Chance me for Colleges :) [TX resident, 3.94GPA, 1510 SAT, top 10%, $15-20k, poli sci]

TAMU has admitted the OP and is affordable, so it is assured.

Minnesota has admitted the OP, but the OP says unlikely (scholarship results have not been given yet).

UT Austin is generally considered a reach for those who do not get automatic admission (the OP is outside of the top 6%).

OP doesn’t really like TAMU, and Minnesota, at present, does not appear affordable. I think it’s important that we find a school that OP would like to attend for four years that would be affordable and an extremely likely admit.

1 Like

Okay. Interesting idea from St. Johns’. I guess my main question is job outcomes? I suspect I would greatly enjoy a curriculum like that, but I doubt a degree in philosophy will be attractive to potential employers. I’m not really familiar with the types of qualifications necessary to work in government, and assume that a political science/administration degree would he preferred.

Yes I can find my transcript. I’ll copy it over when I have access to a computer.

My main priority is a small to medium sized school in a city larger than my current home (c.120000). I’d like to move north if possible, but am also open to pretty much anywhere else.

Why 10-12? What about that number makes it special.

I’m also leaning away from only highly selective schools right now because I don’t want to be limited to, you know, maybe 1 (probably zero) highly selective schools and TAMU.

Have you tried their NPCs? I note NCES data seems to suggest they can both get down to a total net price of around $20K, and they both have merit as well. Seems a shame not to give them a real shot since they seem so perfect for you otherwise.

I agree about colleges like Richmond, Denver, and Macalester too, incidentally. They seem on target as well.

10-12 is generally recommended because of the amount of work that goes into each application.

Each application usually comes with its own set of supplemental essays you need to both draft and edit before the deadline hits. Depending on the schools, you may be able to re-use some of them, but dont bank on that.

In addition, you’re going to be both juggling HS schoolwork during the first semester of the Senior year as well as college applications. Keep in mind that for selective universities, they often require a Mid-year transcript to ensure that your academics dont fall off at the end of HS.

10-12 generally offers the best intersection of having not too many applications to work on, while still having a good spread of options. This is, of course, not a requirement. I know people who were content on applying to 4, and one who applied to 35.

Something else to consider are costs. College Applications, unless they’re already free or you obtain a fee waiver, can cost upwards of $75. For those applying to many schools, the costs can be pretty high.

4 Likes

I’ll look into the NPCs there.

Ok. Thanks for the advice!

7th grade
1 year of physical science
1 year of Alg 1
1 year of band
8th grade
1 year of biology
1 year of geometry
1 year of spanish
.5 year of World Geography???
1 year of Jazz Band
9th grade (move to texas)
Adv Chemistry
Adv Span 2
Engineering
Debate 1
Adv Alg 2
Band
Adv Eng 1
10th grade
Ap Phys 1 (4)
Adv Precal
Ap World Hist (4)
Track (no credit)
Adv English II
Band 2
Adv Debate II
11th grade
Adv Debate III
Adv Band
Jazz Band
AP Lang (5)
AP Bio (5)
AP USH (4)
AP Calc AB (4)
12th grade (this year)
AP stats (4/5)
AP Lit (likely 5)
AP gov/econ (likely 4)
Band IV adv
Debate IV adv
(Would have added more classes if I wasn’t planning on going into music at the beginning of this year)

For anyone else who was having formatting issues with the transcript, I’ve entered it as a table here.

English Math Science Social Studies Foreign Language Other
7th Algebra I Physical Science Band
8th Geometry Biology 0.5 World Geography Spanish I Jazz Band
9th Adv. English I Adv. Algebra II Adv. Chemistry Adv. Spanish II Engineering, Debate, Band
10th Adv. English II Adv. Precalc AP Physics I (4) AP World History (4) Track, Band, Adv. Debate
11th AP Language (5) AP Calc AB (4) AP Bio (5) AP US History (4) Debate, Band, Jazz Band
12th AP Lit AP Stats AP Gov/Econ Band, Debate

@jameshawkings, are you SURE that physical science, biology, and world geography are being counted as high school classes? Typically, I’ve only seen English, math, and foreign language as receiving high school credits in middle school. But there are lots of systems out there, but this is something you need to be crystal clear on.

By my counts (edited after clarification from your post), you’ll have:

  • English: 4 units (2 of which are AP)

  • Math: 6 units (2 of which are AP)

  • Science: 5 units (2 of which are AP)

  • Social Studies: 3.5 units (3 of which are AP)

  • Foreign Language: 2 units

ETA: But @Mwfan1921 indicated, some highly rejective colleges will not count some of the coursework in middle school, so the above tallies are the best that could be considered, but may not be how all schools will tally your credits.

2 Likes

My school district, and Texas public unis, count both years of my science. (Freshman biology is a graduation requirement here, so if it didn’t count I would be cooked.) I’m not sure about each specific college out of state.

I am taking .5 AP Gov/.5 AP Econ.

Those classes show up on my transcript, so if they’re not counted as HS classes, I’m not sure why they’re on my transcript. (Thank you so much, by the way. I’m very confused​:bangbang::bangbang:)

Thanks for clarifying. I’ve updated my post as a result of your comments.

If it’s on your high school transcript, most colleges will count them as credits taken.

You don’t seem that confused to me; you’re doing really well through this process!

1 Like

Even if they are on your transcript, some colleges won’t consider them as core courses taken in HS.

For example, the highly selective college where I read apps won’t consider those as core courses in HS (outside of FL.)

