Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Seiclan - I think our kids must compete against each other at some point. Mine are always on xbox, too! There must be some benefits that we are just not aware of!</p>

<p>Penn and Naviance - like Rockville, our HS naviance has basically the same stats and that “smushy mess of x and green” as well. Echoing, rockville, I too am glad that we will have a more solid app process than that of the wait and see what happens. Much less stressful.</p>

<p>Mhc48- I can’t wait to hear about Miami (ohio) visit! Details please :)</p>

<p>Enjoy the snow to those who are expected to see much accumulation! I plan to use the time with my son to get our list to 20! Thank you snow g-d’s for making him stranded in the house :)</p>

<p>MHC: Your trips sound fun. It makes me just a little bit sad that we’re done.</p>

<p>We stayed in yesterday, since my older daughter is still too sick and exhausted to go anywhere. We actually all watched a movie together last night. I think the last time we did that was last Christmas. My younger daughter is not pleased about the chance for snow today. I’m perfectly content to spend the day watching football.</p>

<p>cherryhill: It would be nice to have a couple of those days down here over break. All we have is frost covering everything. Including our new landscaping that just went in last week…yikes! </p>

<p>I hope you all enjoy the snow. I miss it a little. We love to visit snow, I know living in it is harder.</p>

<p>momjr: I’m glad you were able to find a cozy moment to enjoy together inspite of mono.</p>

<p>On SAT and ACT: Do any of you have any experience with the Princeton review practice tests? I know they have a test that is supposed to be a combination of both and used to predict which would be better. I know from when S1 used the PR SAT review book vs. the CB book he found that the tests were different and even that some of the answers were incorrect. I was wondering if any of you had tried these and if you found them worthwhile. (I may take this one to the SAT/ACT boards as well).</p>

<p>seiclan - sounds like our kids are very similar. If I remember, your son is also interested in CMU? I keep telling my D, that these work habits won’t cut it at CMU. Oy!</p>

<p>jym626 - yesterday sounds like fun, you didn’t want to stick around to watch people make fools of themselves?! </p>

<p>mhc48 - I also look forward to your Miami (Ohio) report. I think we will visit over spring break. </p>

<p>momjr- so sorry that your daughter has mono and had to miss her trip. At least the timing was good, and hopefully, she will be healthy when school starts up. Nothing like some TLC from mom to make a kid feel better.</p>

<p>It looks like the serious snow will miss us. Good luck to everyone in the path of the storm.</p>

<p>OK, D is still asleep, she said she knows she can’t sleep until noon today. I figure by 11 I am waking her up. We have family plans tonight, so she needs to do the stuff she decided she will to today.</p>

<p>We saw the movie The King’s Speech last night. Excellent movie, we really enjoyed it. My DH even stayed awake through the entire movie. That means something.</p>

<p>I have a question that maybe some of you with older kids can help me with. D is talking about doing an internship her senior year. That means either one or two less classes, since they leave school early do go to their internships. Do colleges look favorably at this, or is it better to take more classes?</p>

<p>mdmom-
I think an internship is fine. Real life experience , especially in an area of interest, is , IMO, just as important as a class on the transcript.</p>

<p>Oh, and my the way, we saw plenty of ppl making fools of themselves… including us!! I was chatting with someone and the next thing I know I was grabbed by the oncoming conga line by a man in a silly straw hat-- my husband! :eek: I was hoping they’d put him in a chair, lift it up and sing happy birthday, but that didn’t happen, to his relief.</p>

<p>mdmom: Don’t be too hard on the chicken dance. I don’t know about the rest of the south but it is a Texas tradition. When my husband and I were still Yankees at heart we stopped in on a fair, I think it was in Amarillo, TX, we and most other people danced a few country western dances, with lots of standing around. Then the chicken dance came on. We saw EVERYONE line up and do the chicken dance. All doing exactly the same thing. We thought we had dropped in from another planet!</p>

<p>mdmom: If the internship doesn’t interfere with her academic classes, then it’s a great idea. If it takes the place of core classes, then don’t do it. It’s important to maintain a rigorous schedule even if that means doing the internship after school. There is a lot of latitude with senior schedules, so she’ll probably be able to work it out.</p>

<p>Spectrum2…my S1 did a Princeton review practice SAT test in May of his Jr. year. He would have done the ACT one the week before but had a tournament he had to go to. It basically just gave him a chance to take the test under test conditions. Then went back a few weeks later to have it returned to him. When he took the real thing about 6 months later (after a summer of practicing w/ a test book), he increased his score by about 250 points. They want you to buy their program, but it’s a good way to get practice w/ the test. Didn’t know they had one that combined the 2 to give you a feel for which is a better test. Would be interested in that for S2.</p>

