Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Spectrum2, I think it is fine to go with a kid’s sense of him/herself if that sense is not formed based upon spurious opinion with little data. It is OK to treat different kids differently depending upon who they are. We had a similar situation.</p>

<p>ShawSon who is now a sophomore at an elite LAC, applied to 16 schools. He was a very ambitious kid and much smarter than your average top-of-the-HS-class kid, but seriously dyslexic. We just didn’t know which schools would love him (dyslexic kid with great grades, 99+ percentile SAT scores, interesting ECs including writing a novel that publishers have expressed interest in) and and which would say, “He can’t handle the work here.” So, he applied to lots of schools.</p>

<p>Our second, ShawD, is also quite bright but without the same drive and need to win or to triumph over adversity. She doesn’t like pressure and especially not the pressure of college admissions. Although we started talking about US schools and visited one, we also looked at Canadian schools (ShawWife is Canadian and the kids are dual citizens) which admit largely based upon grades in junior/senior year (and to a lesser extent board scores for US residents). We went up there for a visit to six schools and she said, “I love these two. I’m only applying to them and I prefer either to any US school on my list. If I get in, I’m done. If I don’t, I’ll apply to more Canadian and maybe some US schools.” ShawWife was concerned that somehow ShawD was selling herself short and kept pushing for US applications. I thought ShawD knew herself. She picked the two schools where all students and alumni love the school (that may be mild, actually). They are no worse than the US schools in quality and in some dimensions better. So, just two. She already got into the first and will hear from the second two weeks after they get her end of first semester transcript. End of story. End of pressure.</p>

<p>She seems to have chosen as sensibly as any of the other kids who have been panic-stricken since junior year. She visitied ShawSon’s school and said, half an hour into the tour, “I don’t want to go here. There’s too much pressure.” She has a sense of where she will perform well. We’re going with it.</p>

<p>Like you, ShawWife feels a bit guilty that we should do more. I’m content. The different kids need to be treated differently.</p>

<p>A lot has been mentioned about children going far away to college vs. closer to home. It’s really an individual’s families decision…so many reasons come into play and where in the country the family lives.</p>

<p>My sister sent her son 16 hours away by car because of a full music scholarship to a top university. My son will be going an hour and a half away…our own family prefers closeby(within a few hours) for undergrad. and anywhere in the country you want to go after that for grad. school, law school, etc. We looked at schools for S that were pretty far away, but in the end he was glad to have a fabulous college to go to that also was not that far from home.</p>

<p>Spectrum: It sounds like your S would like to stay in TX, sounds wonderful! (Every child and their needs are different).</p>

<p>UMich: My sister met her H at Michigan State…she was getting a Master’s, he was getting a second bachelors…at a Hillel dinner! :)</p>

<p>Cross posted with Shawbridge, but message is the same…every child is different…listen to what they want…he may decide to stry in TX, but go abroad junior year, that may be enough for him!</p>

<p>Gwen Fairfax, Slithey Tove in post #2253 described a longitudinal study that had to do with decisions to go near or far from college. One conclusion of the study was that girls (but not necessarily boys) who traveled farther from home for college developed higher self-esteem. Here’s the key part of his/her (sorry can’t remember) post:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Emmybet and everyone else, thanks for your support. It’s been a tough week, but I’m trying to keep it all in perspective. When she originally called and said she had a big lump on her neck, we were worried about much more serious illnesses. She’s feeling better today and is starting to get bored, which is a good sign.</p>

<p>Spectrum, I understand how you feel about whether your son isn’t considering all his options. If he’s willing, it wouldn’t hurt to consider one or two schools out of state. On the other hand, I assume that he’s visited his brother at school, so he knows what he’s passing on. As others have said, every kid is different. A lot of kids in our area just apply to Maryland schools due to financial concerns.</p>

<p>Momjr: </p>

<p>Not sure if I said how sorry I was that your D has mono and had to cancel her birthright trip…hope she feels better real soon. Also, hope it’s not too difficult to be waitlisted again for another trip…</p>

<p>Haven’t been on cc for a few days…I’ve been baking for a few parties we just attended…I’m not a baker, I prefer to cook savory things when going to parties, but this time I made baked items…yum.</p>

<p>I wrote earlier tonight that I’d prefer my kids to be within a few hours of driving distance by car when going for undergrad. degree…however we are discovering a downside to that is that sometimes you may not want to go to college with kids you went to high school with! But honestly, we just didn’t want the hassle and expense of dealing with airplanes and their schedules. Every one is different. Slitheytove is sending her D clear across the whole country…I give her a lot of credit for that and I’m sure her D will have a fabulous experience…Emmybet: sounds like you’ve done that with D1 too… really, I guess you take your cues from your child.</p>

<p>momjr - sorry to hear about your d’s illness - hope it’s a mild case! We know a young man who had the exact same thing happen a couple of years ago and he ended up taking the birthright trip at the next opportunity (summer, I think) and had a great time. And he got to be nursed back to health by mom, which was a good thing.</p>

<p>Thanks CCC and stradmom. She will be able to apply for another trip. The timing for Penn’s next trip probably won’t work out for her, but she’ll get on one eventually. Other than the trip, it was very lucky that she was finished with finals and already home when the worst of the illness set in.</p>

