What math&science are you taking senior year?
Have you run the NPCs on these colleges?
Here’s Umiami’s NPC
Is the university affordable? If so, applying ED will maximize your chances. Otherwise, apply EA. It’s a reach Btw.
Have you heard from FIU yet? (Assuming you applied EA/priority). Don’t forget the Honors application opens Dec 12. Definitely apply even if you’re waiting for decisions.
Include USF, good for premeds.
In Florida, Eckerd also has strong science majors.
American is a low reach, perhaps a target if you apply for Public Health (Medical Science track) + Italian minor.
https://www.american.edu/media/news/090518-Abramson-Gift-Hall-of-Science.cfm
https://www.american.edu/cas/health/public/bs.cfm
F&M is a reach.
I would add Dickinson, which would value your Italian skills and complete the premed program..