/awards, so I am looking to be chanced.

Aiming for scholarships, will apply to many external ones to open up the possibilities of where I can go.

Other:

I’m planning on doing independent research using genome databases over the summer. I’m unsure exactly what the project will be yet, but I will start after AP tests are done. My goal is to submit to Regeneron STS, but I don’t have any teacher guidance, so I don’t really think I could do this. Also planning on cold emailing some small LAC professors near me for potential research opportunities, but I don’t see this being very successful. Looking for colleges that would be realistic, given how hard it would be for me to really fix my ECs/awards at this point.

My school does a weird integrated math curriculum, so I couldn’t really get ahead in math at my CC. Will taking Calc/Analytic Geometry I this summer, Calc/Analytic Geometry II in the fall (12th grade), and Linear Algebra in the spring be bad for elite universities compared to other applicants?

Additionally, my school calculates an A- as a 4.0. I didn’t realize until recently that usually an A- is a 3.7 (I know, dumb), so now I have 5 A- on my transcript. Does this limit where I should apply, or are there any ways to meaningfully improve my application?

Sorry if some things were long or redundant, this is my first post on here! Thank you!

1 Like
  1. Do not apply to colleges without taking affordability into account. Run net price calculators.

  2. Why not apply to a couple of hyper-competitive colleges? They are a reach for any unhooked applicant but take your shot. Worst case, you never have to wonder “what if.”

4 Likes

How many years of a single language have you taken? This could be an issue at many schools. I believe UCLA requires at least two years of the same language with three recommended. Please consider taking an additional year of FL in senior year.

8 Likes

I agree your non-native language path as planned might be an issue. I would also make a point of taking some Physics.

I also agree you would be well-advised to have a realistic affordability plan. I see too many kids spend a lot of time and energy on applications where it was never going to be possible to attend.

And realistically, significant outside scholarships are extremely hard to obtain. But if you can tell us your actual all-in budget, and report the results from some NPCs, we can help you come up with some options.

5 Likes

No point in applying if the net price calculator shows unaffordability at these schools that offer only need-based financial aid.

9 Likes

First semester foreign language at California community colleges is generally considered equivalent to high school year 2 for UC/CSU purposes. Second semester foreign language at California community colleges is generally considered equivalent to high school year 3 for UC/CSU purposes. This is based on the UC Doorways web site.

Other colleges may interpret equivalency differently for what they want to see for foreign language study by frosh applicants.

3 Likes

Kind of a bad strategy. What if you don’t get in anywhere affordable? It’s a lot of effort for finding out - I can’t go.

I think you need to do more research. How will Occidental help you meet your goals?

With a year of German and Chinese, I’m guessing the top are out of reach. But so what? You need an ABET accredited school, not the best perceived name.

It’s very possible you will get shut out on this list.

There’s 200 bio engineering programs accredited by ABET. Figure out your budget and find schools to fit.

What is the split between Math and English parts of the SAT?

MIT does not have merit based aid, and does not have athletic scholarships. I am pretty sure that Stanford similarly does not have merit based aid, but does have some athletic scholarships, and that the rest of HYPSM is the same as MIT in this regard. These five schools all have pretty good need based aid, but only if you qualify for it.

Have you run the NPCs, or had your parents run the NPCs, for these highly ranked and highly selective (some might say “rejective”) schools?

MIT does not admit by major. If you are admitted, then they use your intended major to match you to a freshman year advisor. At the end of your freshman year you pick any major that you want and they reassign you to an academic advisor in your major, but you can still change your major (and therefore advisor) later if you want to (you just need to complete the academic requirements for whatever major you eventually end up with before you can graduate). I was under the impression that Harvard, Yale, Princeton, and Stanford were the same in this regard.

Assuming that you are in-state in California, then you have a lot of VERY good in-state public universities. You should definitely apply to multiple of them, and should probably make sure that you apply to a safety that is an affordable in-state public university.

I would be most concerned that you do very well in whatever math classes you take, and get a solid basis in math. Jumping ahead is really not necessary. It sounds like you are already way ahead, and you do not need to get even further ahead. I did not take calculus until my freshman year of university, and this did not stop me from getting my bachelor’s degree in mathematics from MIT (although admittedly this was a long time ago). If you have already had multi-variate calculus, then I will point out that high school algebra and calculus (including multi-variate calculus) are very useful for a LOT of future classes both in math and in other areas (physics being one obvious field that uses a lot of math). These along with probability theory are things that I have used a LOT on the job as well. These are worth taking the time to learn very well, although both calculus and probability theory are things that you can learn after you get to university.

I will assume that “Chinese” means “Mandarin”. Is this a native language for your family, or a foreign language for you and your family?

