Civil Engineering: UMICH vs GeorgiaTech vs. CMU

I can’t really decide on these three schools. People around our giving me different opinions…

  1. They are all good choices, so there is no 'wrong' decision, but...
  2. ...debt is the gift that keeps on taking- for years. The easiest cut is 'which one leaves me the least amount of debt?' Pick that one (and tell everyone who second guesses you that you would be happy to take their advice if they will take on the debt that goes with it. seriously).
  3. If none of them leave debt (b/c your parents can pay for it all without pain) or all of them leave a similar amount of debt, have you visited any/all of them? If so, did you you feel an affinity for any one of them? if so, trust your gut and choose that one (humans typically do best when they are in a place that they feel suits them) (and tell everyone who second guesses you that it is the right school *for you* and that they can follow their own advice for themselves. seriously.)
  4. If finances are neutral, and you either can't visit them all or visited them all and still have no preference, do any of them have a particular feature that you like, such as: an exciting apprenticeship term? the ability to either wait before you pick a specialty or the ability to go straight into your specialty area? near or far from a region that you like/don't like. That's your tie-breaker.

All the other stuff is, for you at this stage, noise. All 3 are top-notch engineering programs, all 3 will open similar doors, all 3 will have similar ‘prestige’ perceptions.

I think for engineering any of these would be fantastic…
So think about:

  1. Net Cost …which is the cheapest?
  2. Geographic location - Michigan is pretty north and GT is more south
  3. City/Urban/Rural…CMU is in a city…what about the others?
  4. School Spirit: Do you like the rah rah of a big football team
  5. Where would you like to work when you graduate?
  6. Look at the “first destination survey” that shows how many graduates get jobs/their salaries
  7. Are you a homebody? Would you like to be nearer where your family is?
  8. Transportation: How would you get home?
  9. Surrounding area - what is the nearby town/amenities like?
  10. Greek life - what % is in greek life? Is that good/bad for you?
  11. Housing - how easy is it to get it for 4 years?

I would make a spreadsheet and include info like the above and anything else you can think of.

You might not care about, say, greek life. but if 50% of the kids are in greek life and you don’t want to be, that is something to know. Or you may want a big time sports scene or you might not want one.
If you are fancy, you could weight each of these.

Grade them from 1-5 as they make sense to you. Then see which one has the largest score.
Then see if that is the one you secretly would hope would win.

Also check out the websites…
https://www.cmu.edu/cee/prospective/undergraduate/student-stories/index.html
See if the others have similar student stories. Do these resonate with you?