<p>Momjr: “one of the Penn Hillel rabbis” …right there that says a lot about the Penn Hillel. Most of the schools I have looked at only have one Rabbi. It must have been comforting for her to know that the Rabbi understood her situation.</p>
<p>I"m curious, especially since all of our HS grades are numerical not letters, when you speak of an A student what do you mean in terms of grades and standardized test scores? I expect S is somewhere between a B+ and an A in terms of grades. As far as standardized tests go I think this will put him squarely in the B to B+ range.</p>
<p>spectrum - I would like to know this too ^^. My A- student grade-wise will probably be in the SAT range of the B student (based upon his PSAT scores…since he is not a natural test taker and refuses to prep for the SAT). He would love to attend a school like U Penn, and would do well in that type of academic environment but, lets face it…based upon prior stats threads on CC it is obvious that only 2100+ SAT kids get it (when they are unhooked). We will make what will certainly be an active new thread this spring for next year’s applicants/this year’s juniors who fall in the various lopsided categories and are not URM’s, atheletes, developmental donors, first generation to college etc kids.</p>
<p>Yes, Penn has a very well-staffed Hillel. One of the nice things about a school with a large Jewish population is that they have programming and services geared towards Orthodox, Conservative and Reformed Jews. </p>
<p>In terms of GPA, I’m not sure how numerical grades correlate to a 4.0 scale. If your school has naviance, that will give you the best idea of what grades a student needs to get into different schools. Our school uses a system that benefits the student. Only year-end grades are used to calulate overall GPA, so a student can get a few 'B’s (for a quarter) and still have a perfect 4.0 GPA. It does look like an unhooked student would need close to a 4.0with a very rigorous course load to get into Penn. My daughter said that it’s easier for a bright, well-rounded kid with good, but not amazing, scores to get in ED. Serious EC’s and leadership seem to help also.</p>
<p>Seiclan: Have you considered having your son try the ACT? The ACT requires less strategy than the SAT, so it might suit him better. Why doesn’t he want to prep? Does he understand that most kids do some sort of prep and it will make him less competitive? I can understand if he doesn’t want to take a course, but he should do some online prep or use a practice book just to get familiar with the test. </p>
<p>I think it’s funny that this is one of the few active threads today.</p>
<p>Well - I’m glad I at least have this to do! When I think of a “B” student - I’m thinking of someone who has a GPA in the 80’s if you use a numeric scale - or someone who has an unweighted GPA of 3.0 - 3.7. This would usually correspond with an SAT of about 1180 - 1280 or an ACT of 26 - 29. Of course - these are very rough and general parameters - few students fit in a neat box. </p>
<p>But this is kind of the range that S2 falls into and this is the range that I was thinking of for students that needed college suggestions. Once you have a 3.7 unweighted GPA or higher - you are an A- student. Once you have an SAT over 1300 or an ACT over 30 - you really can pursue more selective schools. They may be reaches - but you have them available to at least be on your list. </p>
<p>So - that’s kind of how I see the dividing line.</p>
<p>I agree with the use of naviance when available. For Penn - I’m thinking pretty much an A student with many honors/AP classes and at least a 30 ACT or 1340 SAT. I would suggest looking at the Penn forum - you will see kids with higher stats who were deferred in the ED round - meaning even if you have the GPA and test scores - it is still a toss-up.</p>
<p>momjr - My son refuses to take the ACT. He actually took it, unprepped of course, in October and bombed. His rational was that “he told me he didn’t want to take it so he wasn’t going to put anything into it”. My son is very stubborn. He will not retake that test although you and I both know that it would be a better test for him. He will not take ANY of my advice or CC knowledge incidently. Sigh. I don’t know what he understands about the other kids taking the test since he refuses to have that conversation with me. He scored in the 92%tile on the PSAT because of his reading and writing (his math was a perfect 80). He is not an easy child to parent these days. He believes in himself, which is a good thing, but is unwilling to “do what it takes” for the standardized tests. Time will tell and with a kid with this attitude, our college list for next year is very up in the air. </p>
<p>He is very bright and charming btw (I know I made him sound like toddler having a SAT tantrum in the prior paragraph). His friends adore him. He takes only the most rigorous academic schedule because he loves it and not caring about his grades or class rank (although he is ranked in the top 2% out of 800 kids in his junior class). He is, as we say, cutting off his nose to spite his face.</p>
<p>Rockville - I think Penn is much more competitive than what you mentioned. I really don’t think that my son could get in with his PSAT scores even applying ED and with my being a legacy. I think he is more a match for CMU (maybe reach tho).</p>
<p>His hs doesn’t have Naviance or anything at all that would allow you to see the stats of his school’s admissions results. I asked the guidance dept about this and they were very taken aback that I would even want to know… I rely on CC for my information now. His HS refuses to keep stats “for privacy issues” even though I told them that they don’t need to identify anyone, just match GPA’s/scores with admission results. For some reason, this is a big secret and I was viewed as a mom who is trying to make waves!</p>
<p>Oh I agree - Penn is extremely competitive for an unhooked applicant. S1 has a friend who was an amazing student in hs - very high stat - who applied ED and was deferred. My point was simply that IF you wanted to put a super reach on the list and IF your student had at least a 3.7 unweighted and a 1340 SAT or 30 ACT - I would say go for it - why not? </p>
<p>I know the testing is a pain in the tush. S2 is taking the ACT again in February - I’ll be happy with a modest gain and we can be done.</p>
<p>Another way to convert numerical scores to a GPA out of 4.0 is this method. </p>
<p>Anything in the 80’s, consider a B. Give it 3 points.
