<p>stayathome - sorry about SMU - glad you have other options.</p>
<p>momjr - hope she is feeling better soon - hope she has a wonderful trip to Israel.</p>
<p>stayathome - sorry about SMU - glad you have other options.</p>
<p>momjr - hope she is feeling better soon - hope she has a wonderful trip to Israel.</p>
<p>Sorry that your D isn’t feeling well, momjr. Sounds like a great plan to let her rest up for birthright. Too bad you have to miss out on Florida.</p>
<p>What year in college is your D? Is she going with the group from UPenn? Why did she decide on going during the Dec. break as opposed to the summer? How often are these trips offered? Maybe it depends on the college? Do most kids go through their college?</p>
<p>I’ll be looking into Birthright for S1 & S2 eventually…</p>
<p>stayathomemom: Sorry for the denial. We have many friends who do not visit the colleges until after they have an acceptance, especially if it involves plane trips. It could just be a coincidence it happened that way for you…</p>
<p>chocochipcookie – there are a lot of different birthright sponsors – many kids go with the hillel from their school (if the hillel is large enough to sponsor a trip) – but there are also many other trips that appeal to different interests – [Taglit-Birthright</a> Israel: North American Trip Organizers](<a href=“http://www.birthrightisrael.com/site/PageServer?pagename=trip_natolist]Taglit-Birthright”>http://www.birthrightisrael.com/site/PageServer?pagename=trip_natolist) if one of the special interests appeals to your child, it can be a great option (eg, there’s one that emphasizes outdoor activities; there’s one primarily for post-college young adults; Koach – the Conservative movement’s college organization – has run trips specifically for kids with aspergers [koach isn’t listed on the site i gave, it works with one of those organizers – <a href=“http://koach.org/birthright.htm][/url]”>http://koach.org/birthright.htm]</a>). </p>
<p>one advantage of going on a trip thru your kids hillel is that you know the dates will work with their school breaks – with other trips you have to check the dates more carefully. another advantage of going with your own school is getting to know kids from your school, but another way of looking at it is that going on a different trip is a chance to get to know kids from all over.</p>
<p>Stayathomemom, some schools really want you to show the love (demonstrate interest) and a visit is part of that. Some don’t care. </p>
<p>ShawSon decided that he wouldn’t visit schools until after acceptance (“Why should I fall in love with schools with a 10% probability of admitting me?”). He got into a lot of schools he had not visited. So, a rejection might not be due to a failure to visit.</p>
<p>One the other hand, he did get put on the WL for a Maine LAC that his GC ranked as a safety. It is a school that wanted to see love that he clearly didn’t show (he didn’t try to schedule an interview until after the deadline for interviews). So, a rejection might be due to a failure to visit. </p>
<p>So, it is pretty hard to say what causes the decisions of the inscrutable adcoms.</p>
<p>Thank you very much for the info. unbelievablem!
</p>
<p>Looks like I’ll have several choices to look at and decide with my S which will work. I’m thinking that if he went during the summertime, he’d be able to go for the 10 days and them maybe hook up with another trip or volunteer on a Kibbutz for a short time before coming back home to work…I’d have to ask if that’s even possible.</p>
<p>When I was in college, I went on a six week program through Amer. Zionist Youth Foundation…two weeks of touring and one month volunteering on a Kibbutz. I stayed in Israel after that for another six weeks and volunteered at a hospital…</p>
<p>If he does it early enough in May, he’ll be home to work June-Aug…</p>
<p>Unbelievablem: I’m sure if he went with the kids from the college, he’d probably also go with kids from other colleges too, so essentially he would be meeting kids from all over!
