Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>I have been trying to catch up on this thread from the past few days.</p>

<p>First I have to comment on what jym626 said about the comment from a Furman rep. I am shocked that a college representative would say something like that and it should be reported back to the school. I can’t believe any college would send a rep out on the road who would say things like that to prospective students. </p>

<p>Congratulations to everyone whose kids had new acceptances.</p>

<p>LINYMOM - thanks for the University of Miami report. It is on D’s list, but I don’t think we will make it down there to visit, unless the school is in the running once admissions results are in.</p>

<p>Regarding value. This is how we have been looking at it. For D’s reach schools, we will do whatever is necessary (as long is it doesn’t break us!) to send her to one of those schools if she is to get in. Those schools reputations along with the recognized program in her field would give her so much value upon graduation, that we feel it would be worth it. Once we get past those reach schools, honestly, to us it will come down to $'s. Any of her safety/match schools would provide a solid education and I think the “name” for each of those schools, while maybe not being equal, wouldn’t really have such a huge difference. Fit of course is a part of any of the decisions. But I wouldn’t want her to apply to a school if she didn’t feel like she would fit.</p>

<p>D just surprised me this morning by saying that she wants to go to a school where there is at least one sport that everyone goes to watch. She doesn’t care if it’s football or hockey. To her it’s not about the sport, it’s about the school spirit of everyone rallying around a team. She is actually a pretty decent athlete, but I didn’t think she cared that much about watching sports in college. I always thought of her as someone who liked to participate not watch. </p>

<p>Actually this brings me to another point. How much stuff do you put on the college application? For instance D made a varsity sports team her Freshman year. Pretty unusual. However, during the season, she got very ill and had to leave the team. She refused to try out for the team again after that, because of the association of how she felt while on the team. So, here it is an accomplishment to make a varsity team, yet she didn’t stick with it. Do we just leave it off the application? Yet it was an EC Freshman year. </p>

<p>Regarding University of Richmond. I have a friend who attended. Of course that was many, many years ago! She loved her time there. She is not Jewish.</p>

<p>Regarding Davidson, they are actively recruiting Jews. They sent a rep. up to our Day School this year. Apparently, the first time they sent a rep there.</p>

<p>These articles are from the past few years on this topic and have been posted before - but I know the thread is long - so if you have not read them before - here they are again:</p>

<p>[News:</a> Why More Colleges Want Jewish Students - Inside Higher Ed](<a href=“http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2008/10/29/jewish]News:”>http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2008/10/29/jewish)</p>

<p>Info on Washington & Lee, Muhlenberg, Allegheny and Elon.</p>

<p>[Small&lt;/a&gt; Colleges Reach Out To Expand Their Jewish Student Communities ? Forward.com](<a href=“http://www.forward.com/articles/130140/]Small”>Small Colleges Reach Out To Expand Their Jewish Student Communities – The Forward)</p>

<p>Info on W & L and F & M</p>

<p>[U.S&lt;/a&gt;. colleges with few Jews building facilities to draw more | Education | Jewish Journal](<a href=“http://www.jewishjournal.com/education/article/us_colleges_with_few_jews_building_facilities_to_draw_more_20101011/]U.S”>http://www.jewishjournal.com/education/article/us_colleges_with_few_jews_building_facilities_to_draw_more_20101011/)</p>

<p>W & L, Lehigh, Puget Sound</p>

<p>University of Maryland College Park - Not sure if this has been discussed yet on the thread. I have been hearing shocking results from this years applicant pool. Lots of high stat kids being offered Freshman connection or not even getting in. Is this to make room for more OOS high paying students? Or just the increase in applications? Not sure what the story is, but just what I have been hearing from my D and her friends along with friends whose kids go to other schools in the area.</p>

<p>mdmom - regarding your question about the varsity team freshman year - since it was only freshman year - I personally would not list it. Every college rep I have met has emphasized quality of ECs over quantity and wanting to see depth of involvement. I understand that a freshman making the varsity team is an accomplishment - but since it was only freshman year - not sure that it would help - and it may cause some to wonder why she did not stick with it - did she not make the team in subsequent years, etc.</p>

<p>Have these links been posted here before?</p>

<p>[U.S&lt;/a&gt;. colleges with few Jews building facilities to draw more | Education | Jewish Journal](<a href=“http://www.jewishjournal.com/education/article/us_colleges_with_few_jews_building_facilities_to_draw_more_20101011/]U.S”>http://www.jewishjournal.com/education/article/us_colleges_with_few_jews_building_facilities_to_draw_more_20101011/)</p>

<p>[More</a> Choices for Jewish Students | InsideCollege.com](<a href=“The Best College Rankings and Lists | Inside College | CollegeXpress”>The Best College Rankings and Lists | Inside College | CollegeXpress)</p>

<p>[University</a> of Alabama’s New Hillel - SMALL AND MIGHTY](<a href=“http://www.smallandmighty.org/campuses/alabamasnewhillel2010.htm]University”>http://www.smallandmighty.org/campuses/alabamasnewhillel2010.htm)</p>

