Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Cherryhillmom: I’m really sorry that you had to cancel your plans. It sounds like you have a great attitude. I hope you son recovers soon. There’s still plenty of time to reschedule those visits, and the weather will be nicer anyway . We did some on Saturdays, which worked out fine.</p>

<p>cherryhillmom, hope your son feels better soon.</p>

<p>cherryhillmom:</p>

<p>That is a bummer. Please try to not let it stress you out. We actually began our college search in the summer before junior year…yeah, I know, the summer isn’t the greatest time to be looking, but there were definitely students walking around even in the summer! We tried to do most of our visiting for the most part during the school year where there were lots of students, but if you have to see a couple in the summer, don’t fret…Saturdays are also a good option…</p>

<p>Hope your S feels better and catches up on his homework…</p>

<p>Samtalya: I’m heading to Fla next week, but I’d rather be going with you to Antigua!:)</p>

<p>cherryhillmom: So sorry about your son. DD and I had to cancel a college trip fall of senior year because DD had e.coli! We were in the ER the morning we were supposed to be on a plane. (JetBlue was very good about the credit.) It’ll work out.</p>

<p>We’re headed to FL today. Supposed to be for DS to play lots of tennis before his season starts in March, but he can’t serve due to a shoulder injury! At least his stitches from last week’s accident in science olympiad came out today. As I mentioned previously, I’m keeping him off the court tomorrow by taking him to Univ of Miami.</p>

<p>As I kept telling him, it’s all just an inconvenience. You have to be grateful you aren’t really ill or seriously injured.</p>

<p>Hope there is some silver lining for you, cherryhillmom.</p>

<p>cherryhill - I know that is frustrating - but it’s a very crowded weekend to visit anyway. Better luck in the spring! </p>

<p>Please remind your kids to open any college related e-mail they get and to forward to you (or whatever system you have in place) anything important. I just embarrassed myself by calling Elon and saying we had never rcvd an e-mail confirmation to the Open House in April. I got a very quick response confirming that it had been sent to my son’s e-mail on 2/11 and that they could tell he had never opened it. Arghh.</p>

<p>cherryhill, I hope that your son feels better soon! SO much sickness going around (I should know! :slight_smile:
I think that the New York area schools do the right thing by giving kids a week off in February. This was started to break the transmission of the flu! Our kids don’t even get President’s Day off, and illness is spreading like wildfire.
I agree that value is student and family-specific. I was just wondering what everyone’s perspective is on what constitutes value because, to be honest, I have struggled with this and it is always helpful to hear the opinions of people on this thread!
To all of you headed for warm places- have a great time!</p>

<p>On the value question - I am presently comparing Wake Forest and Elon. Wake for next year will be $56,000 for those that pay full price, which luckily, we don’t. Elon will be about $36,000. I know that Wake > Elon in terms of ranking and prestige. But, being familiar with both schools - same geographic area, roughly the same size student body, campuses are both attractive and well maintained - I don’t see a discernible reason for the price differential. Now, Wake will tell you that they raised prices in part so that they could increase their FA budget. But wouldn’t it make sense just to lower their price and pay less in FA? On the other hand, apps were down 6% at Elon this year - does their lower price actually turn people off - less pricey = less prestigious? </p>

<p>I would not pay full price at Wake - I just think there are other less expensive alternatives. And it can be uncomfortable as well - I have posted about my son getting good FA at Wake and one person wrote back to me that her son was full pay and she was not very happy that she was subsidizing my son’s education. Oh well.</p>

<p>^^re: Elon’s decrease in apps; after reading the article this week about Ursinus pulling away from the marketing aspect of “free apps” etc and wanting kids who really want to be there…</p>

<p>I think that Elon’s app is one that stands out; if a kid doesn’t really want to go through the effort of explaining why they are right for the school, they wouldn’t want to complete the app…it has specialized essays; common app personal statement doesn’t necessarily fit…</p>

<p>That could explain the drop in apps…I kind of doubt that it’s the lower price tag…</p>

<p>and this was the first year with the new essays…</p>

<p>and as far as value is concerned: I personally cannot see how any school (except for a select few/ select geographic areas) is worth $20,000 more than another…per year…</p>

<p>Rodney - I see your point on Elon not being a Common App school and having unique essay questions that make it hard to reuse another essay - but that’s not anything new - they were than way a few years back when S1 applied. So - while that may deter some who just want to throw another app out there from throwing it to Elon - I’m not sure it explains the 6% drop this year. Not saying the drop is a big deal - I don’t think it is - just not sure that is the reason. And I applaud Elon’s pricing - wish more schools did the same.</p>