<p>I prefer to have my kids a few hours from home, but it doesn’t always work out. My older daughter is two hours away, with easy Amtrak service, and that’s been great. My younger daughter will need to fly most of the time, but it’s only a one hour flight, and there are flights almost every hour between Baltimore and Boston. She would have preferred a school with easy train service, and seriously considered NYU, GW, and AU. She spent two weeks in Boston this past summer, and had no problem with the distance. I think she’ll be fine, but I may need to visit Boston a few times next year.</p>

<p>Both of my daughters thought UMCP was too close and had too many people from our area. I’m sure that they would have been fine there, but I doubt that they would have branched out as much.</p>

<p>Emmybet,Umich,Gwen,Shawbridge,Chocchip and Momjr: Thank you for your thoughtful replies. S2 has good reasons for his choice and it is a good fit. I’m thrilled to keep him close by (relatively speaking, it is still 3 hours away.) He however has not spent any time on college campuses and he has not been to his brother’s school. Everytime we have gone he has been in school. There is a really nice small college less than an hour’s drive from our home so I think I will take him on a tour of that school just to help him get a small school feel. I will continue reading and looking at schools around the state and country and show him anythat looks like a good choice for him on paper. Unfortunately the only 2 small schools in the state that suit him are TCU and SMU. Two names that result in a knee jerk reaction of, “no way.” If he chooses to do a road trip we’ll do one if possible. If he feels that there is no need then we’ll go with that. Thank you for helping me to work this out. Unlike his brother this is the kid that I expect will grow happily where planted. I’m delighted to plant him in our home state. Thank you for helping me loose the guilt and also for helping to prevent my making S2 a little crazy about this. </p>

<p>For now our focus is back on the SAT. Thanks to all of you who commented on that as well. I love hearing about students who made major improvements between their junior and senior year. For now he’s doing 30 minutes/day at least during the break. As long as he is SAT focused I guess I’ll leave him there. We may go the practice test route through PR. I’d love for him to do a practice ACT at home but I don’t believe I could get him to.</p>

<p>spectrum2 - do try to get him on a few college visits - even if he is happy staying in Texas - show him some different sized schools and different types of locations. My understanding is that some of the msot well known Texas schools are kind of in the middle of nowhere and then you have UT in Austin - which I understand is an amazing college town - so lots of variations.</p>

<p>Personally - I love visiting colleges and would be happy to take S2 to see a few more - but he seems kind of done. He has his list - says he is fine with all of them - and that’s it. He feels he would be happy at any of them - so there you go. Like you - I would be happy to expose him to more options - but he is content with what he already has in mind.</p>

<p>Spectrum: If he hasn’t visited any campuses, I think it’s a good idea to show him different
types of schools, as RVM suggested. Our school has a lot of professional days when the students are off, and we found that these days worked well for visits. We also visited a few schools on Saturdays, which worked out fine also.</p>

<p>I think you’re right to stick with the SAT for now. If he’s doing the prep and making progress, he should be fine. I do think it’s a good idea to take one of the full practice tests that Princeton Review or Kaplan offer if he’s not taking a prep course. I think the full practice tests were the most beneficial part of the SAT course my daughter took. It helps a lot with pacing and also helps reduce anxiety about taking the test. Some of the high schools in our area also offer short, inexpensive weekend or evening review courses that focus primarily on strategy. These courses are a nice option for kids who don’t want to take a long review course.</p>

<p>Emmybet: Good luck to your daughter as she finishes those final applications.</p>

<p>So far the only schools he visited were UT Austin and TAMU. That was this past week and he was surprisingly focused on these visits. He in fact passed some things that would have been more fun to go even though we gave him the option of cancelling. He even shushed H and me when we were talking during the presentation. I think he is very willing to explore if the schools are appealing to him on paper or by word of mouth. </p>

<p>RVM I’m trying to figure out which well known schools in remote places you might be thinking of. I can’t think of any well known Texas schools that are in remote locations. (Although it is entirely possible that what seems remote on the East coast doesn’t seem remote to me.) College Station the home of TAMU I guess could be considered remote but it is well known as a college town. </p>

<p>S is scheduled to visit Texas Tech on President"s day but I’m not sure if he is still going to be interested in this. I might change that for the small private nearby just so he can see what a small school is like. This school doesn’t have a business school so it wouldn’t work for S even if he liked it. TCU and /or SMU are also possibilities, but from a Jewish perspective I prefer TAMU. From this thread Elon, CofC and JMU would be schools I would encourage him to look at. We also may go to the west coast to visit S1 over spring break and I had thought about scoping out that area as well. I have also enjoyed exploring college campuses but I find myself treading with S2 more carefully than with S1. S1 had his sights set on schools far away that he knew he might not get into and that we might not be able to afford. S2 is perfectly happy with a school that he probably can get into and we can afford. I’m a little afraid of opening his eyes and making him less happy in the process.</p>

<p>We woke up to A LOT of snow this morning, Spectrum, come on up! :)</p>

<p>I don’t mind the snow, but the bitter cold bothers me in my old age! Now I see why people move to warmer climates!</p>

