<p>Actually Shaw, just the opposite. There’s an economic effect at play called the Chivas Regal effect, first described by economists looking at consumer goods/products in the 1980s. It also applies to higher education. In essence, economists found that people assumed more expensive colleges and universities charged more because they were worth more - in other words, a conflation of price and worth. A number of colleges raised their tuition - without need to do so - and found that significantly more applications came in and their yield improved. The end result was that many colleges/universities jacked up their prices and discounted down their net tuition cost to admitted students, so that they brought in the same net tuition revenue but the college’s tuition looked pricy and comparable to Harvard, Yale, what have you.</p>
<p>College tuition pricing is heavily influenced by market dynamics and consumer psychology and is significantly artificial. Think about it this way: what are the odds that the “true cost” of a year of education at a small college in rural Maine, a large private university in urban Philadelphia, a medium-sized university in Atlanta, a small college in rural Minnesota, and a large public university in Los Angeles (out of state) are all about comparable?</p>
<p>That is a disturbing article, RVM…especially the fact that Jewish people are involved in an anti-zionist movement…how does your S handle the campus speeches (in general) at Wake? My S has lived in this little “bubble” where he has not experienced a lot of anti-semitism (yet). I think it’s good to be well educated and to educate others one person at a time…many times things happen out of ignorance…it would be SO nice to live in a world where groups of peoples lived in peace & harmony…</p>
<p>PRJ: At least you have grass showing! Where I live it’s still piles & piles of snow!</p>
<p>Save that Florida sunshine for me too! I’m heading down there at the end of next week and would LOVE to have some that gorgeous weather to greet me! In fact, I’m getting a pedicure just in time to embrace that warm air, yay!</p>
<p>Linymom: I have a nephew who is a freshman at U of Miami. He’s not quite as studious as your S but loves it there! Will you be able to tour the Biomedical Dept? Ask if they have an honors college there too! The college is really beautiful…what’s not to like with palm trees swaying in the breeze? You’ll have to decide if it’s academic enough for your S…</p>
<p>Emilybee: Congrats on you S’s acceptances! Hopefully it won’t be too difficult to narrow it down to the favorite…</p>
<p>Just doing the basic tour and info session on Saturday. If we need to do more in-depth look next year (after seeing several other schools this spring/fall), I can always plan a weekend trip with him to my parents’ (about an hour and a half from the U). If he gets merit scholarships and can play tennis all year (if he has time after studying!), that will be a big selling point. Time till tell…</p>
<p>justmytwocents, that’s why I said the straightforward analysis was naive. Thanks for supplying the more sophisticated analysis. Did 2nd tier or 3rd or nth tier colleges actually have greater increases in applications than peers that didn’t raise rates? [We’ve been in a ocean of applications that has been rising for everyone].</p>
<p>I can see the discounting from a high list price really working. I read a book called Switch that cited a study in which a car wash gave some people a loyalty card – buy 8 washes (with boxes to be marked) and get a free wash. To others they gave a loyalty card with 10 boxes to a free wash but two of the boxes were already marked. The second group purchased significantly more car washes.</p>
<p>chocchip - as far as I know - my son does not get very involved with attending lectures or political events at Wake. Or if he does - he does not tell me. I do think he is in a bit of a sports dominated bubble.</p>
<p>On pricing - one of these articles mentioned an experiment where students had to choose between a $20,000 college and a $30,000 college with a $10,000 scholarship. The latter was much more popular. There seems to be a very strong correlation between price and perceived quality of education. I’ll be very interested to see how this experiment works out for Sewanee - hoping they get good results and other schools follow their lead!</p>
<p>Comparing the prices of Seanee etc to Harvard is irrelevant for other reasons, as well:</p>
<ol>
<li><p>Harvard’s huge endowment would allow it to give every student a free ride without endangering its finances. It need not calculate tuition the way Sewanne or Hamilton do, because it needs the money much less.</p></li>
<li><p>Harvard does not compete with Sewanne or Hamilton for students. It turns away so many stellar applicants that it has no reason to fear losing applicants to them on cost grounds. The majority of Harvard freshmen could have received full rides at many good schools.</p></li>
<li><p>Harvard is not trying to use its prestige to maximize revenue. Because of its prestige, the perceived value of a Harvard degree is such that it could double, perhaps triple, its attendee cost and lose virtually none of the students who would not qualify for need based aid to non-top 20 schools.</p></li>
</ol>
<p>yabe, I agree with all of your points, but I’m interested in something a bit different. It strikes me as not obvious that we’d reach a market equilibrium in which a high percentage of schools are charging roughly the same amount. Is it obvious that a big set of private schools would be charging $50K+? [Drew University (all-in-cost of $57K), Hamilton ($56K), Furman and Davidson ($50K), University of Puget Sound $50K, …] I doubt that the U. of Puget Sound could triple costs and retain its applicant pool. These schools are all, I’d guess, pegging their sticker price to the big name schools and each other. But, as justmytwocents pointed out, they then discount to get the students they want. An interesting model. Are there any other similar markets? What causes this kind of outcome relative to others?</p>
<p>FWIW, I can tell you that my son was admitted last year to Drew. They brought their cost down to the point that it would have cost us slightly more than than our NJ instate public U. My son did work on getting a couple of merit scholarships, which were stackable, and then they re-worked our FA package after our son was awarded the 2nd merit scholarship. They had gapped us initially, BUT they did NOT reduce any FA grants. They allowed the 2nd award to just close the gap. I think that for Drew, our package was pretty good. We did get better packages than Drew’s but probably not from the schools within the northeast (our son also did not apply to many private schools in the northeast because of sticker prices and the bottom line).</p>
<p>I do not think those numbers are particularly unusual. Add to the mix the large number of similar schools in the low $40k’s such as those in central PA (we can exclude bargains such as York in the $20k’s) and you have a price range where the low end is over 30% lower than the high end (and even Puget vs. Drew is a double digit spread).</p>
