Background: First try SAT: 1490. (790 Math and 700 Verbal), GPA 3.75 unweighted (4.0 max) - 10 honors courses. Nationally recognized high school with rigorous curriculum.
Independent College Counsellor: “Don’t take the SAT again, you’re in the admission range…focus your efforts on rounding out your application”.
We are applying to “tier A” schools (I won’t bore you with the list, you already know!)
Do you agree?
The new SAT makes this a tough call - the ranges are still shaking out, and fluctuating a lot. A 1490 could be on the border for those “A” tier schools.
My recommendation would be to take the ACT. The ranges have been much more set, and a 33+ would eliminate any doubt for if it’s enough for an “A” tier school. A 1490 should translate to that (edge of 33-34), if not more. YMMV based on the person.
Not sure what you mean by tier a school? If you mean your well respected State University, you may be fine. If you mean Ivy leagues, then I would say it is definitely low. Schools publish their admission ranges. You want to be at or above the 75% range ideally. My son got a 1540 first try. He is not applying to Ivies, MIT or Stanford so he is probably ok. If he were he would take it again.
Also do you mean honors or AP? Big difference in rigor with admission officers.
The 700 isn’t as competitive, if you mean tippy top colleges.
You need to take some responsibility here. Stanford, eg, shows the mid 50% of CR scores as 690-760. It means you’d maybe fall down toward the 25th percentile. Maybe the ACT is a good idea. You also need to understand how a 3.75 plays.
And there’s more to know. As these top schools like kids with their own initiative, don’t rely on a counselor to do all this for you. Of course, you haven’t told what “tier A” means to you.
Take the SAT again. Maybe try the ACT once. It’s not a matter of doing one thing over another. Make sure you have a well rounded resume to the extent possible (you don’t want to join a dozen clubs the end of your junior year).
Not enough info. Yes, the 1490 is a little on the low side if you’re talking about say the top 20 USNWR colleges. But then again, the 3.75 and only honors with no AP or IB is borderline too low as well. Improving your SAT 30-40 points to be in the WOW territory may take more work than you think and the gpa/rigor won’t have moved a bit.
Reading between the lines, the counselor may think that your GPA and SAT are aligned, on the low side and not readily changeable but likely enough to not get your app immediately turfed, so your best bet is to hope those scores are enough to put you in the “considered” pile where your amazing essays, ECs and LORs will shine. You only have so many hours in a day, so the counselor may be thinking your priority is to develop and improve ECs and essays than grinding through hours of test prep.
What ECs do you have? Do you have any hooks? And what does it mean when you say “we are applying”? Are you a twin?