I would hope that the “?” does not mean anything. You will need high school physics and more physics in university for any type of engineering. You will need quite a lot of physics if you want to major in EE. Physics is definitely something that you should take in high school.

One week does not really count for much. Is there any chance that you might want to be premed? Alternately, did you shadow for one week and figure out that this is not the path for you and you want to do something else? If the latter then this is perfectly okay — there are a lot of different careers that are possible and medical school is a career path which is long, difficult, tough, expensive, and something that is only appropriate for students who are strongly drawn to it.

Outside scholarships are often quite small. In some cases it is an honor to get one, but they often do not really make much difference in terms of being able to afford to attend an expensive private or out of state university.

However, you might also want to just be aware that it is relatively common, for those students who attend some form of graduate school, for students to change university when going to graduate school. It is not unusual at all for a very strong student to “switch upwards” in the sense of attending an undergraduate university that might or might not be ranked in the top 100 or maybe 200, but to then go to a highly ranked university for graduate school. I know multiple people who have done this, and used to know a lot more when I was a graduate student. Just as one example, when I was a graduate student I knew a lot of people who had gotten their bachelor’s degree at an affordable in-state public university, and who then went for (and as far as I know got) a one-year master’s degree at a famous highly ranked private university.

Generally speaking for an undergraduate education finding a college or university that is a good fit for you is much more important compared to attending a highly ranked university. Of course finding a “good fit” is not always an easy thing to do. It can be a good idea to visit a few schools, and then think about what you want in a school, then visit some more. My daughters started by visiting universities that were near where we live, but this is just because visiting somewhere nearby is easier when you are first starting the process. We did eventually visit some schools that were somewhat further away (eg, requiring an overnight stay). Visiting a range of schools however I think helped both daughters a lot by helping them think about what they wanted in a university.

Best wishes. It seems to me that you are a very strong student and could do very well at any one of a long list of universities.

2 Likes

760 EBRW and 780 Math.

Sorry, I should’ve clarified about the physics thing. The highest level of physics my high school offers is AP Physics 1, but I’m worried this won’t be good enough for elite universities. I’m going to take at least AP Physics 1 no matter what, but I’m looking at maybe taking 2 courses that would be the equivalent of AP Physics 2. Unsure if Physics 1 vs. Physics 2 really looks that different to admissions committees.

I did some Net Price Calculators, and most of the schools I mentioned would be within my budget, except maybe Occidental (which I was thinking about due to its small size and 3-2 engineering program). UCs are definitely within my budget because I’m in-state as well as Cal Poly SLO, and I’ve already talked with my school’s college counselor about the prices. The net price calculators for all of the other out-of-state schools look pretty reasonable, but I’m not 100% sure yet because I haven’t talked about it with my school’s college counselor, and those schools have a reputation for being pretty expensive.

I’m not ahead in math yet, but I would be getting ahead in senior year if I follow my plan to take certain math classes at the college so I can take linear algebra this spring semester. I could choose to just take AP Calc BC at my high school.

Yes, the Chinese course is listed that way on my transcript, but it is Mandarin. It is a foreign language for me, and they just added a second course at my college, so I could take it for third-year language credit to be safe for schools that require 3 years of language. I’m in the process of researching which schools require this to see if it would pay off to take this course instead of another STEM course.

Yeah, I figured out that pre-med isn’t for me by shadowing. It seems very emotionally difficult, and I do not want to be in that much debt and have so much stress applying for med school and residency.

Thank you for mentioning this about grad school! I got into UCSB this year because I thought I wanted to graduate early, but I was worried about my chances of going to a prestigious school for a potential PhD if I went to UCSB. What you said about students going from an undergraduate university not in the top 100 to then going to a highly ranked university for graduate school was very reassuring. I really appreciate it.

The Mandarin course I took at my community college counts for 2 years, at least for public California universities. Thank you for bringing this up though, I will have to check if it counts for the same credit at OOS universities.

1 Like

Are you saying that both your current school, as well as your new school, only offer Physics 1?

Are you going to graduate early and start taking classes at community college or are you changing to another HS?

This is true, I agree that there are a ton of great schools that aren’t the most well known names! My parents definitely pressure me to go to the most prestigious university possible, so that’s one of the reasons I am worrying so much about the perceived name. Thank you so much for the link to ABET accredited programs! I will be sure to apply to many affordable safety/match universities on this list.

Yes, my current school and new school are in the same district and both only offer AP Physics 1. I tried to transfer out of the district to go to a better school, but transportation isn’t feasible. I’m changing to another high school, not planning on early graduation anymore.

