Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>RVM: Thanks for sharing that post. It is shocking. However, it was reassuring to see how many Jewish students showed up to protest.</p>

<p>Yes, thank you for sharing this, RVM. Very disturbing, but also very important to be aware of.</p>

<p>RVM Thanks for sharing the info.</p>

<p>I went to Hampshire College and took 3 classes at UMass. It is a fantastic area to go to school. Amherst and Northampton are wonderful college towns. There is a bus that goes throughout the 5 college area. There is so much to do in the area. UMass has everything, but it is silly that most students don’t take advantage and go to classes at the other schools. There are great professors at the other schools and you can take classes for free.</p>

<p>While there I attended Hillel events and Chabad. (better Friday night dinner!)</p>

<p>I am hoping when D begins to look, she will look at one of the 5 colleges. It is worth checking out.</p>

<p>RVM, this is very disturbing on many levels. As I read these articles it sounds like there was initially no fee and when many Jewish students came to the program the request for a donation changed from optional to required and this requirement was enforced by the campus police. It isn’t clear if the fee was charged to all or just the apparently Jewish students. It sounds like those who were members of the sponsoring organizations were not charged. There must have been non Jews who were attending who weren’t members of sponsoring groups. I guess those students were also charged. From what I gathered Jewish students weren’t barred, just charged a fee, which they chose not to pay. It would seem that once the event was advertised as free and open to all, then charging some or all especially after some people were admitted to the event without a fee would not be legal. It is disturbing but not surprising that programs like this exist. It is appalling that a Public University would support this pointed implementation of fees. It is comforting that no doubt the message that the group hoped to get out was limited because people who would have otherwise attended chose not to because of the fee. I can only guess that it wasn’t just the Jewish students who refused to pay for entrance. At least I hope that is what happened. I wonder if the Rutgers administration has had anything to say about all of this. Good for those who stayed and protested.</p>

<p>Hey, guys, I’ve missed being on CC this past month. I noticed that several of you were discussing KU as a possibility. I live in suburban KC where lots of kids attend KU and I went to law school there, many eons ago. If you have any questions, send them my way. Update on senior son: He went to visit Indiana this past weekend and liked the campus. He has been admitted to Kelley’s business school and the honors program with scholarships, but he is still waiting to hear from Northwestern, Emory and Penn. I think he is leaning to Michigan where he was admitted, but won’t hear if he got into Ross until April. Most of his friends are starting to make decisions, so he is frustrated and checks the mail everyday. How are the college visits going?</p>

<p>More on KU:</p>

<p>Campus: This is a lovely campus about 45 minutes outside southern Kansas City proper. My kids can usually make it there in 30 minutes from our house. Central campus is located up on a hill with the engineering, law school and some dorms located further out from the center. Mostly Midwestern, nice kids. Lots coming from Texas and the kids I know seem to date lots of Jewish girls from Dallas and Houston. My son’s friends from summer camp who live in Minesotta, Chicago and Wisconsin also come here in large numbers. Naismith is the Jewish (and Johnson county, where I live) ghetto, but very nice size rooms. It is similar to the social scene of Statesider in Wisconsin, which is also a private dorm.</p>

<p>Social life: tends to have good frats and sororities. AEPi is represented and I know the kids who are trying to get the ZBT chapter going right now. Lawrence is a really quaint town with good shops and bars/restaurants. Most kids come into KC for concerts, shopping and other events. I don’t need to mention how crazy people are around here about the Jayhawk basketball team and we attend many of the home games. Football needs improvement.</p>

<p>Jewish life: Hillel is definitely picking up. I have several friends who are on the board of Hillel at KU and they are committed to raising attendance at activities. Kids often attend High Holiday services with other Jewish kids in our synagogues in KC. The Jewish community here lives all within a small suburban enclave of Overland Park, Prairie Village and Leawood. Basically towns where you go out to eat and you are bound to meet someone you know. This area is run by Republicans and our current Governor who went to law school with me (I won’t mention how many fights Brownback and I got into in the commons over politics) is ultra-conservative. My kids who are very liberal have never had a problem voicing their opinions at school although sometimes they come home feeling like they are living on another planet. The people here are respectful of other opinions.</p>

<p>Academics: KU has great programs, but is not selective. This has led to a low graduation rate. I hear this often about my friends’ kids who take 5-6 years to graduate. My oldest daughter who attended law school there last year met an old high school friend at her apartment pool and asked her what grad program she was doing and her friend answered, “oh, I still have about 2 semesters to go to graduate.” I think proximity to home makes many of these kids take minimum hours and thus they slack off. I know several in the honors programs who have been admitted to great graduate programs. But at KU, you have to be a self-starter and keep on track, because a lot of kids take the more relaxed route.</p>

<p>Okay, enough for now.</p>

1 Like

<p>Rockvillemom, thanks for posting that. Several years ago, a similar speaker was scheduled in Pittsburgh, right near the universities. Word quickly spread in the Jewish community (probably student community too, but I am talking about the general Jewish community in Pittsburgh, the heart of which is adjacent to the universities). Hundreds of Jewish people showed up to take up the seats. The idea was to keep this message from getting out to the intended audience. I went, but was actually closed out of the venue because so many people had shown up before I did. So, this tactic did work. This is another example of how much the Jewish community of Pittsburgh supports the Jewish community of the universities.
But this whole phenomenon is another example of how we have to help our kids cope with this type of thing before going to college.</p>

