<p>Thank you so much, everyone, for your insightful answers re: Catholic or other Christian colleges. Interesting to hear all your many viewpoints. While some of you would not mind it at all for your children, the majority of you would mind…I’m in the group that would mind it, which is why we didn’t consider any of those schools seriously for us.</p>
<p>I don’t think I would be very happy knowing my S was one of only 200 jewish kids out of almost 10,000 kids. That’s why we crossed Middlebury College off our list, even though it is not a Christian school (and also way too rural for S). I agree with Levrim just for dating issues…easier to date jewish kids when there is more than a handful to choose from!</p>
<p>RVM: Keep Muhlenberg on the list! You never know what financial aid you’re going to receive until you get a package! It may turn out to be affordable in the long run!</p>
<p>Rodney: Thanks for the tip on the Boston Globe articles…I may look some of those up!</p>
<p>I would not consider a Catholic college for any of my kids. When I asked my son if he’d ever consider BC or Georgetown (just out of curiosity) he was also adamantly opposed.
I know for a fact that the opening activity for orientation at BC is a Mass, which is obviously not mandatory, but who would want to miss out on the kick-off to freshman year? And to get back to the conversation (waay back) about the potential for finding a mate in college, going to a Catholic school really stacks the odds against that possibility.
There are many, many schools that combine a great education with a rah-rah atmosphere. To eliminate a few doesn’t seem like the biggest sacrifice in the world.</p>
<p>Ok - keeping Muhlenberg on the list - I really do want to see it - just hate the thought of another pricey school and dealing with FA and so forth - but it won’t hurt to visit.</p>
<p>levirm - S1 loves Wake Forest - the Baptist affiliation has not bothered him in any way. He frequently attends programs held in Wait Chapel - beautiful bldg - clearly a Christian chapel - but they have speakers and so forth there. I wish he would become involved with Hillel - especially since it seems to be getting a little more active - but he has zero interest. On an unrelated note - I do feel like we periodically get the FA thing rubbed in our faces. Before he even started - he was asked to write a thank you note to the scholarship committee. He got a call today requesting he participate in a “thank-a-thon” event where the “scholarship” kids call donors and thank them for their support. Just making me cringe a little - but I am appreciative.</p>
<p>momjr - Delaware seems to have fallen by the wayside. S2 seems to have no interest - and in that size category - Towson and JMU would both be much less expensive.</p>
<p>First, lots of mazal tov and congratulations to all the recent college acceptances.</p>
<p>To Rockville Mom’s question about Muhlenberg’s price tag. Is a private school worth 50k?
Since you have excellent options on your list which are more reasonably priced, I don’t see the need to spend 50k and go for FA. Keep in mind, most financial aid includes some loans.
Particularly in this difficult economy where some college grads are having a hard time finding a job at graduation, I think it is very stressful to put your child in a position of having to pay back loans during uncertain economic times. I am very optimistic that your son will get accepted to Towson and Elon, which are probably your top choices given your criteria.</p>
<p>Since you plan to visit Muhlenberg, you can certainly ask on the tour, what makes your school special and worth the additional cost. Perhaps there are some special perks which make the price tag worth it to you.</p>
<p>In our case, I do not want my children taking any loans. We are older parents and know that planning for retirement is also important. I can’t see a reason to pay 50k a year when Towson will provide an adequate Business school education with a good Jewish community.</p>
<p>Rockville Mom: Any chance that you think your son will be eligible for merit aid at Muhlenberg? $50,000 school might be ok if your son gets good merit aid.</p>
<p>Congrats on the acceptances and I’m sorry about the deferrals. As others have said these things work out either with a different school starting to look better or with eventual acceptance, having been on the waiting end of things I know that is tough, but it will be fine.</p>
<p>RVM: Thank you for your thoughts about ED. As I said S1 didn’t apply ED and that may have made the difference for him regarding being WL’d vs accepted to his then top choice. Attempting to speak to the school’s FA dept in advance is a good idea. I don’t think we will apply ED to any that don’t give a good feeling regarding the aid. Its just too risky. Regarding your concerns about FA. My S1 is at an expensive school but not on scholarship. He got some very significant grant money that made the school possible. He has never been asked to send out thank yous or anything like that but we do cringe about what the FA package will be from year to year. So far so good but it is easier when you know you aren’t relying on an outside decision. Still I don’t think I would cross a school off the list because of price unless I didn’t think it offered anything better than a less costly school that was a sure thing. S2 has just begun mentioning some pricier choices and I have made the cost limit issues clear. I have also used this as an opportunity to explain to him that getting the best standardized test scores he can will increase his chances of going to a more expensive school since this would increase his scholarship chances…It sounds like your bad experience at Gtown had a good outcome for you in the longrun. </p>
