<p>Chocchip: Our kids sound a lot a like. My son loves to read, anything and everything - just is a poor writer. His gym teacher had to take a book out of his hands last year, he was trying to run a mile while reading.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I LOVE this. :)</p>
<p>This <em>might</em> work on the track. Cross-country with tree roots could prove gruesome…</p>
<p>Guess what Mom24boys!</p>
<p>My S2 loves reading too and is also a poor/average writer! Although I believe his writing has improved quite a bit these last few years. He got an A- in English, so I’m not complaining. There is a writing workshop class at our h.s. that I tried to sign him up for as a freshman, but upperclassmen get first dibbs, so I may have him try again sophomore year.</p>
<p>Funny re: reading while running in gym class! :D</p>
<p>I will join the club of moms of kids who love to read but aren’t the best writers. D struggles with writing and English is usually her worst grade.</p>
<p>I made my son take a double period of English Freshman year to improve his writing, big mistake, just lowered his GPA. His writing has improved this year because he talked his way into AP Gov’t without having taken Social Studies Freshman year - had to make room for the double English.
Next year I am moving him up to honors English agianst teachers advice because his biggest complaint about English is they never read a book. They spent 2 quarters on Othello and only got to Act 3 of 5, he finished it on his own. They also did some of it in comic book form. Last year, Shakeapeare was “translated” and they were not allowed to read in in Olde English.</p>
<p>A couple of points:</p>
<ol>
<li><p>Most important thing in course selection is matching your child’s interests and trying to get a great teacher. This is far more important than regular vs. honors vs. AP level.</p></li>
<li><p>If your child’s practice PSAT score has the potential to become National Merit, then have your child take PSAT prep course if you are both willing (time and money).</p></li>
</ol>
<p>Mdcissp
- Totally agree on course selection, he always wants to push himself, I held him back in English hoping to improve the writing. The school even looked into moving him this yr, after seeing his PSAT scores, but couldn’t make it work.
- Prep class question - How do you judge the quality of a class? What do you get from a class that you don’t from the practice tests.</p>
<p>Mom24boys, your son might be really bored in a class if he already had a 205 on the PSAT! Since he seems so self-motivated, you might just get two PSAT prep books (there may not be any more out there, actually) and then have him practice the exercises and tests for about 10 minutes a day. He will probably gain 10 points just from being a year older and wiser, and he might gain another 5 points from prepping, which would bring him up to NMF level for MD.
After he is through with that, you can start with SAT prep! One of my favorite ways for that is to go to majortests.com and click on the SAT prep link. There are little 10 to 15 question quizzes that he can do. If he submits the answers, he can see what he got wrong with an explanation. I like this because it is in such small doses - 15 minutes a day.</p>
<p>Just wanted to share some great news. DD started classes this week at UDel. Three of her classes are Jewish studies related (Hebrew, Philosophy and a 1 credit requirement for her Jewish studies minor) – the way the profs cancelled classes for Passover, it looks like she can come home for the first seder! She is so happy because she loves Passover! She’ll be home for less than 24 hours, but it’s really not a bad train ride and not expensive. Plus it was her idea to come home for the seder (not mine). There’s a positive for going to a college with easy access to home!</p>
<p>Linymom - That is great news. It shows yet another of the many reasons why a thread like is wonderful.</p>
<p>I think prep classes are not so good for bringing up scores from very, very good to great. They are better for the kids who are in the middle and want to get into the “very good” range.</p>
<p>My daughter scored in the NMF range sophomore year, and when she sat down to take the practice tests ahead of the junior year PSAT, she was pretty much getting all the questions right, so there really wasn’t anything to “study.” Unfortunately, regression towards the mean set in for the “real thing” and she wound up with a score that would have qualified in about 42 states, but not our state. It’s just a matter of one or two questions either way that makes or breaks the score at that point. There isn’t much a prep class can do.</p>
<p>On PSAT prep: It has seemed to me that classes designed specifically for PSAT are more likely to attract strong test takers because really no one else really needs to prep for the PSAT. I think the best way to assess a course is to speak with others who have taken it if possible. One unhappy lesson that I learned from prepping is that at least in S1’s case it would have been really helpful if S practiced prior to the test in Sept and Oct. S1 prepped for the PSAT over the summer, on his practice tests (which were former PSAT’s) he scored in the upper 220’s, then once caught up in his EC’s which even had required activities the night before the test and AP classes S didn’t review in Sept and Oct. Hard as a I tried I couldn’t make it happen. He missed our state cutoff by 2 points If I were to do it again I would have been on trying to eek some review time into his school day if all of the other demands were in place. I would also be on top of getting him out of EC’s the week of the test. At the time the test snuck up so quickly by the time I realized how soon the test was I couldn’t make any changes. BTW S1 also scored a 205 as a Soph.</p>