<p>KU is an excellent example of how many people ignore fine universities in that part of the country. Missouri is also a good school (especially strong in communications) with big time sports, etc which gets a miniscule amount of attention on CC. For whatever reason, OOS Jewish kids seem to think the Midwest consists solely of Michigan, Wisconsin and IU, ignoring Illinois, Minnesota, Iowa, Ohio State, Nebraska, OU, KU, and Mizzou. </p>

<p>Michigan, IU and Wisconsin are all fine choices–but the others offer most of the same attributes. I have not looked at the Jewish populations at these schools, but would only think of Nebraska, OU and perhaps Iowa as much lower than KU.</p>

<p>Linymom,</p>

<p>I am glad you looked so knowing and cool with your daughter.</p>

<p>Molto, Loved the KU update from a local jewish perspective. I look forward to seeing it.</p>

<p>RVM, upsetting post. thanks for enlightening us.</p>

<p>If I have missed any acceptances since I last posted - Congratulations to all! I’m in Florida visiting my parents so not much time to be online lately. </p>

<p>Good news came today in the mail - boychild was accepted at Hobart with a very nice merit award. Very happy. He’s now 7 for 7 with just 2 to go.</p>

1 Like

<p>emilybee: Enjoy your visit! I am headed down with DS on Friday to visit my parents too. Just booked a tour/info session at Univ of Miami on Saturday for us (grandparents want to go also!) A little bit of everything on this trip. </p>

<p>levirm: So great to hear about the involvement of the Jewish community there. I’d like to live in an area like that some day.</p>

1 Like

<p>I thought this was an interesting article. Wanted to share.</p>

<p>[News:</a> Price Check at Sewanee - Inside Higher Ed](<a href=“http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2011/02/17/sewanee_cuts_its_tuition_by_10_percent]News:”>http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2011/02/17/sewanee_cuts_its_tuition_by_10_percent)</p>

<p>congrats emilybee to your son…and hope you are having a great visit with your parents!</p>

<p>Moltobene: Welcome back. Congratulations on your son’s acceptances. It can be hard to wait for the later ones while other kids are already set. It’s such a long process.</p>

<p>Emilybee: Congrats on the lastest acceptance. </p>

<p>I will be joining Emilybee and Linymom in Floida tomorrow. My husband, D2 and I are going to spend a few days in Sarasota. I’m really looking forward to the sunshine.</p>

<p>Somewhat off topic, but check out this video. Go to Youtube and type in “Bar’chu!” (I’m A Jew) – Remix of Cee-Lo Green’s “Forget You”". Very nice done.</p>

<p>Interesting article in yesterday’s Times about Ursinus College (one the CTCL schools) deciding that the thousands of not very interested applicants yielded by a marketing consultant using priority apps with no essay were not worth the effort.</p>

<p>For those joining me in Florida the weather is glorious and not only no rain in the forecast for the next ten days but barely a cloud in the sky!</p>

<p>Welcome to Florida Linymom, Emilybee and momjr!!! The weather here has been spectacular this week so far. It looks like Saturday will be a warm and sunny day for your tour of U Miami…bring hats, sunscreen and water bottles! Please do come back and report after your visit. I visited UMiami back in 2005 with D1, who ultimately chose UF instead. I have heard that the place has changed a bit in the past 5-6 years (student body) so I am very curious about the vibe there. We will visit ourselves in early Fall.</p>

<p>Interesting email wrt Sewanee and pricing strategy. I have always found it a little hard to understand how fine schools like Sewanee or Hamilton can charge the same as Harvard or Williams (35,000 applied this year to Harvard). Naive economic analysis suggests that they would need to charge less. [More sophisticated analysis is probably needed, though]. </p>

<p>Per Moltobene’s discussion about under-appreciated schools, we’d fully saved for full-boat private US college educations for our kids. We’re sending one to an elite school at full rates but the second kid decided to look in Canada and fell in love with a couple of schools. Costs are very low by US standards and quality is in many dimensions comparable – full ride for US citizens (room, board, tuition and fees) appears to be about $21K or $22K. We’ll be paying less for the Canadian schools because ShawD is a dual citizen. But, in the vein of under-appreciated venues, several of these seem worth considering, particularly if one is sensitive to cost.</p>

1 Like

<p>RVM, thanks for that post - very unsettling indeed. </p>

<p>tsdad, LOVE “Bar’chu”! Just posted it on my friend’s FB - her D will become a bat mitzvah in a couple of weeks.</p>

<p>soooo jealous of those of you in Florida! we can see the grass in Ohio for the first time in weeks and it is not a pretty sight :(</p>

<p>I’m kinda sitting on the sidelines of the college conversation. D2 (HS junior) is in a holding pattern - just not engaged in the process yet. she is off to NFTY convention in Dallas tomorrow, where she’ll meet up with D1 who is on staff. anyone else with kids headed to Dallas?</p>