Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>shawbridge: very good post about your S and D. I am in a similar boat. You expressed it well. That’s partly why DD is at UD (rather than American) and we are looking at private schools for DS.</p>

<p>Speaking of which…</p>

<p>We had our info session and tour at University of Miami today. SIGN ME UP!</p>

<p>DS seemed to like it. Engineering school graduates have 100% placement (grad school or job); appears to be especially great if you want to remain in FL, which DS does. School is beautiful. Lots of places outside to study (why not???). Some points I wrote down during the info session:</p>

<p>Freshman class mid stats: 1250-1390 SAT (they don’t look at writing at all); 28-31 ACT. They superscore. No SAT IIs required for general admission; some honors program require them. Admissions officer presenting said that the school is for A-/B+ students who are taking honors/AP/IB. 12% Greek. 15% Jewish (from my research; presenter did not address this). They emphasize getting into research freshman year (hands on, early on - something like that). We did not go to Hillel. However, if we go back to meet with someone in the engineering school, perhaps we will check out Hillel. DS says it is definitely on his list.</p>

<p>I can’t imagine he will like any schools in upstate NY (RPI, Union) after seeing Miami.</p>

<p>If you have any questions, I will try to answer if I remember from what we were told today.</p>

<p>after we are finished with the Wake/Elon convo, we should probably table Wake for the purposes of this thread…it is not a school for a “B” student; heck, it is not even a definite school for an A- student…two kids with VERY strong profiles, lots of honors/Ap’s from my daughter’s school were both rejected ED this year…</p>

<p>but I am curious to hear dwhite’s impressions (although her son is not a B student!!)</p>

<p>RVM - University of Richmond is stunning. It is located about 7 miles outside of Richmond in a very upscale neighborhood and the campus is probably one of the prettiest I’ve ever seen. It has a total “Hogwarts” feel. Unfortunately, we didn’t do the info session/tour as we stopped on a whim and just walked around. We will definitely go back for the official tour as S2 really liked what he saw. It is smaller (just under 3k undergrads) and admissions are fairly competitive (ACT: 29-32, SAT: 1270-1420 CR+M). We know a couple kids there that love it. </p>

<p>Wake vs. Elon - so very difficult to articulate which we liked better and why.</p>

<p>Wake - Loved it. Beautiful campus, great academics, big time ACC sports, great advising - all around a wonderful school. Is it worth the $56k? I don’t know. I will say it does “feel” like the “better” school of the 3. It may just be the name recognition, famous professors, big time sports, etc. but it is an impressive place. Aside, from the price tag, it’s really hard to come up with any cons about it. We even found Winston-Salem to be charming - its an artsy place and has quite a few nice restaurants and bars. </p>

<p>Elon - also really liked it. It was our first visit and we were all impressed. I did get the feeling they are trying a little harder to “sell” the school - not in a bad way but more that its more of an up and coming school and they still feel the need to explain what they are about. Unlike Wake - which was more like the confident and accomplished older sister. I do really like their 4-1-4 semester schedule - seems to give kids so much flexibility. In addition, the Engaged Learning aspect is great. We got the feeling Elon really strives to get their students actually working! Imagine that!!?? </p>

<p>In the end, there is no question that you get a lot more bang for your buck at Elon, I think the only reason my S2 would chose Wake over Elon is perhaps the ACC sports and his perception that its the more elite school. Again, it is such a personal decision for each family.</p>

<p>cherryhill: If we were anywhere else or if S falls out of the top 10% he will also apply to more schools. For now we can apply to just one because admission is the law. I’m not sure that we will apply to just one but it is not unusual for kids here to do that.</p>

<p>dwhite - you make me want to visit Richmond - sounds gorgeous. I agree with your analysis of Wake vs. Elon - luckily for S1 - he had good FA from Wake and was able to have it be his choice. If we were full pay - I’m not sure how that would have played out. But Rodney is right - value comparisons aside - Wake is not an option for a “B” student.</p>

<p>spectrum2, thanks. As my current pro bono project, I’m writing a book on how to think about career choices. That is part of my first chapter. If only I had more time/drive as this is a solo book and I’ve only co-authored books and find the interaction with a co-author very stimulating. But, ShawWife is urging me on as she’s been volunteering my advice on career stuff to friends, colleagues, strangers, for 25 years.</p>