<p>Someone mentioned that High Holy day services at Elon are off campus. Can you explain that further. How much travel is involved and how difficult are they to get to. S and I haven’t yet discussed Elon but from so much of what I have read on this thread I think it could be a good fit for him.</p>
<p>By the way we did our first college tour at UT Austin today. Not exactly a great time to get a feel for the student body but S did feel more comfortable about the size after this session than he did before. I think the talk about intramurals and interest groups made him feel more secure about the size. Just to give you an idea about how flexible kids can be in there choice of majors, while he was sitting in on this session S who all along has seemed set on a business major said, that he might consider engineering since math is his favorite subject. I guess now we have to consider schools with business and engineering programs.</p>
<p>Hi- Congrats to all the “Ins” , sorry to all the deferrals, my son also got a deferral to Lewis and Clark within the last few days so I know how it feels!</p>
<p>For the catholic school question- I think there is a difference between a catholic school and a jesuit school. I think I would feel comfortable with a jesuit school which seems to be a value based education, as opposed to a catholic school which, from the websites that I looked at, seem to be more religion based. There are some really nice catholic schools in Cal that I would not feel comfortable sending my kids to, even though I think they are great schools (like University of San Diego- so pretty!!!). But it’s a comfort level thing.</p>
<p>spectrum2 - your comment about having to wait for the FA pkg every year - yes - I really hate that part of it. We don’t receive that info until June - and the first semester pymt is due by August 1 - so there is very little time in case you get a nasty surprise. I would be much happier if S2 was at a school that we could kind of swing on our own - rather than be in a FA situation again - hence my concern re Muhlenberg.</p>
<p>However, it occurred to me last night that Muhlenberg with FA might be less than Elon without - so it does make sense to visit and see what we think. </p>
<p>mdcissp - I agree with you re loans - S1 will graduate with maybe $20,000 in loans - all subsidized Stafford or Perkins - so I don’t think that is too bad. Would not want either of them to graduate with more than that amount. At this point - I don’t think he is strong enough to receive merit aid from Muhlenberg - but if he can get his ACT up a few points - then maybe - that would be fun!</p>
<p>What does that mean that you have to wait until June for a FA package?</p>
<p>My S1 applied ED and received his FA package almost immediately, just a few days after his acceptance.</p>
<p>If my S2 applies RD, don’t the decisions as to what college he decides upon have to be made @May 1st? How would you know what FA packages are for each college if you don’t get the info. until June? I’m clearly missing something here.</p>
<p>It’s very likely we’ll be doing RD or rolling the second time around…when do FA notices come out, at the same time as the acceptances?</p>
<p>Sorry for the confusion - I mean for returning students. My son is now a sophomore at Wake - we had to wait until early June to get his FA award letter for his sophomore year. It changes every year - as your EFC changes. My finding so far is that we get less of the good stuff - grant money - each year and are offered more loans - which of course you can accept or decline. He also gets work study. He did - as you mention - get the original FA award letter right around April 1 with his acceptance. </p>
<p>My gripe is that, IMO, our EFC increases slightly each year - but so does the COA - meaning his pkg should remain about the same - but it didn’t. He rcvd about $4000 less in grant money for sophomore year - and we didn’t want to increase loans - so we had to scramble to come up with the difference between June and August 1. Now I’m prepared for that event - and am mentally taking the amount we needed last August 1 - adding $2000 to it - and praying for the best.</p>
<p>re: Muhlenberg, my daughter’s very observant best friend applied ED but hasn’t yet gotten her FA package yet. It’s causing a lot of stress waiting and wondering. There’s a beautiful new theatre there on campus if your son is into the arts. Personally, when we visited the school last year, we were both so turned off by Allentown and the area within a few blocks around the school, that we couldn’t consider it seriously. We arrived early for our tour and wanted to get a bite to eat as well as check out if there was any sort of college town or atmosphere. There isn’t and it was so seedy and depressing that it colored the rest of our time there. Nor do I think the reputation is such that it trumps Elon, all other things being equal.</p>