<p>mhc48…also looking forward to hearing about your visit to Miami/Ohio. It’s a school that I’ve been looking at for S2 (although we still have plenty of time), and am interested in hearing your impressions.</p>

<p>mhc - I’m interested to hear what you think about Elon and JMU. We really have no negatives for Elon - but I am always interested in what others think of it. JMU - my concern was the physical size of the campus - very spread out and the issue of overcrowding. I think I posted something a few pages ago about Psychology being over-booked and kids having to be on a waitlist to start a certain course sequence leading to the major. Sp, please do share your impressions.</p>

<p>Everything I’ve read has suggested that the Princeton Review practice tests are not as helpful as the real SAT’s in the College Board book. (Have you looked at the ‘xiggi method’?
<a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/sat-preparation/68210-xiggis-sat-prep-advice-39.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/sat-preparation/68210-xiggis-sat-prep-advice-39.html&lt;/a&gt; ) </p>

<p>And I second the internship advice-- as long as it’s in addition to core classes (might be in place of an elective), it’s great-- shows dedication to her field. You could check with her GC as to how it will be shown on the transcript, too.</p>

<p>spectrum- I was the one drawing the line at the chicken dance. We’ve seen it at bar/bat mitzvahs north and south, east and west for years. I think I first remember it at a cousin’s bat mitzvah in Wisconsin probably 14 yrs ago. Sorry–still can’t handle that dance! </p>

<p>And apologies for the typos above-- meant to say “by the way” not “my the way”</p>

<p>Thanks for the info on internships. I will keep an open mind. I will also schedule a meeting with D’s GC to go over next years schedule. D is also in a signature program at our HS and the internship would be coordinated with that advisor, so I may schedule a meeting with her to. </p>

<p>No fighting with D today (yet!). I asked her what was her plan for the day. She told me. I made an additional suggestion, got a look and left. Of course, I believe she is still reading in bed. Holding my breath and hanging out on the computer!</p>

<p>umich8790 - impressive score increase from studying on his own!</p>

<p>Mdmom: I think that the internship is a good idea, as long as your daughter still takes a full load of academic classes. A lot of the top students at our HS do them, and I think they look good on an application. It will also give your child a chance to check out an area of interest, and might provide some interesting experiences for her essays. Out school lists it as a gifted and talented class, and kids haveto do some presentations.</p>

<p>Been so busy the last couple of days (MIL’s bday, plus H’s family activities) - I missed so much! </p>

<ul>
<li><p>Our HS naviance is a great resource! I think it’s a much better gauge for acceptance info than CollegeBoard.</p></li>
<li><p>I was always worried about D’s study habits - she is queen of procrastination. I was so afraid of what would happen at college. She started out with her ways of procrastination but she’s learned that doesn’t work. She’s also learned what “studying” really means. We really read her the riot act before she went to college and she has really responded. She missed the dean’s list first semester by less than .03! She is very excited about her classes next semester - I’m so happy for her with everything coming together.</p></li>
<li><p>It’s so exciting to see where your kids are getting into colleges. I feel like I know them! I just got S’s midterm schedule (only two during mid-term week); depending on the weather forecast, we may go up to RPI for an info session/tour there on one of his off days. Having fun in this college mode - it’s fun to keep up with all of you while we are “in between” right now.</p></li>
</ul>

<p>We are getting slammed with snow now - through tomorrow, they are predicting. Great day to watch football. H will get fire going in the fire place after he picks D up from work (didn’t want her driving in the snow). Hope you all stay warm and safe today!</p>

<p>umich: Very impressive. That helps me believe he still has a chance to improve significantly. I agree especially impressive because he did it on his own.</p>

<p>Gwen: Thanks for the link for the xiggi method, I was planning to do a search for it. I had read it years ago for S1 but it has been a while.</p>

<p>jym and mdmom: No problem about the chicken dance. It was such an oddity when we first saw it reminds us of laughter and lots of fun. It was back in the early 80’s when we came down here after living in the northwest and northeast and had never seen it in any other part of the country. I’m amused that it has made its way around to country.</p>

<p>So here’s my dilemma after visiting TAMU. S says unless he found an amazing school that he could get into he doesn’t see any reason to leave Texas. I love the idea of him staying here and (provided he stays in the top 10%) he can get by with just applying to one school and eliminate all of the stress. So why do I keep thinking I should take him to a couple of other schools in different parts of the country. Part of me keeps saying, “keep it simple” part is saying, “he needs to know what’s out there”. Has anyone else dealt with this. S is making this so easy, is there a reason to make it harder? After dealing with S1 I feel that I am not giving S2 equal opportunity if I don’t broaden his horizons. But then it was S1 who drove the train to go to college OOS. We just supported it, perhaps doing less is supporting S2 in the same way. Any thoughts out there?</p>