<p>Was out with friends last night whose 2 children both attended Elon. She said while there were not a of of Jewish kids, they were very respectful of the Jewish kids. She gave as one example that they had scheduled a meeting of the honors program that was to be attended by the school president on Kol Nidre. Her child (who graduated several years ago) emailed the president and basically said if she had to choose being disrespectful to her religion vs disrespectful to the school president, she would have to choose the latter, with apologies. The president rescehduled the meeting so it did not conflict with Kiol Nidre. That earns kudos in my book.</p>

<p>jym626 - great story. I think we are living in a great time to be a Jewish hs/college student in that so many schools are trying to attract Jewish students and make them feel comfortable. Now, the large universities may not be changing as much - but I see so much activity among schools under 10,000 students or so. I had a conversation with a Hillel advisor recently and she acknowledged this observation, saying that colleges know the hs population has peaked and is now starting to decline and that with college costs skyrocketing, families are more thoughtful about paying for college and making college-related decisions. The administration at this school feels that attracting Jewish students is part of the solution as their families place such a high value on the importance of education. It’s nice to feel wanted!</p>

<p>Can someone remind me-- is it William & Mary that has a special scholsrship for jewish students?</p>

<p>You might be thinking of the Weinstein scholarship at Washington & Lee</p>

<p>[The</a> Weinstein Scholarship :: Washington and Lee University](<a href=“http://www.wlu.edu/x33771.xml]The”>http://www.wlu.edu/x33771.xml)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Not really a “B” student item - but since you asked.</p>

<p>Ah yes… thats it–thanks RVM. I was about to check Washington and Jefferson next!</p>

<p>You’re welcome - took me a while to keep those names straight too. I think Washington & Lee is another good example of what I was mentioning above - colleges recognizing the value in attracting and retaining Jewish students and taking the concrete steps to make it happen.</p>

<p>Agreed. As has been posted before, Vandy made a concerted effort to do this several years back. I dont think its true so much anymore, as they successfully increased their Jewish population by quite a bit, but it was apparent for several years.</p>

<p>Agree - Vandy has increased their Jewish population considerably in the past 10 years - I don’t think being Jewish is an application boost there anymore. But thankfully - it seems to be at a number of other places.</p>

<p>While on the subject of some schools looking to increase their jewish enrollment…like Vandy a few years ago…</p>

<p>Can you tell us which schools currently are making a concerted effort to increase their jewish enrollment, and if any will take a b jewish student in order to achieve these goals. Is Elon one of those schools? Who is making that push now?</p>

<p>Thanks</p>

<p>Remember I’ve been talking about Univ. of Richmond for awhile? I’ve never visited it, but dwhite seems to like it…anyway, they may be trying to increase their Jewish enrollment as well…</p>

<p>The JCC in Richmond is named after Carole & Marcus Weinstein…wonder if they are related to the Weinsteins of Washington & Lee…The Weinstein’s of Richmond are supposedly promoting the Hillel at Univ. of Richmond and having it tie in with the JCC activities…hmmm…could be the same family!</p>

<p>Hiya Jym: Hope you’re doing okay :)</p>

<p>Carole and Marcus Weinstein are also donating to Davidson, with references to “increasing diversity”:
<a href=“http://www3.davidson.edu/cms/x37167.xml[/url]”>http://www3.davidson.edu/cms/x37167.xml&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Thats great to hear, levirm. There is clearly work to be done, especially here in the south. The friends we were out with last night siad whenthey went to a college fair, they went to the Furman table, and during the course of the conversation asked about the Hillel. The response they got was “we prefer our own kind here”. :eek:</p>

<p>^^ You have got to be kidding me!
The person at that table should be reported to the administration!</p>

<p>And that’s exactly the kind of info I want to bring out in this thread!</p>

<p>socaldad - no school is going to come out and say that being Jewish is an application boost or that a Jewish student has an advantage over a non-Jewish student in the admissions process. The best we can do is look at their quotes in magazine/newspaper articles and their actions in terms of expanding Hillel, hiring a Rabbi and so forth - and then draw our own conclusions. And I don’t want anyone to overestimate this boost either - plenty of well qualified Jewish students were not accepted at Elon in the EA round - it is by no means a guarantee.</p>

<p>From my own research and/or visits - Elon, Wake Forest, Washington & Lee, Franklin & Marshall, Dickinson, Davidson, Richmond, Lafayette and Susquehanna seem to want Jewish students and have taken actions to demonstrate this. You’ll notice these are all small to medium private schools that do not historically have a significant Jewish population. This list is by no means exhaustive - it’s just a few off the top of my head. And some of them - Wake, Davidson and W & L are really more for at least an “A-” student than a “B” student.</p>

<p>Furman and High Point - not interested.</p>