<p>momjr - I’m glad we don’t have such a policy here in MD - that’s for sure. Whether or not a student is in the top 10% of his class or not has a lot more to do with the hs than the student. In our area - you could have straight A’s and still not be in the top 10% of the class.</p>
<p>At this point its not for me to support or contest the policy. It is the law and we deal with it. It was originally adapted to give students in disadvantaged communities opportunities for representation in the state’s more competitiive schools. The competitiveness varies from one district to another. It isn’t unusual for a student to “move” into a less competitive area for their senior year if they are just below the top 10% in a more competitive school. Students who are not in the top 10% still have opportunity to be admitted to the top schools but it is a lot more competitive and also less likely that they will get into their major for freshman year if they have a major that is very desireable. For S2 if he is in the top 10 or above at the end of this year, I guess I will love it because he will have a for sure safety that he wants to go to. If he is in the top 10.1 or below I will hate it because the stress will continue. Either scenerio is entirely possible. Unfortunately after getting his ranking S2 has gotten a little too cocky for his own good. I’m really trying to keep him grounded.</p>
<p>Oh Momjr: To answer your question about competitiveness, oddly enough I haven’t seen this in S’s school which I would say is middle of the road with a focus on football :). I expect other schools might get more competitive. More than competitive I see more strategy getting calculated into course selections for some students. S2 went with his heart and not with strategy so I hope it doesn’t come back to bite him.</p>
<p>Spectrum: I was thinking about course selection also. Our school calculates both weighted and unweighted GPA and class rank, which helps balance things out. It’s great that your son has a shot at top 10%. I hope it works out.</p>
<p>Thanks Momjr! Please update us on your daughter.</p>
<p>Spectrum: Thanks for asking about my daughter. She’s feeling a little bit better, but is still really exhausted. She hasn’t had the energy to leave the house for the past few days. I’m really thankful that she got sick before she left for Israel. She would have been miserable on the trip. </p>
<p>RVM: I’m also glad that we don’t have that system in Maryland. I think that the competition among the kids would bet ruthless. We already have some cheating problems at our HS, and I think this would make it worse.</p>
<p>Not sure if this has been shared already, but here is an interesting blog post from the Executive Director of the American Jewish Committee offering defense of Israel–may help kids asked to stand up for Israel among their college peers.</p>
<p>[How</a> can you defend Israel? | Blogs](<a href=“http://blogs.jpost.com/content/how-can-you-defend-israel?tr=y&auid=7563358]How”>http://blogs.jpost.com/content/how-can-you-defend-israel?tr=y&auid=7563358)</p>
<p>Beautiful article - thanks for sharing. I think Israel is judged more harshly than any other country - so it is wonderful to read such a moving tribute.</p>
<p>that article actually brought tears to my eyes. thank you for posting, DP.</p>
<p>around our dinner table we talk often about how badly Israel needs a much better PR firm. only half kidding.</p>
<p>Just curious, are there any active homeschool students on this thread? Can you PM me, please!</p>
<p>Working on our list! Took a break to catch up on my “college search” and I found this interesting thread today-</p>
<p><a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/1058093-5-gpa.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/1058093-5-gpa.html</a></p>
<p>It made me question some of our choices and maybe a reminder to look deeply into the course selection, maybe some professors syllables to really grasp what the college workload would look like.</p>
<p>I’m wondering if its better to be a big fish in a smaller pond?</p>
<p>Thank you for sharing that article Deskpotato. That is one to hold onto and one to share.</p>
<p>cherryhillmom - those sentiments and the wise counsel of Yabeyabe have led me to believe that is very true. I think for the “B” student in particular - who may need more help than an “A” student in adjusting to the workload and demands of college - this could be very true. I know that other parents have shared that large universities do have writing centers and resources to help struggling students - but I still feel that a smaller school wiill catch the problem earlier and be more proactive in reaching out to the student and offering assistance - while a larger university is more likely to let a student flunk out. I know I am generalizing - but based on anecdotal info - this is the conclusion I have come to.</p>
<p>Conceptually I’d like to agree with RVM, but based on my nephew’s flunking out of Middlebury for not doing his classwork…or even going to classes, and my own son’s ability to get writing help and tutoring at UMich, I’m more skeptical.</p>
<p>Maybe a kid could “get away” with no one noticing his absence or caring about his grades more easily at a big school, if he or she tried to hide it and his parents didn’t know, (which might happen if he or she is clinically depressed or overwhelmed) but I’m beginning to think that if the problem is recognized there is likely far more help available in a larger campus.</p>
<p>Thanks for sharing the article, Deskpotato. It made me even sadder that my daughter missed the trip. </p>
<p>Cherryhillmom: I think that it is important to find schools that are good academic fits for your kid. We tried to find schools that would be challenging without being overly intimidating. One thing that I’ve noticed on visits is that some schools require students to average 5 courses a semester, while others only require 4. It’s also worth considering if your son/daughter will do better on a quarter system where they might only take 3 courses at a time, but will have mid-terms and finals more often.</p>
<p>We stuck with schools where our daughters were at least at the median for test scores. I think it would be tough to go to a school where you’re in the bottom half.</p>
<p>I think whether a kid is at a large or small school, they need to be self-motivated. I think this is where all our discussions of HS parents pulling back and letting kids handle school issues on their own comes into play. Like MHC, my daughter has taken advantages of the support resources available at her school.</p>
<p>I agree with momjr, and I also feel the same way that RVM feels. </p>
<p>I also know B students who have done well in big Us by picking majors in small departments (another way that a student might want to go). Still, that could be life altering if one wants an undergraduate degree in business, but to be in a small department one changes their major to Family Studies (I am not picking on this major, it is just one that I chose at random).</p>
<p>momjr - I agree with you completely on avoiding schools where S2 would be in the bottom half of the freshman class. No reaches on his list for a reason. I’d like to see his ACT score go up to improve his chances of admission and merit aid to the schools already on his list - but even if he does increase his score - we are not adding any reaches. I guess it does come back to fit and my gut tells me that a school he scraped into would not be the right fit for him.</p>
<p>mhc - I’m sure there are exceptions - but I just think that speaking generally - it is harder to fly under the radar at a smaller school. But certainly not impossible - as the recent suicide tragedy at Muhlenberg demonstrates.</p>
<p>Incidentally - some of these issues are why we have found so much to like about Elon. Freshman take 4 4-credit courses - which I think is a more manageable workload that 5 3-credit courses. They also take a course called Elon 101 to help them with the transition to college and to catch any problems early. I’m sure many other colleges have similar support systems in place - but Elon’s efforts really caught our attention.</p>
<p>what a great article. thanks for sharing.</p>