My DD had similar stats and loved both Wash U and Northwestern. She ended up at Vanderbilt, and loves it! I would consider adding Vandy to your list. Vanderbilt gives fantastic financial aid and there are a number of scholarships available. Finances played a role in my DD decision, she got a great offer from Vanderbilt, but ultimately can not imagine herself anywhere else. It is similar to both Wash U and Northwestern in size and urban/suburban location. Nashville is a vibrant city, the student body is diverse, it does not have a typical southern feel, the campus is gorgeous and climate is mild.