Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Thanks MoltoBene, I didn’t think he was still eligible but then when you mentioned 5 years I thought he might be. The group experience is incredibly valuable.</p>

<p>CCC: I guess the first thing you need to do is just have S check with the Hillel at his school to find out about how to sign up. As far as I knew S1 didn’t even have it on his radar. He just got the email about the opportunity and responded quickly. I know he had some paperwork to do, there may have been an essay. All I ever saw was the deposit request from him :slight_smile: …S was also given a$500 scholarship for his expenses,(he had to fly to NY) As far as I know the scholarship came from the birthrite program and it was in exchange for him volunteering to work for about a week at our JCC. He became camp counselor for a 1 week camp.</p>

<p>Momjr: I hope she can make it on the trip but, I wonder if there is anyway to work with the program in case of illness to get the trip rescheduled.</p>

<p>Our DDs received very generous scholarships from the local Federation for their NFTY trips. I don’t know if that kind of community support for youth travel to Israel is typical, especially Birthright, but it might be worth looking for local resources.</p>

<p>Thanks so much Spectrum and everyone else too…well, now that I’m done researching colleges for S1 and S2, the freshman, said not to come near him with regard to colleges :slight_smile: then I guess the next big piece of research will be Birthright Israel! Yes, I would LOVE for him to have this experience and I guess planning ahead is hopefully the key to a smoother experience, you would think. So even if he doesn’t do it the summer after Freshman year, as what I had envisioned, I’m sure that between then and age 26 we’ll be able to fit it in!</p>

<p>Momjr: I certainly hope your D bounces back & joins the Birthright group!</p>

<p>++++++ that Momjr’s D has a quick recovery.</p>

<p>CofC is high on S2’s list and we are looking forward to visiting in April. But sometimes I’ll read something about South Carolina which just leaves me shaking my head - which is what happened today when I read about the Secession Ball which was just held in Charleston this week. Here’s more:</p>

<p>"Distasteful. That’s the best way to describe it.</p>

<p>Pro-Confederacy supporters gathered in Charleston, S.C., Monday evening to attend a “Secession Ball,” commemorating the 150th anniversary of the state’s decision to secede from the United States of America.</p>

<p>What’s the cause for celebration? Dredging up the bondage of black men and women as slaves? Applauding the decision to break apart from the nation and bring about a war rather than using the political process and laws to address differences?</p>

<p>While the root causes of the Civil War are complicated, historians agree they included states’ rights, slavery and political and economic considerations, with slavery influencing the other three.</p>

<p>Organizers said the ball and other events planned over the next four years are designed to preserve the history and legacy of the South’s citizen soldiers, who exhibited bravery and tenacity in protecting their property and beliefs.</p>

<p>But even 150 years later, wounds from the Civil War still ache. Members of the Charleston NAACP conducted a peaceful protest outside Monday’s gala, saying the state’s secession is a part of its history, but having a ball to celebrate an episode associated with preserving slavery is insulting. It’s that, and inflammatory, too.</p>

<p>Charleston Mayor Joe Riley criticized the event, organized by the Confederate Heritage Trust and sponsored by the Sons of Confederate Veterans, calling it “the opposite of unifying.” When Mayor Riley said the Civil War was fought over slavery, he was heckled."</p>

<p>[The</a> Day - War Between the States still simmering for some | News from southeastern Connecticut](<a href=“http://www.theday.com/article/20101222/OP01/312229927]The”>War Between the States still simmering for some)</p>

<p>[Charleston’s</a> ‘secession ball’ a contentious start to Civil War’s 150th anniversary - USATODAY.com](<a href=“http://travel.usatoday.com/destinations/dispatches/post/2010/12/charlestons-succession-ball-a-contentious-start-to-civil-wars-150th-anniversary/135669/1]Charleston’s”>http://travel.usatoday.com/destinations/dispatches/post/2010/12/charlestons-succession-ball-a-contentious-start-to-civil-wars-150th-anniversary/135669/1)</p>

<p>“As the Charleston event kicks off more than four years of 150th anniversary Civil War commemorations, it also frames persisting questions. Chief among them: How does a nation remember the time when 11 of its states tried unsuccessfully to break away?”</p>

<p>Looks like an interesting time to attend college in Charleston. I have to admit I really don’t understand this interest in re-living the Civil War. Do you see this as a non-issue or as a negative factor in an evaluation of CofC?</p>

1 Like

<p>My wife has family in Charleston and I spent several years doing business there. It is a great city and a very good college. Forget the Confederate nonsense as it is nothing more than reliving a respectable, southern way of life. It also includes manners and a lot of decency.
My daughter is interested in going there and we would be thrilled if she did. They have a good mix of sports and majors in a very controlled environment. The Citadel boys make sure of that.</p>

<p>RVM:</p>

<p>I live way up in New England and have heard many positives about C of C. I would definitely consider it if I were you. With only a small handful of schools on your list, keep them all there and see what plays out! I’ve also heard that there is a large and still growing Jewish population in Charleston…</p>

<p>Good advice from collegeseeker…:)</p>

<p>Excellent - thank you. I’ll just put the Secession Ball off to the side mentally.</p>

<p>RVM - I totally understand your feelings. I also find myself shaking my head at some things I read about South Carolina (also saw that article today). I was in Charleston recently and walked through the campus - which is very lovely. Neither of my kids ever had an interest, but I know some kids who did and felt it was just too southern with very little diversity. I hope your visit goes well when you tour with S2. </p>

<p>On a random note - I’ve noticed that our little state of MD seems to be well represented here!</p>