So, for example, in that eval, you would have 4 years of english, 4 of math (accelerated noted, but also noted took the ‘easy’ choice senior year with AP stats, assuming calc BC or some other higher level math was available to you at your HS or thru DE/online HS), 3 of lab science, 3 of SS, 2 FL. All of the band are elective courses, and your senior year course load is quite light.

Different colleges are going to vary as to how they evaluate your transcript. I don’t know many colleges that would consider 7th grade phys sci, 8th grade bio or world geography as HS courses.

You can’t change much of this at this point, unless you were to add say a Spanish 3 dual enrollment class this spring semester (something I would encourage you to think about but it won’t be easy having not had Spanish 2 since freshman year.) Would that help at some highly selective schools? Probably, of course we can’t know if that would be the difference between an acceptance or denial.

2 Likes

How significantly will this impact college decisions, in your opinion?

Additionally, this conflicts with what @AustenNut said about admissions policies.

With that in mind, what would you recommend I do?

Yield to @Mwfan1921’s knowledge, though I did update my language to say “most” colleges.

1 Like

I guess I’m left asking, where does my “light” course load leave me? I could have handled more if my counselors had recommended it. I didn’t really understand what would be important to a college AO at all before this year; nobody had explained any of it to me.

It will be difficult to compete with students who have 4 years of courses in each of the 5 core subject areas, and who have full academic loads senior year at the more selective schools. The competition is fierce. Academically there’s not much you can do now. Maybe adding Span 3 DE if that could work, but
again that could be hard after not having had spanish for 3 years. I do want to reiterate that not all schools will be as harsh as my eval, but some will be
and the downside is it’s difficult, sometimes impossible, to know how a given school evaluates transcripts.

If you want another affordable choice in addition to TAMU (which is a great option to have!), look at Ole Miss as discussed above (some other highly likely schools could also work, but Ole Miss is really strong in your major.)

Definitely still put some apps in at schools that look to be affordable based on NPCs.

I don’t know if any non-meet full need schools can get in price range for you
but you can try a couple of those too (e.g., GWU, American, Richmond, Denver, Macalester, etc). Some schools have full tuition awards (also mentioned above)
The issue is that those awards are all uber competitive, so make those schools reaches/high reaches too.

Lastly, you might consider mentioning that you were thinking that music would be your future major and that coupled with the change of high schools, this impacted your ability to take more core academic classes. You could put this in the box explaining the reason for your school change, see below. You could also ask your counselor to mention this in their LoR/report, if they are amenable to it.

2 Likes

Let me preface this by saying that I am NOT a college admissions professional. I am a parent who works in the education field who finds colleges an interesting topic. With respect to college admissions, particularly at highly selective colleges, I yield to experts like @Mwfan1921 and would strongly urge you to do the same.

Most colleges accept most of their applicants. It just so happens that the bulk of the schools that you had on your list are among the small minority of schools that receive far more qualified applicants than they can accept. There’s a reason why some people call them highly rejective schools.

I suspect that your “light” courseload will probably have the greatest impact on schools with sub-20% admission rates. It might have an impact on schools in the “lower probability” category, but it might not. And I suspect that it will have minimal impact on admissions at any school that would be a “toss-up” or likelier school. But again, these are just my guesses.

Based on some of the additional information you’ve shared (including the strong interest in music), I have sorted the list of schools based on my guesses as to what your chances for admission might be (not necessarily hitting budget) and bolded the schools that I think might be among the better fits. (Also, realize this bolding is from an internet stranger. If a school I didn’t bold interests you, there is no reason not to consider it!) The lower the likelihood of admission, the lower the odds of receiving significant merit aid (i.e. to get to your budget via merit aid).

Extremely Likely (80-99+%)

  • Butler (IN): About 4400 undergrads and also has a strong music program

  • Drake (IA): About 2800 undergrads and also has a good music program

  • Hendrix (AR): About 1100 undergrads

  • Millsaps (MS): About 600 undergrads

  • Oglethorpe (GA): About 1500 undergrads

  • Ohio Wesleyan: About 1400 undergrads

  • St. Edward’s (TX): About 2800 undergrads

  • St. John’s: About 500 in MD and about 400 in NM

  • Suffolk (MA): About 4400 undergrads

  • U. of Denver (CO): About 6200 undergrads and also has a strong music program

Likely (60-79%)

  • Gettysburg (PA ): About 2200 undergrads and also has a strong music program

  • Providence: About 4k undergrads

  • Southwestern (TX): About 1500 undergrads

Toss-Up (40-59%)

  • American (D.C.): About 7900 undergrads

  • Dickinson (PA ): About 2100 undergrads

  • George Washington (D.C.): About 11k undergrads

  • Trinity College (CT): About 2200 undergrads

  • Trinity U. (TX): About 2500 undergrads

Lower Probability (20-39%)

  • Denison (OH): About 2400 undergrads

  • Macalester (MN): About 2200 undergrads

  • U. of Richmond: About 3100 undergrads

Low Probability (less than 20%)

  • Brown (RI): About 7600 undergrads
3 Likes

I don’t think my school offers DE spanish, and I’m not sure that it would be possible to take it. They offer Spanish 3 as a class, I could have taken it but I chose not to (
 to practice instead)

It’s hard both because my parents are convinced I’ll get into any school I apply to, and are reluctant to encourage applying to schools they deem as lower (i.e. that they haven’t heard of before).

I’ll enter something about that on my common app later. Thanks for the tip.

Given my lack of rigor, what would be realistic schools to apply to? What would be made unrealistic? Are LAC’s still in the equation?

Thanks for the honesty, I needed someone to tell me this

1 Like