I have plenty of time to figure this out, but I thank you for sending me the links!</p>
<p>There is a documentary on tonight at 9pm (east coast time) on CNBC - The Price of Admissions - dealing with college costs and student loan debt. Sounds relevant - thought it might be of interest to some of you.</p>
<p>Re Birthright: D2 went with Michigan her Freshman year and the trip was sponsored by Hillel. Most of the buses were split between sorority and fraternity groups. That was a year when Birthright still had a lot of money and close to 100 kids went on the trip. Birthright’s funds were heavily affected by the downturn in the economy and the same trip only sent half as many kids the following year. Michigan only does the May trip because their winter break is so short. </p>
<p>And chocchipcookie: Yes, you can extend your trip if you go in the summer. D2 stayed for an extra 4 days with 5 friends and visited places they didn’t go on the regular trip. You are responsible for your own costs at that point, but you can change your return flight to a later date at no extra cost. In fact, they ask you about that option when you sign up. One other issue about Birthright is that you cannot have gone to Israel on another touring trip 5 years prior to the upcoming trip. For this reason D1 never went on the Birthright trip.</p>
<p>BTW, you can go on one of these trips until you turn 26. My niece who is 23 is on the trip right now with a group from LA. Since she moved there she doesn’t know many people and she is hoping this trip will introduce her to new people in LA.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>it depends on the size of the school and how many kids they send – some hillels fill their own buses so that they aren’t really with kids from other schools. some hillels do combine with kids from other hillels (often with schools in the same geographic area). i guess its something you can ask the hillels at the prospective schools – as well as how often they have trips and when (some schools tend to go winter, some summer, some both) there may be occasions when different buses there at the same time run into each other, but they really spend just about all their time with the kids on their bus.</p>
<p>i believe the limitation on eligibility for birthright is that they not have been to israel with a peer educational tour – so if they travel there with family, i believe they are still eligible.</p>
<p>Thanks you guys, for all the info. re: Birthright! :)</p>
<p>I still have plenty of time, but will begin the ball rolling once he becomes a freshman next fall. No, he’s never been to Israel yet. We were planning to go this coming summer with the whole extended family, but just could not swing it financially at this time. He went to Spain with the high school last Feb. & loved every minute of that trip!</p>
<p>Another option could be when he graduates, but I wonder if more kids go while still in college.</p>
<p>Momjr: Hope your D is well enough by Sunday to go…I’d love to hear about it when she returns!</p>
<p>RVM: I’ll be missing that documentary, but please summarize it for us if you find anything interesting! Thank you!</p>
<p>Spectrum,
You asked about high holiday services at Elon. When we visited last feb we were told that kids wishing to attend were welcome at a synogogue in the local town and the school provided transportation. I would expect that, with the building of the new Jewish center, this will change in the future.</p>
<p>My son is being recruited to play soccer at Elon. When we visited the campus he loved it. He also wanted to play soccer at Emory (Div. 3) but the coach could not get him in. His sister goes to Emory and loves it.</p>
<p>I enjoyed the CNBC documentary. They profiled a young couple with $250,000+ in student loan debt between them - their combined monthly payments were over $1700/month and would last 20 years. They absolutely had regrets about the amount they spent on their educations. Another family had 4 kids - each of whom would graduate from college with about $80,000 in student loan debt - with no real concept of how much the pymts would be per month and how long they would last for.</p>
<p>I think the documentary missed the mark by not explaining some rational guidelines - such as don’t accumulate more student loan debt than what you believe your first year salary would be - that’s a rational starting point.</p>
<p>They also profiled the very sad case of a NJ couple whose son died in a car accident last year - and they will still owe his $81,000 student loan debt because they co-signed. Their advice was to have life insurance on your college-aged kids if they have significant student loan debt and you are the co-signer. They were able to negotiate it down to $40,000 - but still a horrendous situation.</p>
<p>I think the biggest point made is that you can’t make the assumption that student loan debt will pay off in the end - there are too many unemployed or under-employed recent college graduates out there today to support that assumption any longer.</p>
<p>RVM that is so sad. We parents try and think of everything, but life insurance for my kids never crossed my mind.</p>
<p>CCC: At the start of his spring freshman semester S1 called and asked for $250 for a refundable deposit on birthright. He was not active with Hillel but did participate in high holy days services so I guess that was enough to get him on a list to be notified about this. We responded quickly and off he went. I guess one of the few advantages of being at a school with a relatively small Hillel was that he didn’t have any waitlist experience. From what I hear it is sometimes difficult to get into a program so if the opportunity arises it is probably a good idea to take advantage of it. I thought it was great that he got to go with other kids on his campus. It gave him a chance to make some Jewish friends or at least acquaintences. His tour was with students from a couple of other schools around the country.</p>
