Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>With all the talk about hummus, it hit me, we are going to a friends house for dinner and I was asked to make an appetizer. I hadn’t decided on what yet but this morning I foound a recipe, braved the Christmas shopping traffic at the market and bought some tahini, chick peas and pita bread. …Its so sad to hear about Israeli products being boycotted.</p>

<p>Momjr: So sorry about that, but as RVM said, after finals and before leaving on the trip is fortunate. I’m sure it is good for her to be home right now.</p>

<p>Emilybee: Congratulations on Binghamton!</p>

<p>I don’t expect that most of you would be interest in Texas A&M but over the past couple of days I found out that their Hillel was the first in the US. That was a big surprise to me. The A&M Hillel website has a parent page and I just received a lovely welcoming e-mail from a parent telling me about her kid’s experience at A&M. The other fact that came up in our orientation was that OOS students who get a $1000 scholarship for college (I’m not sure whom this needs to be from, but worth looking into) would also be allowed in state tuition. This is generally a very conservative school and I was surprised how good S2 felt about it. I was also surprised how good I felt about it!</p>

<p>So sorry to hear about your D missing her trip, Momjr</p>

<p>Congrats on all of the acceptances since my last posting. Sorry to hear about the deferrals and rejections :(</p>

<p>In Northern MI for about a week and a half w/ my family. Love spending the time w/ my boys. Enjoy the break from school.</p>

<p>spectrum - that is fascinating about Texas A & M. I would never have guessed that in a million years. I think there are more Jews in Texas than an east coast person would realize.</p>

<p>Stayathomemom mentioned Tulane’s approach to admissions. It worked in our case. S2 applied because of the free App and easy application and was admitted with a generous merit award (which dad liked). Once he visited he fell in love with it, turning down UC-Berkeley among others to attend. He found it full of very high achieving students and to be very friendly to Jewish students. He loves it there after a semester. He came home with a t-shirt from what looked like quite the Hanukkah party sponsored by the Tulane Hillel.</p>

<p>From what I have read this year - the key to Tulane is to apply early! Like in September. Those who applied early got much faster responses and seemed to have a much higher rate of acceptances than those who applied a few weeks later. Tulane gets over 40,000 applications each year - I believe that is the highest number of applications for any private college in the nation. It is a wonderful safety school for a “A” student and worth a try for a “B” student. I have read stories from many “A” students who applied to Tulane as a safety - and then for various reasons ended up attending and are generally very happy. They also give great merit aid to strong students.</p>

<p>Right now there are at least 3 threads on the Parent Forum from parents of seniors who are in panic mode. They are upset because their child was accepted at a “dream school” or worse - an ED school - and now they realize they cannot afford it. This is, IMO, the worst possible outcome - child is accepted, but parent has to say they can’t swing it financially.</p>

<p>Please don’t let this happen to you and your family. Please go to a financial aid website like Financial Aid.org and read about FA. Please use the free calculators and calculate your EFC. Please make sure you have some financial safety schools on your list - these would generally be in-state options that are less expensive than either privates or OOS publics. Please have the conversation with your spouse and child as to what your budget is for college.</p>

<p>It is so frustrating and sad to read some of these threads - people should be happily celebrating their child’s good news and instead they are sick with worry that the FA pkg was not what they expected/hoped for/anticipated and now they just can’t pay for thie college in question.</p>

<p>Don’t let this happen to you. Paying for college is a huge burden for most families. Please spend some time planning and researching this topic now - not when your child is a senior.</p>

1 Like

<p>EmilyB: Congrats on Binghamton. What a nice surprise.</p>

<p>Thanks for all the concern about my daughter. She is very disapointed about missing the trip, but as RVM said it’s lucky that she got sick before she left. The trip leader was very understanding, and she will be able to apply for a future trip. </p>

<p>I know a few Jewish kids who attend Tulane, and they love it. As RVM said, it looks like you need to apply early. They send out a lot of free applications.</p>

<p>This precisely what happened to S2, and he reports to many of his friends at Tulane. Most of his friends were accepted at Ivies and other top schools, but fell in love with the school (and the merit scholarships didn’t hurt either). The yield is not great, but they appear to be looking for those few higher-end students who fall for the school, and accept enough B+ students to make it worth a shot for many kids. Visiting the school is usually what clinches it. And, it is indeed fun.</p>

<p>Good advice, RVM. I know several families who do not consider themselves wealthy that were not eligible for any need-based aid. It’s best to be honest with your child about financial restraints early in the process.</p>

