This article outlines the cases of folks leaving the state dues to high college costs (and property taxes), and fleeing to GA, FL, CO, TX. I could see the same thing happening in PA and other northeastern states.
How do these southern states keep college costs and property taxes low? Reasonable pension payouts? Other revenue?
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/editorials/ct-edit-illinois-exodus-population-taxes-20180328-story.html
Generally when a state slashes the budget, there is a lag before the effects are felt in many people’s lives. You may not realize the lack of a safety net until your town really needs it and all of a sudden there’s a foreclosure, homelessness, or drug crisis. You can see one of the long term effects of the low-tax low-service mentality in the mass teacher walkouts in WV and OK.
Much of college costs are labor. In lower cost of living areas, they do not have to pay their staff as much.
But also, the priorities that states have with respect to higher education, its funding, and financial aid vary, and are not necessary the same across any given region (or state political leaning). A crude measure of college affordability in various states is student loan debt: https://ticas.org/posd/map-state-data
The high cost of living creates high labor costs. This is mixed with high taxes and overbearing regulation, and businesses are moving to more hospitable areas. This takes the bulk of jobs, which reside with small/medium sized companies and leaves only large companies in places like Illinois. Large companies only make up a small fraction of jobs, so job competition becomes tighter and tighter. This competitive landscape artificially creates a demand for more education at selective colleges. Universities react to the demand by raising tuition and becoming more selective. The funny thing is that these schools aren’t any better or more rigorous. All of the demand is artificial.
That’s the reason why schools in Texas and other parts of the south aren’t as selective. They really don’t have to be. There’s no shortage of skilled jobs, so there’s no pressure to go to “top” schools. All those jobs came here.
I don’t believe TX property taxes are low.
@coolguy40 I would think that would equalize over time to an extent. I see this as being akin to the fact that the cost of labor in Asia is rising, offsetting some (obviously not all, or even most) of the benefit to manufacturing overseas.
I don’t think of Colorado’s college tuition as low… COA at Boulder is now over $30K for instate; over $26K at the much less desirable Colorado Springs campus.
Colorado also has some of the worst state funding for K-12 in the country. Right down there with Mississippi…
@kataliamom They mention the low CO property taxes as a benefit in the article - maybe that contributes to the low K-12 funding.
Colorado property and income taxes are low. That means residents have to pay more ‘as they go’ for services. Tuition at CU is high, but much lower at CSU and other state schools. If people want CU, they pay more. And yes, pensions for most public workers are not insane like they are in some states. California is basically paying double for every fireman, once for the one on duty and again for the one who is retired at 90% of salary.
Much of K-12 funding is done through school districts and bonds. Want better schools? Move to a suburb with a high school bond (Boulder, Aspen, Cherry Creek) or live in the city and pay for private schools. My sister is a Denver school teacher with a master’s degree and makes about $45k per year. She’d make about $5k more in the burbs, and have supply closets full of paper and pens and a computer for every kid in her classroom.
@twinanddone In NE states (PA, NJ, DE, NY) after a few years, suburban teachers often make twice that and more. And there are very high property taxes.