So - if you can afford it (I’m assuming without aid), you should go see it, talk to people - it’s great you’ve researched but until you touch it, you can’t know.
Also, your reason for applying to BC is not a good reason to apply ED - because you think you won’t get into others.
You should apply ED to the school you want to go to!! If you’re not 100% sold, I would not apply ED.
If you think you won’t get in to the others, why apply to them? You will definitely get into IU and likely Kelley. And Nova.
You have such an eclectic mix - I’d figure out - what do you really want - size, location, etc. Middlebury and Michigan - tiny in the middle of nowhere vs. huge in the midst of action.