<p>Levirm: Thanks for the shot update. S got his meningitis vaccine last time you brought this up. We’ll go over the rest on his next visit. </p>
<p>LINDYMOM: That’s another reason for me to avoid encouraging S2 to look at too many OOS schools! Having one able to commute home easily sounds really nice!</p>
<p>I think the PSAT test prep is especially good if you think your child will not otherwise give the time and attention to do adequate test prep study on their own. It takes a lot of discipline to study on your own. Test prep gives a lot of feedback and structure that makes sure your child does prepare. </p>
<p>Rockville Mom has a great son who will go through the entire test prep book studying on his own. Be honest with yourself–do you think your child has the time, initiative, motivation and desire to complete test prep book/CD on his own without the structure of a class or help of a tutor?</p>
<p>mdcissp: You are exactly right about test prep. While I decided that DD’s test scores were not going to be a reflection of how much I was willing to pay, I did sign her up for some lower cost courses - one private, one at school, one at the public library. She kept telling me that it was all repetitive. LOL. I told her that was the point! And explained that, since she wasn’t doing it on her own, then she had to go to these classes.</p>
<p>I’m going to sign up DS for a course in the fall (junior year) so he can learn the test-taking strategies. Then we can see how the PSAT goes and what he does on his own. At the point, I will consider further tutoring.</p>
<p>In some towns, SAT test prep is a competitive sport (not here becuase of different economics). However, I can see how, if you can afford it, you will do all you can to help your D/S reach their potential on these tests. Some families can do it on their own (I will try to follow RVM’s lead) and some can’t for various reasons.</p>
<p>SAT scores are in. D did very well. Increased her math score substantially, so the private tutoring paid off for that. She didn’t study for CR or WR this time around, and had a 10 point swing in each of those, going different ways, so those netted out. But those scores were high to begin with! So happy! Her math + reading scores qualify her for a lot of merit aid at some colleges with automatic stat driven scholarships. She wants to get a little higher, so she will take it one more time. Now just have to figure that out along with the ACT exam. But she will need a 32 or better on the ACT to beat her SAT score according to the conversion charts, so not sure if the ACT will turn out to be the better test for her. We will see what happens when she starts practicing for that.</p>
<p>I really think that you have to know your kid to figure out what test prep works best for them. Some kids can study on there own, others do fine in a class and some need the one on one tutoring. This kid needed the one on one tutoring to push her over the hump in math. Now I think she is motivated to study on her own to increase the scores just a little bit more.</p>
<p>Mdmom: Congratulations on the improved SAT score! It’s great that your daughter has a high score so early in the process. If her ACT practice tests aren’t in the same ballpark, it’s probably a better use of her time to just stick with the SAT. </p>
<p>I agree that you really need to figure out what type of prep will work out best for your kid. Some kids need the structure of a class, others learn best with one-on-one tutoring, and some work best on their own. I think that the best way to motivate a kid to prep is to take them on a college visit to a match or reach school.</p>
<p>Deskpotato: I’m sorry that your daughter just missed the cut-off for NMF. I think it’s really unfair that the cut-offs vary by state. It doesn’t really make sense for a national competition.</p>
<p>LINYMOM - so glad the schedule worked out for her to come home for Passover - that is fabulous.</p>
<p>On test prep - I agree 100% that what you need to do will vary by child. Paid test prep is very common in our area - with many families spending $1000+ on a private tutor. One thing I saw with S2 is that he likes to manage his own time. He was much happier with me setting a weekly goal of what practice test work he needed to do and then determining himself when to do it - vs. having a scheduled hourly tutoring session - which he really disliked.</p>
<p>mdmom - congrats on the SAT scores - good news!</p>
<p>Chocchip & Mom24boys…I’m a little late reading your posts, but wanted to comment about Vex robotics. My S1 has been in robotics for 6 years, started out doing First, did First Tech (which used to be First Vex) until Vex split from First, and has been doing Vex ever since. If either of your kids go the World Championships in Orlando in April, let me know. Both of my boys’ teams have qualified, and I’ll be tagging along. If you’re there, maybe we can meet up for coffee?</p>
<p>DS did the online college board SAT prep to prepare for the PSAT. His 10th grade score was on the cusp of NSM qualifying and we wanted to see him over that hump. His score came up about 15 points, which was what we needed, helped him start on actual SAT prep, and was only about $70, I think (for a year’s access). His routine was a bit haphazard…took the pretest, than concentrated on the sections where he needed help. I think it was more effective than giving him a book - a little structure, but not a class.</p>