<p>I doubt Puget and Drew are “pegging their sticker price to the big name schools” as they just suffer from the comparison–the NJ media coverage when Drew’s sticker price passed Princeton’s was understandably brutal. </p>
<p>Pegging to their usual rivals for students is likely, but the regional variations in college tuition you cite are not very different from other goods and services. For example, on a Cost of Living calculation website used by HR departments, the cost of a basket of goods and services in Fort Worth, Seattle, Springfield, MO and Troy, MI had a spread of about $44-52,000. That would leave Hamilton and Drew as cost outliers on your list. Drew is in the horribly expensive NYC area housing and labor market. Hamilton should have lower labor costs, although its heating and snow removal costs must be very high (I wonder if Colgate, Hobart and Lawrence are similar in cost?).</p>
<p>There is also a base cost of a private college of 2000 students anywhere in the US–the cost of buildings; technology; teachers; athletic teams; support staff. There will be variations depending on the local cost of land and labor, but such costs as computers, food, football uniforms, national advertising and paper will not vary much. </p>
<p>Some colleges, of course benefit from endowments (or sports revenues) which allow them to avoid borrowing money and be more generous with aid. </p>
<p>The college’s philosophy on financial aid can also create differences–how hard will it try to entice top students and subsidize needy students at the expense of other students? And, as in justmytwocents’ apt example, will it set an artificially high sticker price and then routinely discount it (or possibly also not to discount it to affluent students who are likely to attend anyway?</p>
<p>Rockville–noticed your article about Kosher food at Muhlenberg. Yes, we live in Allentown and the entire community is thrilled with the Kosher dining hall at Muhlenberg. We’ve tried to sustain several kosher restaurants in the Lehigh Valley, but most can’t make it beyond initial launch. But Muhlenberg now provides a great place for the entire community… we can go in at fee and join the great group of 'Berg students. I noticed you talk about your son at Wake Forest. My D is there this weekend visiting. Two Jewish girls have reached out to her (Admissions made their connection) and they will be meeting with the Hillel Rabbi tomorrow. Your comments about WFU Jewish life on the other site gave me some confidence that there will be something there for her. Thanks.</p>
<p>creativecrew - that is very interesting about Muhlenberg - I didn’t realize it was open to the entire area Jewish community - very cool. I’m glad my comments on Wake have been helpful. It is certainly nothing like Muhlenberg in terms of Jewish life - but I see signs of progress and a growing emphasis on both racial and religious diversity. Let me know how it goes this weekend and what you think.</p>
<p>Bert’s Kosher Deli in Talbert Hall, at SUNY-Buffalo! Yum. Most customers are students, but community folks go there, too. No meal plan for the neighborhood fressers, who just pay cold hard cash for their nice warm food.</p>
<p>I think that one interesting aspect about the discussion of cost is the concept of value to the consumer. Value is a perception, but it is one that my husband and I have taken seriously in college searches with our kids. For example, our state-related universities have a certain value for the money. If we were going to spend more, we wanted to make sure that what we were getting was worth it, both in terms of what the students get out of the experience and their potential for financial stability and independence after they graduate. If we were considering paying more for an OOS public, for example, we had to ask ourselves - is this really worth the price compared to our in-state public?
What do you think constitutes value? Are you formulaic (tryng to figure out the difference in income after graduating from a certain institution and whether it justifies the cost, for example) or is this something that is more intangible?</p>
<p>Wow, I missed a lot yesterday!
Moltobene and Emilybee, Congrats on the acceptances.</p>
<p>LINYmom have a great time in Florida. 70 here in Jersey. I am sporting capris and sitting on the deck in the afternoon! Next week off to Antigua.</p>
<p>I think these big ticket schools exclude many of us that don’t qualify for financial aid and don’t want to pay the high sticker prices for a school without the BIG name. There are so many lower priced schools that provide a good solid education with a good reputation, that it is hard to stomach those kind of tuitions. Besides, would these schools hand out merit awards to 3.2 students vs the 3.7 students?</p>
<p>All in the NE, enjoy the great spring weather!</p>
<p>What constitutes value is such a family-specific determination - based on variables such as your financial situation, your own experiences, your student’s interest/performance and the experience you and your student want from college. It’s one of those conversations I don’t like to have with people outside my family. It bothers me when other parents are insistant about their own value and why don’t I think the same way for my kids. I try to remember that it’s because of their situation (the variables listed above) and try to put it in it’s place. It’s not always easy so I prefer to change the subject rather than get into it with anyone.</p>
<p>It’s much easier to have this discussion here because we are all here to share information, not judge.</p>
<p>Everyone should think about value, but have their own concept of what it is (and consistent with their financial realities), because I think intangibles matter a lot. For example, in state publics are usually a better deal than OOS, but parents might think either that their kids will benefit from expanding their comfort zone and experiences by going far away–or that they will benefit from building contacts in their home state if that is where they will likely live.</p>
<p>Some families rate big sports highly; others a nurturing atmosphere; a a strong social service ethic; a large community of their own religious group; a strong study abroad program; a nationally ranked program in the intended major; a vibrant fraternity/sorority culture; a beautiful or urban campus; or the broadest range of potential majors.</p>
<p>I think we are very lucky to have this group. We have learned so much from each other about schools we may have not considered. There are so many good schools out there and it is obvious from this group that we care to explore, visit and expose our children to them. I know I have appreciated all the advice and confirmation.</p>
<p>All good plans laid to rest. I refuse to be stressed and will go with the flow. Son is sick, tons of homework and our President’s weekend college tours are now all canceled. :(</p>