Anything in the 90’s, consider an A. Give it 4 points.</p>
<p>If there is a single final grade for the course, and all courses are a full year long, you can just add those up and divide by the number of courses.</p>
<p>Our school adds a half-point for an honors course and a full point for an AP course, but there are so many different ways to weight that it’s helpful to see an unweighted average, too.</p>
<p>However, if your son is in the top 2% of his class, that suggests he’s probably either a strong A student (or, if not, his school is stingy with A’s). However, if he aims at schools that attract the top of the class he will be in competition, as you note, with kids who have higher test scores. Yet he would probably be very competitive for admission at schools that attract kids outside the tippy-top of the class. We were told at several schools we visited that scores were less important than grades. (My daughter’s scores are better than her grades, so we weren’t thrilled to hear it…that’s why I remember it.)Some schools even have a test-optional strategy available.</p>
<p>So I looked at the Penn info on our large public hs Naviance. In 2010, 54 students applied - 8 were accepted - 6 matriculated. The average accepted GPA was a weighted 4.67 - which indicates pretty much straight A’s with many honors and/or AP courses to get over a 4.0. The average SAT was 1460 and the average ACT was a 33. But - the stats are kind of irrelevant in that the graph looks like a big smush - with red X’s on top of green boxes - meaning kids at the exact same data point - having the same stats - had different results. So - even having the highest of stats is no guarantee. There were data points with a 34 ACT and a 35 ACT (and high GPAs) who were denied. It makes you wonder who gets in?</p>
<p>I agree that these might be very rough parameters. I know of plenty of students within the 3.2-3.5 range with ACTs in the 23-26 range too, or SATs in the 1080 to 1200 range.</p>
<p>Yes, that was my take on Penn too (as well as all the Ivy’s). They are really a crapshoot for anyone and who knows exactly what they are looking to round out their class with on any particular year but it probably is not my very bright but ordinary, white, Jewish boy from a huge and highly competitive public high school in densely populated Broward County, Florida! They are looking for things that stand out, not just test scores but special/unique awards and activities that show specialness. If seiclanson lived in Alaska or in one of the states in the midwest, where he was a standout student and intellect then…maybe he would catch the interest of the Ivy Adcom but, here…unfortunately, like in Long Island, he is “a dime a dozen” in the college admissions process.</p>
<p>Who gets in? Other kids with more or less the same qualifications.</p>
<p>Sometimes there’s some obvious reason why kid A and not kid B got in (geographic diversity, the band needs a euphonium), but sometimes there isn’t. There are just so many top-notch applicants to these schools, now that there is nation-wide (and even world-wide) recruitment, the Common Application, and so forth. I think it was the Dean of Admissions at Stanford who said that he didn’t think he could build a better class out of 30K applicants than out of 15K, because “I just wind up rejecting duplicates of the same kid.” So, while we all think our kids are unique snowflakes, once you consider there are something like 3 million college-bound seniors, it turns out there are several of everything–several valedictorians who star in the musical and won the state track meet and volunteered on a medical mission, etc. </p>
<p>Schools like Penn get a self-selected group of applicants, almost every one of whom is entirely qualified to go there. Maybe 10-20% fall in the “who are they kidding?” category of just reaching way too high, but the rest of them really have “a chance.” Yet–MOST of them do not get in.</p>
<p>I’ve looked at Naviance for a few schools in the next county over that have guest access (maybe even yours, Rockvillemom) because mine doesn’t have it, and I’m amazed at the kids who don’t get in. And I know people who have interviewed for the Harvard Alumni Club for years and pretty much NO ONE THEY HAVE INTERVIEWED, no matter how amazing, has gotten in. And they were amazing. It actually makes me relieved that my kids aren’t aiming that high because the pressure and uncertainty would drive me mad.</p>
<p>I agree completely - I am very happy to have a B student this go-round. I think it is much easier to predict where he will get in - once you have a certain GPA/test score combination - with a B student than with an A student. It seems like all of the A students are vying for admission to the same 20 - 30 schools - making the competition incredibly intense. B students really have so many more options - you have so much less pressure to be admitted to a very impressive school - so it can be more about size, location, fit, etc. </p>
<p>One thing that does come up from time to time is an unusual EC and how much added umphh that gives an application. My son is a teen court juror - which is not really an unusual EC in our area - but maybe it is when you look at a broader pool of applicants. Do you find that to be an unusual EC that would be worth emphasizing on his applications?</p>
<p>RVM, It would be an unusual EC in our area. Perhaps you might not want to emphasize this EC at schools immediately in your area, but I think it is fine to highlight for other schools.</p>