<p>Comment I’m adding later: There’s some overlap with RVM’s post. Looks like I was composing while she was sending.</p>

<p>The furman comment happened several years ago, as her younger child was the one looking at colleges and graduated from Elon at least a year ago. That said-- there was NO EXCUSE for that comment. Dont know if it was a local alum manning the table, a student representative or a college adcomm. I can try to find out.</p>

<p>On Maryland - it really seems like test scores determined your fate this year (in-state admissions only). Now reps from Maryland will deny this - saying their review is holistic - but from what I have seen/heard - kids with a 29 or higher ACT score were generally accepted for the fall, kids with a 27-8 were offered spring admit/Freshman Connection and some also got waitlisted for the fall and those with a 26 or below were denied. Obviously there will be some exceptions - but this scale seems pretty accurate from the kids I have spoken with.</p>

<p>Rockvillemom - Thanks, that was what I was thinking. She has lots of other stuff that she is very involved in.</p>

<p>Maryland ACT scores - does the same hold true for the SAT scores?</p>

<p>There actually wasn’t an increase in applications at the University of Maryland this year. Nor has there been an increase in yield over the past couple of years. </p>

<p>I was surprised by these statistics, since everyone (including me) has assumed that applications to UMCP would be up and that more kids who would otherwise go to private colleges would accept, rather than decline, admission to UMCP because of the economy. But that’s not the case, looking at the numbers over time. Maybe there might be some balance between kids not bothering to apply because they are sensing the school has become out of reach for them academically and stronger-stat kids applying who might have, in previous years, thinking it wasn’t selective enough for them. So the numbers are steady but maybe the applicant pool is changing?</p>

<p>Good morning everyone!</p>

<p>dwhite, thanks for your impression of richmond. hope someone else goes and tells us more.</p>

<p>spectrum and shaw thanks for your insights on value and putting things all in perspective. In the end, if our children don’t like where they chose, it is a lesson on making mistakes, adjustments and what you can do about it.</p>

<p>jym, wow about furman. when we spoke to the rep at u of tampa and asked about the hillel, the response was that u of tampa likes diversity and you can see this with the large moslem population. no thank you, didn’t answer the question and not what we are looking for.</p>

<p>FYI- There are 2 (that I saw) buildings on the University of Richmond campus with the Weinstein name - the Carole Weinstein International Center and the Weinstein Center for Recreation and Wellness.</p>

<p>Just want to add another “B” student school to our list:</p>

<p>[Hillel</a> Welcomes Lynn Students](<a href=“http://hillelcenter.org/v3/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=9&Itemid=22]Hillel”>http://hillelcenter.org/v3/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=9&Itemid=22)</p>

<p>Lynn is a small private school - good for kids with learning differences. Rolling admissions with a 3/31 priority deadline. About 350 Jewish students out of 1800 per national Hillel website.</p>

<p>The majority of students from our large public hs who have applied have been accepted. Average accepted gpa is a 3.0 with a 1000/1600 SAT.</p>

<p>mdmom - I am sure the Maryland stats hold true for the corresponding SAT scores as well - I just remember it better in terms of ACT.</p>

<p>Desk Potato - I agree with you that many “B” students are not applying to Maryland because they don’t expect to get in - applying to Towson instead and then they can try and transfer into Maryland after a year if that is still their goal.</p>

<p>The only thing I know about this school is that a ‘B’ student who had gone there, transferred out. She remarked that it just felt like an extension of HS.</p>

<p>mdmomfromli, I would not list the varsity freshman year only participation either. That being said, it is great that your daughter is putting her resume together now!</p>

<p>Regarding comments like the one jym described at the Furman table - I was thinking about this for a few minutes and I believe that if anyone runs into comments or situations like this it is much, much better to report them to the Anti-Defamation League than to try and handle them yourself.
The reason for this is that the people at the ADL really know what they are doing. They have whole programs that they can bring into an educational institution if they think that this is indicated. They can bring awareness and actually change cultures.</p>

<p>mdmom - and that could be very true - but for a student with a gpa in the 2.8 - 3.0 range - that might be the case at many of the schools they get into. I know one boy who graduated last year from Lynn - he did have some LD issues - and the school worked for him - he did stay and graduated in 4 years. And I guess - particularly with boys - if they did not do well in hs and then go to a school like Lynn for a year - get their academic act together and then transfer someplace that is more selective - that’s a good outcome too, right?</p>

<p>levirm - great suggestion - thank you.</p>

<p>The student I knew at Lynn (jewish) also transferred out. Said they had a big drug/alcohol problem there.</p>

<p>I have heard that Lynn is a good choice for students with LD.</p>

<p>^, yes, this student chose Lynn b/c he has NLD (nonverbal learning disability). He was not happy with the services there.</p>

<p>That comment from Furham is troublesome. </p>

<p>Regarding UMCP - OOS students are seeing the same thing from our high school. Freshman Connection and spring admits.</p>