Chance me for t20s: Current junior, NC resident, 3.89 UW, 1540 SAT, 35 ACT, Engineering [low income, applying for Questbridge]

I’m genuinely asking. I’ve seen it repeated here often. Perhaps this question needs it’s own thread.

1 Like

Agreed. FWIW, the school where I work doesn’t care so much…it’s hard to sort thru the heritage speaking issue. Even if the student says they are fluent in X language on the common app and then took that lang in HS, that would not be held against the student. Even if a heritage speaker, the student/family might not regularly speak that language at home to take one example.

For OP, they could reach out and ask this question of some admissions folks (as well as their HS counselor.)

Our son is a heritage speaker but he originally couldn’t write it or read it well. His elder sibling sisters were a bit stronger in Spanish skills.
When I went to high school, Heritage speakers were not allowed to take the home language, so I learned French.

My son didn’t even want to attempt French. He basically took a “Spanish for heritage speakers” course, but the courses were tougher than the “regular” Spanish courses. From what I understand the counselors describe these courses in the additional comments action as being extremely tough.

A large number of California students are in this position of home languages and the private and public universities in California realize this.

Our son took four years of Spanish and took the AP test. He was required to do some intensive reading in Spanish. This includes writers like Miguel de Cervantes, as well as historical interpretations of architectural readings and writings from Gaudi, plus a number of poets like Garcia Lorca. These were not easy courses.

If you’re looking to apply to the most exclusive schools in this country, then you need to include rigor.

Our son was accepted by every school where he applied including Caltech which he attended. No we didn’t qualify for Questbridge.

He was fortunate because he had an amazing counseling team who strongly encouraged their students to surpass the minimum requirements.

The students had to first meet the high school diploma requirements and they were strongly advised to meet the requirements set by the UC schools in our state. They informed the students that when the universities said: “recommended”, it meant “required” if you wanted any chance of getting in.

Just my two cents.
Make sure you and your parent check the net price calculators on all of these schools because for some you really may have to pay full fees.

My daughter’s best friend is a heritage speaker, her mom and grandparents are fluid. She was put in a heritage class that my daughter wanted to take, but was denied. Today my daughter is pretty fluent (went past AP Spanish, seal of biliteracy, is a PT and doesn’t need an interpreter), her friend isn’t (I know her mom is disappointed, she’s one of my best friends). I think heritage classes are a good thing.

1 Like

My own opinion is that holistic admissions means there is not an unshakable standard for all with no wiggle room. I expect selective schools will weigh the kid in a single parent low income home, working several jobs differently than the affluent kid with two parents from Scarsdale. In other words they will cut the first kid some slack. Of course they will! Otherwise that low income kid just could not compete. How much slack they will cut none of us knows.

2 Likes

I love that your daughter took on such a challenge and did well. I envy the European countries who have kids speaking fluent Spanish, French, German, and Italian!

I think that the heritage classes are a good idea but a number of those courses have students who don’t have strong backgrounds in English literature and that hurts them when they’re learning Spanish literature and content. I think they’re extremely tough!

I took a conversational Spanish class in college. Big mistake! I didn’t realize how hard the list of novels required would challenge me so much that I had to drop out. It was easier for me to take a college French class than to stay in a heritage conversational Spanish class!

OP, please increase your coursework in Spanish. Some of these schools will require additional foreign language coursework in order to graduate from that college.

I know that at my daughter‘s UC, if you were in STEM-related majors, you had to meet a foreign language requirement to graduate and it was tougher at the college, than the high school! Her roommates, in engineering, were bemoaning the foreign language requirement.

1 Like

Wouldn’t questbridge give a full ride if OP is selected?

1 Like

Questbridge partners provide need based aid only (generally, some do give the $2K NMF award, for example), so OP still has to run the NPCs to make sure those consider OP low income/low SAI/low asset (the vast majority of QB matched students have SAI -1500 and minimal assets.) I posted the QB financial guidelines above that OP should share with their parents. Note that QB does not provide scholarship money, all the financial aid comes from the QB partner schools.

I think your parent (or parents, I’m not sure) is cushioning the blow. I think affordability is going to be the primary issue for you. You really need to focus on those net price calculators. Your profile is terrific, and it wouldn’t shock me at all if you get accepted by a very selective university. It is better not to apply than to get your heart broken by getting into a school like that without being able to afford it.

2 Likes

What about this?

I’m not sure your point, that’s the scholarship I was talking about above…for QB applicants who become finalists and who match to one of the colleges (as selected by the colleges.) As that page you linked says, the financial aid comes from the colleges.

1 Like

From the page for the Match Scholarship:

The Match Scholarship covers the full cost of attendance

I take this to mean that every recipient gets a full ride (i.e. 0 EFC financial aid package), but I could be wrong

1 Like

There is variability among the FA packages that each QB partner awards a matched finalist…all the information is on the QB website.

Keep in mind the vast majority of matched finalists are pell grant qualifiers, so whether QB or not, if these low income students are accepted to a meets-full-need school they students will usually receive a ‘full ride’ covering tuition, fees, room and board. Some QB partners will cover books, personal expenses, health insurance, and/or travel for QB matched finalists. Some won’t.

Some QB partners can require (again talking only matched finalists) work-study, a student contribution from summer work, a student contribution from the student’s savings and/or the direct federal student loan. Some people would say an FA package that includes those items is not a ‘full ride’.

OP has to look on the FA page for each QB partner they rank to see their FA policy. Outside of QB and their matched finalist FA package, OP has to run the NPCs at each school on their list. If NPCs don’t show a ‘full ride’ or very close to it, they may not be a candidate for QB.

Here’s BC’s QB matched finalist FA page:

And MIT’s:

4 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.