<p>RVM, I do not “know”, but I will take a guess. 25% of students at Elon are instate students. Perhaps in this economy, and because pricing is very good in NC for public schools, there is some reduction in the number of students from instate who are applying to Elon.</p>

<p>cherryhill: so sorry your plans fell though. Because of all the travel that our OSS college visits required for S1 we did many over the summer. This is different from visiting during the school year but we found it to be adequate combined with the research we did. Congrats Moltobene and Emilybee!</p>

<p>Those of you traveling have a wonderful safe trip!</p>

<p>On value:
For us value is very individual to our kids. Each of my boys have a very different set of things that they want and also need. In both cases we looked at our state university schools which are excellent and used (use) this as the gold standard to compare our choices to. Any school that S1 applied to received an answer to the question “Why would this be a better option than the state university?” that to us justified the application. For S1 schools that offered small classes that were more discussion based than lecture based, that had a very academic minded student population that tended to be collaborative, and had internship opportunities and specific EC opportunities were schools that made the cut. All of the schools had what we considered an adequate Jewish presence so this was not a tipping point for S1. For S2 we are looking at business programs, intramural opportunities, the friendliness of the campus vibe, employment history of the student graduates, school spirit and again EC opportuniites. For S2 being in state is a big plus. For S1 being out of state was a big plus. Since S2 would rather stay in state and he has had a stronger affinity to Jewish organization, the Jewish factor is a tipping point. </p>

<p>For S1 we eliminated many schools because they did not appear substancially better than the state University. For S2 we haven’t yet found a school that seems to top TAMU. For S2 probably the biggest limiting factor is that most of the schools that would be comparable are far away and not substatially better in other areas to justify the distance.</p>

<p>For both the bottom line is a huge factor. S1 made up his mind that he preferred (and convinced us that he would do better at) some schools that both rejection and cost could make them out of reach. The experience was grueling but it was easy to consider everything because he most wanted things that he knew might be out of reach.</p>

<p>For S2 our search may be over before it starts, it may be as easy as it gets. On the other hand it is much more difficult to introduce options… With S2 I always have to consider if introducing a choice that could be out of reach will make him less happy about the first choice which he presently loves. At this point the perceived value of any school has to pass the test, “Is this school so good that it is worth adding the possibility of disappointment to this experience?”</p>

<p>Levirm: Did that answer your question? I’m not sure if I got off topic but it was therapeutic for me to think this through. Thanks. :)</p>

<p>As for Elon and pricing, the pricing would only make me want to apply more.</p>

<p>Spectrum:</p>

<p>Wow-well stated!:D</p>

<p>You sound exactly like what my sister in Miami did for her two boys! One went a plane ride away to Vanderbilt, and one stayed local and is attending U of Miami…for many of the reasons you mentioned!</p>

<p>Glad to see someone putting down on paper our thought processes! Each child is different, so in a sense, you’re starting over with each child one at a time!</p>

<p>I am definitely keeping my fingers crossed that your S makes the academic requirements for TAMU…sounds terrific.</p>

<p>sorry for the travel plans snafoo cherryhill. My older s got sick when we were at Dartmouth. He was feeling horrible and the school got nixed from his list, perhaps because he felt so bad. Fortunately I had an old college friend in the area who is a physician. He gave my DS antibiotics so we could finish the college tour.</p>

<p>As for Wake vs Elon,</p>

<p>I have jewish friends with kids who have gone to Elon. They were very happy with the school, the schools assistance with one of their kids (who was on the aspergers spectrum) and had a stronger jewish presence than Wake. And if the prices is better at Elon, so much the better!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Levirm, I would think that what constitutes a good choice for one kid may be different than for another. I think a school that is a good choice for a kid should increase the chances that that particular kid will lead a satisfying adult life. I’m trying to help my kids to lead satisfying adult lives. While that is blurry, that is in a sense how I am defining “value.” </p>

<p>Income is part of value, but beyond a certain level, that won’t matter. I think that one component of a satisfying adult life involves doing work that is in some ways consistent with one’s vision of oneself – my test is that you get up in the morning wanting to do what you are going to do that day. Several lawyer friends of mine unfortunately do not, and when ShawSon was thinking about law school strongly urged him to look at other choices. [I’m sure there are lawyers who love what they do, so this isn’t a blast against lawyers, but rather an example of people ending up doing something that doesn’t fulfill them.] Another part of a satisfying adult life is being treated well by the world. Income (likely good relative to one’s peers rather than absolute) is part of that, but so are a position in the world in which one is treated with respect and living in an environment that one feels comfortable in. </p>