<p>The Secession Ball is really an abomination. I can’t believe that some would have us think that the Civil War was just a matter of defending states’ rights. Charleston, however, has a really rich Jewish history worth exploring.
It’s probably worth inquiring, if you can, from existing students how pervasive the Southern feeling is.</p>

<p>@chochipcookie. My D1 applied for Birthright for this winter and got waitlisted. Hopefully she’ll get in for summer. Check out the trip organizers carefully. Some of the programs are much more religious, which is great if that’s what you want, but maybe a turnoff if a kid isn’t comfortable with that.</p>

<p>As predicted small SMU envelope today- a deferral. Not a big deal but it’s so much more fun when the news is good!</p>

<p>2flipper2 - glad it was expected and not a shock. There are already quite a few threads on CC from students/parents upset by their results so far - glad we don’t seem to have any posters in that boat.</p>

<p>Count us in with the disappointed …Clark…denial…I think I’m more upset then my son. He had fallen out of love with Clark at the Clark Conversation but rejection stings…so …anyone hear anything about Franklin Pierce?</p>

<p>Sorry to hear that news - and I agree with you that many times the parents take it harder.</p>

<p>I’ve never heard of Franklin Pierce - had to Google it. Has your son applied there? He likes to ski, right? I guess that makes sense.</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.franklinpierce.edu/[/url]”>http://www.franklinpierce.edu/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>and they do have a Hillel:</p>

<p>Hillel (Jewish Alliance)</p>

<p>Hillel We provide a presence and support for students of the Jewish faith and culture. We offer a place for promoting education of Jewish culture to non-Jewish students of the community who wish to participate. We organize a Passover Seder, Chanukah Party and Sunday Brunch and other opportunities for community and education.
Recent Events</p>

<p>A Passover Seder, Chanukah Party, and Sunday brunches are a few examples of opportunities offered to provide community and education.</p>

<p>Sorry about today’s denials and deferrals. Hopefully you all will have better news to report and this will soon be forgotten!</p>

<p>College4three: thanks for the heads up. Question: What do you mean by trip organizers? If it’s through the college’s Hillel, would that make it more social or more religious? It’s still very early for me since S is still a h.s. senior, but when I have a free moment, hahaha, I will look up info. on the Birthright website and begin asking questions. Does it say which programs are more religious? Knowing my S, he would be much happier with a social trip than a religious one…I had no idea they have so many choices, but once I begin to research it (my favorite word:)), then I’ll have a better grasp on our options.</p>

<p>No idea about Franklin Pierce at all, but heard positives about Franklin & Marshall!</p>

<p>One of one of my son’s friends applied to Franklin Pierce. I know nothing about it. I know that the friend who applied was looking for a business school and was a B- student in HS. He did not end up attending FP (he chose Quinnipiac instead). I also know that in his case money was not a deciding factor.</p>

<p>@ccc: I would try to find out from Hillel directly about the degree of religious observance. From what I’m reading here, Hillel seems to be more of a sure thing, though, so it may be the way to go anyway. Also, your son will undoubtedly know kids who are taking the trip at the same time. Tufts, right? I know LOTS of (Jewish) kids there if you have any general questions.
If you go to the birthright website, you’ll see Trip Organizers and can research the various programs (look under the sample agendas). My D1 ultimately chose Mayanot.</p>

<p>Just wanted to mention a few things I saw on their website tonight that might be of interest:</p>

<p>Their Pyschology department seems to be over-subscribed and has a waiting list. Not good.</p>

<p>“It is Department of Psychology policy to grant “Fully-Admitted” status to all qualified students who apply. So many students applied and qualified to become psychology majors during Spring and Summer 2010 we could not accommodate all of them in Fall 2010 classes. Consequently, many students were placed on a waiting list. These wait-listed students will be the first students to be able to register for Psyc 210 during early registration for Spring, Summer and Fall 2011. There were so many students on this waiting list we expect these students to fill our Spring 2011 sections of Psyc 210; some of these students who have fewer credit hours earned or who register late in the process will need to wait until Summer or Fall 2011 to take Psyc 210 or 212.”</p>

<p>They have also created a new School of Hospitality, Sport and Recreation Mgmt. This was done by combining the Dept. of Tourism and Hospitality and the Sports Mgmt Dept - which had been under Kinesiology. Have no idea as to the pros and cons of this - but this is one of the areas that interests S2 - so I do check it periodically.</p>

<p>I have to say I find both of these developments a little unsettling - but I guess he is still applying there as a 3rd or 4th choice.</p>

<p>S just visited Texas A&M today. He met with a rep from the business program and he was really excited about the school. It seems like a good fit. If he can stay in the top 10% until the end of this year this will be both an financial and academic safety as he would have no problem getting into the business program as a freshman. Also his standardized test scores won’t really matter for admission. While this is added pressure to be in the top 10 it is also exciting to know there is at least one school that is a good fit that he is excited about and we can afford. There is supposed to be an new Hillel building being built on campus. This time of year it wasn’t possible to meet with anyone from Hillel but we will be exploring this. It is nice to know that there is enough of a Jewish presence for a building to be in the plan.</p>

<p>Thanks again, C43 for info. I’m putting Birthright on the back burner for now. Next thing to plan…graduation party! I’m sure these parties vary as much as BM parties!</p>

<p>Senior year…SOOOO much going on. Trying to juggle senior and freshman schedules…how do you people with multiple children do it? :)</p>

<p>Spectrum: Good luck with Texas A&M…having a Hillel Building scheduled to be built is very exciting.</p>

<p>RVM: I’ve heard of colleges accepting a bunch of students & expecting a certain percentage to go to other schools…however sometimes when too many kids say yes to that school there is an overcrowding issue. It could work itself out over time but I agree, a bit unsettling.</p>