<p>RVM your numbers are pretty much in the ballpark that I expected. </p>
<p>The thing to remember when looking at schools that are highly competitive is that they are pretty much a reach for every student. It seems like for those schools kids need to have great stats and then the soft factors will get crunched however the adcoms crunch them. With admission rates in the low 20’s and below lots of qualified kids don’t get in, and then sometimes they do and there is no way you can predict the results. At least we couldn’t have with S1.</p>
<p>We don’t have naviance and since there is such a small percentage of students going to schools out of state I don’t think we would learn much from it even if we did have it. As for the testing it is difficult. Based on PSAT I expect 1100 to 1200 SAT scores. Over the summer S did some half hearted practice on the ACT and scored in the low 20’s. He’s been flipping back and forth between both and isn’t really committed to either. Any suggestions on how to narrow down which way to go. He hasn’t taken either yet and I’m hoping to sign him up for one or both before this break is over. By the way at the moment based on your conversions I’m guessing he’d calculate to a low A or A- UWGPA but Junior grades aren’t in yet. Our school does count semester grades on the transcript.</p>
<p>Seiclan: Wouldn’t it be nice if our kids would just listen to us? I can understand your frustration. It sounds like your son is very bright, and is capable of pulling SAT scores that would make him competitive for schools like Penn. It’s possible that he’s afraid to try and not get the scores he’d like, so he’s using the lack of prep as an excuse. Even without prep, his scores will probably improve from his PSATs. Have you taken him to visit schools? Maybe that will motivate him to work on the scores. If the final scores still aren’t in line with his grades, you might want to consider test-optional schools or schools that only use the Math/Verbal. We found that a lot of the publics were still only using the math and verbal scores.</p>
<p>In terms of Penn, they do give legacies an admissions boost when they apply ED. My daughter was originally afraid to consider Penn. Her scores were right about their median. She was a strong student with a lot leadership and good EC’s, but nothing earth-shattering. Most of her friends were similar. She did mention that they were all Editors-in-chief of either the school newspaper or yearbook. It also seems that some High Schools have better luck with acceptance. Our High School usually has one acceptance a year, but she know kids from prep schools in NYC and publics in Westchester county that have a lot of acceptances every year.</p>
<p>Our HS doesn’t have naviance, either. The kids post their acceptances, and I’ve paid attention to this over the years. Kids have to be a real superstar to get into MIT, Stanford, or the Ivies. We have better luck with JHU, Georgetown and Vanderbilt, and great luck with Elon, JMU, Delaware, Penn State and VT, in addition to the Maryland Schools.</p>
<p>Rockville - I never heard of a teen court juror so that sounds impressive from where I sit! My son, who woke up at 12:30 today, is currently playing xbox…sigh. </p>
<p>momjr - we visited a few up North schools last summer. DS loved Columbia, and Penn but thought that Muhlenberg might be too small for him (we saw it because of its character and Jewish population…learned from my sister, an alum and CC). He was lukewarm on NYU since he thinks he wants an actual campus. </p>
<p>My son thinks he will improve on the SAT by osmosis, since he has such a fabulous teacher for his AP English Language class (which he is pulling B’s in) this year!!! </p>
<p>January is going to be a rough month here. DS has two weeks of class then midterm exams for four days, which are 25% of his semester grades. Our high school puts both semester grades on the transcripts…so the heat is on. DS is also taking his first SAT on January 22, the day after his last midterm. I am going to be working very hard on my breathing lessons…in, out, in, out…wait…that is too fast!</p>
<p>D1 and I just had a lovely screaming match. It was supposed to be a calm discussion on scheduling out all she had to do over winter break. She has tons of work over break for her 3 AP classes and the only way she will get it done, plus the other things she wants to do is to schedule it out. She wants to take it day by day. Which means she does her fun things, then gives the work a little bit of time, tells herself she will do it all the next day, repeat previous day, end all of a sudden it’s two days before all work is due, stays up all night, gets sick and misses school and is even further behind. Rinse and repeat! </p>
<p>I just wish she would listen. I don’t understand how she can keep doing the sames things over and over and not learn from them. I spent a good part of my career doing scheduling, I know time management, she will just not listen to a thing I say. She says if I stop nagging it will get done. Tried that, didn’t work. </p>
<p>I understand everyone else’s pain with their kids. And it’s not just the S’s. My guess, a little less drama with the boys? Yes, she woke up at noon today and got right on the computer. Now she tells me she needs to run on the treadmill, shower, etc. get together with a friend tonight. It’s already 2 pm. My guess nothing is getting done today. Which adds to the nothing that got done yesterday. I didn’t nag her at all yesterday, everyone deserves a day off now and then.</p>