<p>For those who this applies to enjoy the snow!!!</p>

<p>I really hope you folks getting hit with snow have a chance to enjoy it!!!</p>

<p>First - hugs to your D, momjr. I’m so sorry to hear she’s dealing with mono. I hope she can get on her feet soon. I definitely know the feeling.</p>

<p>My comment about test prep: D2 was always a mediocre tester, and had pretty low PLAN and PSAT scores. She did a bit better on the “real” ACT spring of Jr. year. Then she did excellently fall of senior year. I would say her success was 50% maturation and 50% test prep - and the test prep was 50% subject-based (with the book ACT sells you) and 50% general test-taking “tricks” that she learned from a friend who’s an SAT tutor. This friend also told her, “Don’t take it a 3rd time just for a roll of the dice - your first 2 scores were really similar. The only way you’ll really change it is by prepping.”</p>

<p>About dealing with the second child: I think the best way to support these kids in this process is to listen to them. If he’s saying something he’s really thought about and which to you, knowing him, feels like it makes sense, I’d just go with it. With our 2, it’s been very important to D2 to feel like we “care” as much about her process, of course, but also very important that we’ve done it the right way for HER. </p>

<p>Ironically, she’s applying to 2 schools that were on D1’s list (but she didn’t end up applying to because of her ED acceptance). D2 clearly feels she came to choose these schools very much on her own - and definitely for different reasons. She doesn’t even mention that her sister “might have” gone there.</p>

<p>In our family, D1 has gone to school far away, and that was a prime goal. D2 has a mix of options, and at this point while she leans toward going far away, I think she’ll think very hard about any acceptances that are closer. She knows distance has its ups and downs. Maybe spectrum’s S has observed and thought about that and knows what he wants?</p>

<p>As for winter break work getting done, count me in among the nailbiters. This week D has 2 apps to do (and we’re taking the CommonApp poster’s advice to have them done by the 30th), plus audition prep for both acting and music. She also has some reading for school, but that’s least on her mind right now. She hasn’t said a word since vacation started Tuesday - and I let her alone through the holiday (we’re a blended-tradition family), also through her BF’s departure for a 10-day vacation last night. </p>

<p>This morning she told her her plan to proceed, and it was very clear she wants no advice or tinkering from me. She also told me about some nightmares she’s had about things not working out. So I think she’s got enough pressure on her mind, and I’ll just be a cheerleader right now. We’re leaving Tuesday for a 5-day trip, just the two of us, and she says getting away will be a good time to focus and get everything done. </p>

<p>I trust her … and I worry … mostly I just hate seeing her so burdened, but soon this part will be over. And it absolutely will be the way of life for several more years. I’m shocked college D didn’t come home sick and completely disintegrated. There are lots of ups and downs, lots of pressures, and so many time crunches that you just can’t completely avoid when you’re a student. But then that segment is over, and you get a break, only to move on to the next. It’s hard to watch, and hard to know what to do.</p>

<p>I guess with this, too, it’s a question of listening to them AND knowing them well. This D has pulled a lot of successes together in the past few months and I know all will turn out fine. That’s the message I hope she hears from me more than anything.</p>

<p>Emmybet, thank you for the helpful post, especially as it relates to SAT prep and dealing with the second child. Good luck to your D with the apps and auditions!</p>

<p>Not quite the same story, Spectrum2, but my S1 decided to only apply to 3 schools, all w/in driving distance, knowing that he would most likely go to our state school (Michigan). I felt the same way about us not visiting and considering other schools. Now, however, we are in Dec., know where he is going, and all of the pressure is off. It might not be the same, but I keep thinking that I shouldn’t buy into all of the hype. </p>

<p>I knew I wanted to go to U-M when I was in high school, only applied there and Mich State as a back-up. My younger sister only applied to Michigan. They were different times as far as getting into these schools, but knowing where you want to end up, and only applying there, is the same.</p>

<p>I’m guessing that for 85% of kids, close to home is the right place for college. It’s a huge step even if you’re only going an hour away, after all. There are definitely kids who have good reasons for going far, and that’s great – but, if a kid wants to stay closer to home, would just be glad! Less worry and distance if and when something goes wrong, and still plenty of independence. They do need to know what’s out there, but they have long lives ahead of them, and college is a first step.</p>