<p>RVM: Just a little Hillel trivia. When I first heard TAMU had the first Hillel this surprised me as well. Not only because it is Texas but also because it is TAMU a very conservative university with a strong military history. According to their Hillel website they were first the TAMC (former name of TAMU) menorah club in 1916 and then became Hillel in 1920. [tamuhillel.org:</a> History](<a href=“http://www.tamuhillel.org/about/history]tamuhillel.org:”>http://www.tamuhillel.org/about/history). However on another site a more likely school is credited with being the first,University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana in 1923,[Hillel</a> History Comes Alive](<a href=“http://www.hillel.org/about/facts/history/default]Hillel”>http://www.hillel.org/about/facts/history/default). So as is typical with history there are some discrepancies. Clearly though Hillel has a very long history at TAMU, and I too would have never guessed it.</p>

<p>I really would have never guessed either one - would have bet on an east coast college - particularly NY - for sure. Very interesting, and yes, my east coast bias is showing! :)</p>

<p>RVM: I just saw your post about FA. I couldn’t agree more. I will add that we were among those scrambling. We never plugged our numbers in but we knew we were in a unique situation. I don’t think we could have convinced every school about this but we were fortunate that S’s choice school did listen to our “unusual circumstances” and we could work things out. We had prepared s about the limits that we could pay but none of us ever really thought that our EFC would exceed the COA, that was a huge surprise when we finally calculated it on FAFSA. </p>

<p>Having grown up in NY and transplanted to TX I could guess that the need for finding a community is greater in other parts of the country. In NY I didn’t have to search for a Jewish community it was always there. I wasn’t in one but there were many sororities that weren’t Jewish by definition but in fact all of the members were Jewish.</p>

1 Like

<p>emilybee: congrats on Bing. Kids love it there and it has a great reputation.</p>

<p>rvm is exactly right about applying early to Tulane. It is best to get the app in to them in September for a timely response.</p>

<p>momjr, Sorry to hear about your daughter and her missed trip! I hope she gets another opportunity soon.</p>

<p>You all won’t believe this, but my mother just told me that she recently found out that her Grandfather was buried in a Jewish cemetery. My Mom says she is not sure exactly when he died but it had to be before 1924. His wife, my Mother’s Grandmother, was not buried with him. Both of them emigrated from France, on the border of Germany sometime after World War I. Would it be unusual for a non-Jewish person to be buried in a Jewish cemetery??</p>

<p>Hearing about the possibility of us being Jewish, my daughter said, “I wonder if I could do a birthright trip??” Apparently a friend of hers just went. I didn’t know she even knew about them.</p>

<p>

Yes it would be unusual today and very unusual before 1924. That might explain why the couple was not buried together.</p>

<p>Although you don’t have matrilineal descent, you likely have a Jewish great-grandparent (your mom’s grandfather). Had your grandparents not emigrated, you can assume your Mom would have been considered Jewish by the Third Reich for having one Jewish grandparent, regardless of what she was practicing at the time. </p>

<p>I think it’s a stretch for your daughter to envision going on a Birthright trip, but for the cost of the travel she could certainly go and visit Israel any time she chooses and take a tour. Friends who have a non-Jewish mother and Jewish father today might request consideration for the free tour, but your D’s story is too many generations removed for the Birthright tour program to consider her Jewish based on that information alone.</p>

<p>Kind of gives you the goosebumps, though, doesn’t it.</p>

<p>paying3tuitions, Definitely a stretch for daughter. She just likes to travel and is in grad school for international education and policy management. I sometimes think her goal in life is to visit as many countries as she can. </p>

<p>Thanks for the quick response. I’m avoiding my stocking stuffing duties…</p>

<p>^always glad to help a fellow procrastinator! I hope your daughter has many adventures and travels, especially in her interesting line of studies! My goal at her age was to go to as many bodies of water as possible in my lifteime, and I count creeks and brooks. So she should count Monaco.</p>

<p>KathieP - fascinating story about your great-grandfather. If he was buried in a Jewish cemetery, I would say, he was Jewish. Especially, if your great-grandmother wasn’t burried with him. If you have any interest in researching this, I would be glad to point you to some resources. Do you know the cemetery? Is it near you…or maybe one of us on the board. You can get a ton of information off of a headstone.</p>

<p>Kathiep - so now you really belong on this thread! Sounds like a very interesting story - you really need to research this further.</p>

<p>Kathiep: What a facinating story. No wonder you felt at home on this thread!</p>

<p>My daughter got a nice e-mail yesterday from one of the Penn Hillel rabbis to say how sorry he was that she was sick and had to miss the trip. For any of you out there with a “A” student, you can’t do better than Penn for a supportive Jewish community.</p>