oh wow swim and math club ?? its not like 2000 other ED applicants have the exact same ECs and better because these are literally the most basic ECs anyone can have. at my school you can join the swim team by just asking, and yes it counts a varsity letter too
the stats are good, even great sure, but thats not what gets you into an ivy league. ok i don’t know his story but how possible good can it be when there is nothing here of substance besides his stats?