<p>It is worth it to me to pay full freight at an elite school for ShawSon, who is very ambitious, intellectual and driven to succeed. I was fortunate to attend some elite schools and found that the horizons (“I want to be the best in the world at what I do”), connections, and regard of the outside world have provided me with lifelong benefits. However, ShawD, who is also bright, does not want that kind of pressure. Her performance in school was not as strong as ShawSon’s, though she has graduated from B student to A- student in junior/senior years at a tough-grading private school. But, unlike ShawSon who really thought he should get a 105 out of 100 (when the teacher wasn’t getting extra credit), ShawD thinks “I got a 93. That’s pretty good. Well above the median. X and Y got a 93 and a 92.” She doesn’t think, “Well Z got a 99. What could I do next time to get a 99?” </p>

<p>In her case, it was not clear that there was the incremental $20K was worth it. She and I explicitly discussed the relative indistinguishability of schools on her list that varied substantially in price. In part to avoid the pressure of the US college application rat race, she chose only to apply in Canada and got into the two schools she thought were the best for her. The cost differential is actually more like $35K a year. In comparing schools, she pointed out that at one excellent US school that would have been a great choice for her and that was a match or probably a little more likely, she said, “If I go there, everyone will be pretty much the same as me.” (same grades, SAT scores, academic levels.). “If I go in Canada, there is a much wider spread and I have the opportunity to stand out.” I’m hoping she attends a school that nurtures her and helps her flourish. She’s a delightful kid and if she gets to the right place in life, she’ll spread happiness.</p>

<p>jym626 - exactly. But many kids who apply to Wake also apply to Elon as a safety. If they get into Wake - that’s where they go. So - for many families - the extra $20,000 year is worth it because of the higher ranking? The higher level of prestige? I’m sure there are many other similar comparisons that can be made - this is just one that I am familiar with. </p>

<p>northeastmom - I have read that Chapel Hill may be separated from the UNC system and go private - that will surely drive prices up.</p>

<p>Anyone else have some fun college road trips planned for the coming weeks?</p>

<p>Shawbridege,</p>

<p>Interesting post. May I ask, what Canadian schools did you look at? Where was D accepted, and where did she end up going? </p>

<p>Do you think the canadian experience is comparable to the US college experience? Is there a rah rah college feel up there. I was lead to believe that is hard to come by? Is there greek life? I know the Toronto schools have lots of Jewish kids? What is your D’s experience?</p>

<p>I am always happy to learn from all of you here. </p>

<p>thanks</p>

<p>Thanks, Chocchip! I hope both of your sister’s kids are happy with their choices. Have a great trip. I hope your mom is doing well.</p>

<p>" I think a school that is a good choice for a kid should increase the chances that that particular kid will lead a satisfying adult life…I think that one component of a satisfying adult life involves doing work that is in some ways consistent with one’s vision of oneself – my test is that you get up in the morning wanting to do what you are going to do that day…" Shawbridge, I love that, it is the essence of what we are after. As with your kids we find there are different paths toward the goal.</p>

<p>I might also add that as much as we want it to it isn’t all over if we don’t get it right the first time. One of my HS friends told me that she used me as an example to her kids. I went to 3 undergraduate colleges and graduated in 5 years. She reminded me of this when I told her that I hoped S1 loved his school because I so didn’t want to go through the process for him a second time.</p>

1 Like

<p>Spectrum - thanks for that post. We are finding it tough to introduce schools as well when we stack up against Rutgers. Many schools quickly fall to the wayside however the economy has me very worried and this “trickle down effect” I am seeing. While I still think Rutgers is a safe bet, I need more options for my sanity! </p>

<p>Rockville - I had heard Temple might consider going private as well. Just another thing to consider, I suppose. I wonder how would they charge tuition for enrolled students?</p>

<p>Timely discussion about Wake and Elon as we just returned from visiting both this weekend (with a stop at University of Richmond). </p>

<p>Interesting and shocking that there is an almost $20k difference - not sure how I feel about that but my S2 would do exactly as RVM said - go to Wake instead of Elon if given the chance.</p>

<p>dwhite - I have never seen Richmond - since you just saw all 3 of these schools - how about some comparisons and pros and cons. How do you feel about Elon’s lower price tag? Which did you like the best? Least?</p>