<p>So that is why people look for rolling admissions? Because you get an acceptance & FA package for RD @April 1st and have to make your decision by May 1st? Oy. Sounds very stressful.</p>
<p>I take it that rolling admissions gives you FA info. at the time of their acceptance? EA works the same way?</p>
<p>Glad I have a few more years to figure out college info. for S2…maybe things will work themselves out by then!</p>
<p>Received a very small envelope from SMU (Southern Methodist University) with a denial letter. I am starting to notice a pattern here…S1 has been accepted to all the schools that we visited and denials/deferrals from schools that we didn’t visit. This experience w/S1 has taught how important it is to have a few - safety/rolling schools and to make sure and try to visit as many colleges as possible! Good luck to everyone else waiting to hear back in the next few months. Happy Holidays!</p>
<p>Just to add to what RVM said, although our grant money didn’t go down we did have to renegotiate our FA after the original Soph award came out. (With the increase in tuition we ended up owing more.) We didn’t even get to discussions until late July, which is when we first learned what FA he was awarded!!! Those of you relying on FA might want to check with the school to find out when upper classmen get their awards, just so you are prepared. We tried to think of everything in advance but we didn’t think of that. Our FA situation has been very unusual, in our favor not FAFSA predictable, the school has worked with us but not having that stress would be a very good thing! I will say that although it would be really painful to enforce, when we accepted the school we also told S1 that it was contingent on the FA award going as expected. Of course if you are going to look to make a change it is really difficult to do when you just learn of the package in the middle of the summer!</p>
<p>Now that we have left that option open for S1 to go to a private, I can’t imagine offering S2 anything less. He is however required to get the money as S1 was required to do. But RVM, I agree with you, I would much rather know from the get go that we are prepared to handle the full bill. Of course even when you think you know that you still don’t know for sure what will happen to tuition over 4 years so if you are at the top of your budget I guess there is always some stress.</p>
<p>Stayathomemom: It looks like we cross posted. I’m sure it is better to visit whenever possible. But S1’s experience was different at least at the schools he cared the most about. He was WL’d at one school he visited and accepted where we didn’t visit, didn’t even attend a local info session! The admission stats at both schools were similar.</p>
<p>I’m sorry about SMU, that’s another school I have thought about but I came accross a list of average SAT scores that said their’s was 1400, so I’m not looking at it all that much now.</p>
<p>Here’s an interesting article for this group - food for thought as we prepare our young adults for college - and discuss/struggle about the Jewish population at various schools. I think that the way we’ve handled being Jewish since they were little (especially if we live in a less Jewish area) has a bearing on how important a Jewish presence is at college. Just a thought.</p>
<p>Humm ^^^I enjoyed reading that. I don’t know that we fell into any one of the categories but I do remember thinking long and hard about how to handle the holidays as parents who grew up in the northeast raising kids in the south. My conclusion wasn’t to compete but to make a much bigger deal about Hanukah than we ever made in our homes and to make it fun. We always had the central message in our home that the holiday teaches us to do what is right for us even when it is difficult and different. I guess they got that message because I do have 2 very strong minded kids. When I watched my Christian friends it became clear to me that tied up in the fun and Santa and commercialism many families were also cultivating a love for Jesus and faith. I have to say that I tried to learn from this and tried to do the same for our family. Not out of competition, but because I thought it was a little bit of genius to make holidays so much fun. Incidentally while we observed, for the most part holidays were more about rules and less about fun when I was growing up.</p>
<p>Sorry about the denial, Stayathomemom. Fortunately, your son already has some good options. I always think it’s best to visit, but I think it affects admissions more at small schools that track interest. My daughters were both accepted to big schools (Michigan, Pitt, Northestern) without visiting. I do think not visiting can hurt at schools that have “Why us?” essays. It’s hard to be genuine about a place you’ve never seen.</p>
<p>Thanks for sharing the article, Linymom. I admit to some Christmas envy myself this time of year.</p>
<p>We’re having a stressful week here. My older daughter came home from college really sick. We were supposed to go to Florida to visit my in-laws tomorrow, and she leaves for Birthright on Sunday. It looks like she and I may skip Florida so she can rest up for the Israel trip.</p>