<p>MoltoBene: From what you are saying my younger S who went on a NFTY Israel trip at 16 could still be eligible to participate in birthright when he is 22. He had asked me about that and I didn’t think he would be. If he is that would be good news for him. He’s ready to go back anytime!</p>
<p>Thanks College1, that makes sense. I was surprised that Elon didn’t have services on campus.</p>
<p>I have a question for those of you who have kids involved in Hillel. I was speaking with a Jewish college prof today who mentioned that at his school Hillel had a primarily religous agenda rather than a social one. He thought that their Hillel didn’t get as many students as they would because they were not focusing on what the kids were looking for. My S1 has really not been motivated to participate in Hillel activities except on holidays but knowing him this didn’t surprise me. I had however been under the impression that there was a strong social component to most Hillels. Is that the way it is or is it more religiously/educationally focused?</p>
<p>Momjr: It seems that illnesses come at the worst times. According to my S birthright is wonderful but exhausting. Taking time to rest is a great plan. I hope the TLC gets her well enough to make the trip and enjoy it. S’s birthright trip was also really close to his getting out of school. I wished they allowed for a little chill time between the end of school rush and taking of on the trip. S had 1 day at home to unpack and repack. You have to be young to keep that schedule!</p>
<p>Stateathome- my son didn’t interview, didn’t visit, and his stats are below SMUs averages…fully expecting a small envelope tomorrow :-(</p>
<p>2flipper2 - S1 is not disappointed - only applied to SMU because they sent him an “invitation” and a abbreviated app with no essay required and no teacher recommendation needed. And since SMU is pretty low on his list, he did the minimum. He has a friend that goes there and she loves it, his stats are similar to hers. Our high school has very few kids who have applied to SMU so maybe they are not familiar with our school?
I do think SMU wants you to show love. Tulane also sent S1 a letter to apply, application fee waivered, etc…wonder is this is a way for some college to increase number of applications submitted? I know Tulane has received a whopping number of applications each year but the yield of accepted students that actually go there is pretty low. </p>
<p>Momjr - hoping your daughter is feeling better soon! </p>
<p>Just wanted say again that I really appreciate how welcoming you all are to me!</p>
<p>Thanks for the good wishes for my daughter. She is still very sick. She and I are skipping the Florida trip and hoping a few days of rest will help. Like Spectrum says, the birthright trips are very active and tiring, so we’ll have to see how she feels at the end of the week. She’ll see the doctor on Friday. I realized how much she’s grown up last night. She is disapointed about possibly missing the trip, but is thankful that this hit right after her finals.</p>
<p>CCC: It looks like you got a lot of good information about birthright. This trip is a Penn trip with 40 students. She and her cousin applied for general trips last winter and spring, but got waitlisted in the winter and were offered a trip leaving from L.A. (!) in the summer. It seems that applying for a trip organzied by your school’s Hillel is the best way to get a spot. And as others pointed out, the dates and logistics are usually more compatible.</p>
<p>So if I’m understanding this correctly, you just sign up as soon as you can as a freshman and wait for an opening for either winter or summer? Yikes! I’m such a planner, that may put me over the edge not knowing! :eek:</p>
<p>Talk about learning to be flexible!! Oy.</p>
<p>Let the fun begin! Oh boy!!</p>
<p>Momjr: what do you mean the trip leaves out of LA? What about the trip your D will be taking this Sunday? You don’t get to leave out of the most convenient airport? Wow, I really am unaware of this program…I’ll have to look up the info. as soon as I have a free few minutes!</p>
<p>RVM: It’s hard to imagine people racking up that much debt over a college degree. I read somewhere recently that the bubble will burst, meaning colleges will have to go to more reasonable prices…not sure how that would happen…</p>
<p>Spectrum2: If your child has been to Israel on an organized trip here is the answer from the Birthright site. My niece had gone on March of the Living in high school, but not a USY, BBYO or other such trip and so she was now eligible to go on Birthright since she was 23.</p>
<p>Q. I have been to Israel before, am I still eligible?</p>
<p>A. It depends. Taglit-Birthright Israel strongly believes in the value of the peer trip experience. Therefore, if you have been to Israel before but only with your family or on other personal business, you are still eligible. However, if you have been to Israel as part of a touring group, educational program, study program or an organized extended residential program since you were 12 years old, you are not eligible. If you participated on the March of the Living when you were in high school you are eligible to participate on one of our programs once you turn 22 years of age. If you were born in Israel or are an Israeli citizen you are only eligible if you left Israel before the age of 12. If you have served in the Israeli Army or volunteered on an Israel Army base, you are not eligible. </p>
<p>Also, in colleges where there is a big Jewish population, you have to write an essay and be picked to go. Not everyone makes it. In D2’s trip there were kids from other colleges who chose to go with the Michigan group.</p>