<p>Spectrum: Refresh my memory on S1? Where is he at college now? How are the logistics? He’s enjoying himself? Does he like being far away?</p>

<p>It also sounds from what you’re describing that your S2 is taking the college tours seriously and listening and taking it all in…if he seems happy & content that’s all that parents want! He may have other experiences in college that take him out of TX! Does he want to visit a college campus outside of TX?</p>

<p>I don’t know anything about TAMU, but you say it’s 3 hours away, certainly enough away for him to feel “on his own” but still close enough if needed…I know, the job of a parent is always a balancing act…</p>

<p>spectrum - I have family living in north Dallas. Their older daughter was not in the top 10% - so UT in Austin was out. They did not like the area of either Texas A & M or Texas Tech - described it to me as being in the middle of nowhere - so that’s what I am going by. I have never seen any of these schools. This girl started at the University of Arkansas - transferred to the University of Oklahoma after one semester to be with her BF - and now that they have broken up - is talking about trying to transfer into UT-Austin.</p>

<p>Spectrum: What’s the Texas top 10% policy?</p>

<p>CCC:I’d love to visit.Snow is a blast to visit but I know can be a hassle to live in. Send us few flurries :). It is always exciting when there is any snow here.</p>

<p>S1 is in an LAC on the west coast. He loves it. He comes home twice a year. He was sick once but nothing major. He has really made a very smooth transition, he has had no issues with the distance that I know of. He’s looking at travel abroad for a semester next year without blinking an eye.</p>

<p>S2 really is taking the tours seriously. I was really impressed both with how attentive he was and the way he held his own when speaking with a b-school rep. After the visit to TAMU he said that unless it was a much “better” school he really didn’t see any reason to go out of state. He did express some apprehension about being out of Texas. I think by better he means a school that would improve his employment opportunities after graduation. He is really thinking that way. TAMU’s B-school had 86% of their graduating class either employed or going to the graduate school of their choice at the end of last year. I’m not sure but I think he would define better as a school with a statistic in the mid 90’s. The question about employment stats was his. I don’t know that he is completely committed to the idea of B-school and he needs a school that will allow him to have lots of options to explore.</p>

<p>RVM: You make a good point we really didn’t discuss life in college station that much. He has a friend who lives there so I know he can discuss it with her. There were few students on campus when we visited, again a reason not to make a hasty decision. Genereally if you speak to anyone who went to TAMU they are filled with pride about the school and exude a sense of community. He also has a friend in Lubbock (home of Texas Tech). He has some reservations about that area being boring but before visiting TAMU (and getting his soph rank) he was ready to visit. The top 10% rule is either a blessing or a curse depending on where you fall. I will be on edge about it until the Junior rankings come out. As I suspected your definition (your Dallas family’s) definition of remote is different from mine. There are some seriously remote areas in Texas, some with colleges but none of them that I can think of would be called well known. As for UT Austin, S liked it but felt that there was a greater community feel at TAMU. Also admission to the B-school for him as a freshman is unlikely. I think students need to be in the top 2-3% of there class for automatic admit to it.</p>

<p>momjr: Any student in the top 10% of their HS graduating class of a Texas HS (actually some variations on the point about the school’s location) is automatically admitted to the state school of their choice. This was recently modified for UT Austin and the automatic admit percentage will vary from year to year but for my S2’s year it will be top 9%. Automatic admit gets the student into the school but not necessarily into the school within the school of their choice.</p>

<p>Thanks Shawbridge, that’s very interesting about girls self-confidence and school distance. I can’t help but think that the phrase “women feel more pressure than men to satisfy parental wishes by staying close to home” might be the important one there. Anyone who makes parental wishes a major priority in such an important decision might be subject to confidence issues already. (Of course parental advice, parental financial need, etc. must be taken into account!) But ‘parental wishes’…I can think of so many that can undermine, from prestige seeking, to staying close at hand or studying a field the parent finds appealing. A kid who tries to satisfy that kind of parental wish…well, I was one of those kids once, and it wasn’t good. </p>

<p>My power is flickering, but D has a full day of canceled rehearsals, so I am grabbing the chance for some major SAT prep! And rethinking the college visits to Ithaca and Syracuse planned for late January, as the snow swirls here.</p>

<p>Shawbridge, another thanks for passing on an analysis of the connection between self-confidence and school distance. </p>

<p>I also really appreciate your thoughtful discussion of the respective college application/selection processes of your son and daughter. My D2 (a junior) sounds somewhat similar to your D: very bright, but not as highly motivated/driven as her older sibling. D2’s college process will be quite different, but hopefully in the end as rewarding as D1’s. D2 has a great attitude and believes that she will be happy, and make the best of her college experience, wherever she goes. But she also sets high standards in her own way, and finding a good college fit is still important.</p>

<p>I’m glad we don’t live in Texas. That 10% rule sounds like a lot of additional stress. Does it force a really competitive atmosphere among the kids?</p>

<p>I’m jealous of those of you who got a lot of snow. Somehow the storm came up the east coast and just left a dusting here.</p>