1 Like

Thanks for the clarification.

Thank you! I should’ve clarified on the question mark next to the physics course. The highest my school offers is AP Physics 1, so I’m trying to decide if I just take that or if I should take 2 courses that would be the equivalent of the AP Physics 2. It seems it would probably be better payoff to take another language course to get me to 3 years of foreign language (1 CCC language course = 2 years, the second course adds a year I believe). As for affordability, I got into UCSB this year because I thought I was gonna graduate a year early, but I decided to stay another year to try to get into more colleges. UCSB would be around $26k per year, and my parents and agreed that it would be manageable. We could probably do a bit more than that, but generally in that range. I did some NPCs, and it seems that most of the universities I mentioned in the post were somewhat realistic prices, aside from Occidental. Unless I’m missing something major which is possible because those colleges are known for being super expensive, lol.

I was waitlisted at UCLA this year, but I will probably take another language course to boost it to 3 years of the same language to be more competitive next year. Thank you for the insight!

I definitely still need to review some of the NPCs with my school’s college counselor and my parents, but it seems like most of the colleges I mentioned in the post were within my budget because of aid. Although it’s definitely confusing because many of the ones I checked have reputations for being extremely expensive, so I will be sure to triple check that!

And this is true, thank you! I guess I’m just scared of seeming crazy to the people who are writing my LORs since they can see where I’m applying, lol

Were you admitted to UCSB’s College of Engineering and waitlisted for UCLA’s College of Engineering?

Did you apply to other UCs or CSUs this year? If so, what were the results? Those results will give us an idea of how strong your application is.

This is very good. I think that the median math score for Caltech, MIT, and Stanford is probably 790. I would be mildly surprised if anywhere is higher than that, and expect that there are are most a tiny, tiny handful of schools that are the same.

I think that it is fine. Elite universities do not expect you to fix your high school. Excelling in the toughest classes that your high school offers is what is expected by the most selective schools.

One issue that I see with HYPSM + Caltech is that there are so many very highly qualified candidates for very few spots, and admissions is not strictly 100% based on academics. It is very hard to predict a student’s chances at these schools other than “you are academically qualified, just like 80% of the other applicants”. Of course they are also expensive unless you qualify for need based aid. I think that you should make sure that they are a good fit for you before you attend one of these top schools. More important is probably keeping in mind that you do not need to attend a famous highly ranked school for your bachelor’s in order to either do very well in life or to attend a top school for a graduate program (or both).

You figured this out early. Good for you!

I would be very cautious about jumping ahead. Math is useful and important in so many different areas that it is worth the time to learn it very well. Taking Calc BC in high school is still pretty advanced. You will get plenty of chances to use Calc BC once you get to university.

By the way one daughter due to some scheduling oddity ended up taking both “physics without calculus” and “physics with calculus” at different times. She definitely preferred the physics with calculus. There are a number of areas where calculus helps to make physics more understandable (and calculus was originally developed to help with physics calculations).

I could give a lot of examples of this, but will try to restrain myself.

A different but perhaps vaguely related issue is that in choosing a grad school, both fit and the very specific subject that you want to major in and do research in can impact the choice of which school is the best fit. It is not just math versus biology versus physics. It could be as specific as research into one disease versus research into a different disease, or estuary biology versus great lakes biology versus desert biology. I have not specifically looked into graduate programs in biomedical engineering, but I would not be surprised if different top schools had slightly different focuses, implying different sub-areas where each is particularly strong. This is a long time into the future, but when (if?) you get to the point of thinking about graduate programs you might want to look in detail at what sorts of research is going on in your field in each university that you are considering.

Admitted to UCSB for pre-bio, so not very selective. Waitlisted for Microbiology, Immunology, and Molecular Genetics at UCLA. Waitlisted at UCI for pre-bio, I believe. Didn’t apply for engineering at these schools because I hadn’t taken calculus at the time of applying, and there was no way I’d get in without calculus. Rejected from Cal Poly SLO for materials engineering because again, no calculus, and I wasn’t maxed out for many areas at the time of applying. Accepted at safeties - Cal Poly Pomona for biotech and a local LAC with a high acceptance rate for biology (won’t say the name as not to dox myself). One of my biggest weaknesses was the fact that at UCs and maybe CSUs(?) don’t look at freshman year grads, so I only had a year of grades for them to look at. Also, I obviously wasn’t maxed out on courses yet, and my ECs aren’t good. Honestly, my whole application was my weakness lol. Definitely learned from this admissions cycle to apply for way more schools, as my school’s college counselor and many others have told me. That is why I mentioned applying for schools regardless of NPC results, however I now see why that isn’t a great idea.

1 Like