Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Just catching up here…I am shocked by the Furman comment. Hopefully this represented the view of the alum and not the school as a whole, but it certainly does point to the fact that the Deep South is not always as hospitable as we’d like. My impression is that, as a baseline, perhaps the more salient statistic with regard to Jewish kids would be the distribution of students by region. For example, schools with a decent number of kids from the Mid-Atlantic, NE, Midwest and CA will more likely be a good fit for Jewish kids. Not that there aren’t tolerant people everywhere…but it’s difficult to overcome pervasive stereotypes in communities where there is little to no exposure to all kinds of people.
I believe that schools such as Elon, Vanderbilt, Tulane, etc. have large contingents of kids from outside the region, although this, of course, may be a chicken and egg situation.
URichmond does seem like a great school. I think it will garner much attention in the next few years.
As an aside, every time I see levirm’s name, internally I hear “Levirim.” We are on the jewish thread, after all.</p>

<p>mdmom: Yes, it is an accomplishment to have made varsity freshman year, but given that it was just one year, you should probably leave it off.</p>

<p>When I read the comment about Furman, I was going to give the person the benefit of the doubt, and think that either they misunderstood and didn’t know what Hillel is, or that they have their own Jewish organization on campus that wants to be independent. Then, I went to the website and saw that it doesn’t appear to be ANY Jewish organization whatsoever! Wow! [url=&lt;a href=“Furman University | Top Private Liberal Arts University in Greenville, SC”&gt;Furman University | Top Private Liberal Arts University in Greenville, SC]Home[/url</a>]</p>

<p>So - I guess we’ll conclude that Lynn University is a ?? - might work for a student with a low B/C average and/or a student with LD issues - but proceed with caution.</p>

<p>And Furman - does not seem interested in attracting or retaining Jewish students. Not to say that Jewish students would necessarily be mistreated there - I have no proof of that - but I don’t think anyone who is interested in even a modest anount of Jewish life would pursue Furman.</p>

<p>The report of UNC considering going private is very interesting–is there a link to a news story? Has a state flagship ever gone private? Since going private would likely result in a vast reduction in in state admissions, I suspect the state legislature would go nuts. You would likely also need a complex set of agreements for the repayment of the public funding used to build UNC.</p>

<p>Temple is a somewhat different story–it used to have a peculiar hybrid status, where it received a lot of public $, but wanted private legal status to avoid some of the legal obligations of public entities. Pitt was similar.</p>

<p>Why are these schools said to be considering going private?</p>

1 Like

<p>With all going on in Wisconsin, there is talk of UW Madison splitting off from teh UW system [Walker</a> to gut MPS, break up UW, education leaders say - JSOnline](<a href=“http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/116339939.html]Walker”>Walker to gut MPS, break up UW, education leaders say)</p>

<p>For those of you looking for large, public rah rah…</p>

<p>.not sure if Michigan State has been mentioned for OOS students; definitely reaching down into the applicant pool to get the OOS $$ from this vantage point…PM me if you want more details…</p>

<p>Back in 2007, a Jewish friend of my older daughter looked at Furman; she really wanted a LAC that was not on the radar of anyone around here; they visited the school and came back saying that she really felt she would have been out of place there…I know it’s a great, great school and that there were some on CC who chose it over Elon last year, but interesting discussion nonetheless…</p>

<p>one other note: keep in mind that Elon’s Jewish population is now around 8%; when jym’s friends children attended (since graduated) there were around 100 students TOTAL in the school…when I first heard about it back in 2005-2006, there was very little chance I would have considered it; I don’t even know if there was a Hillel back then in fact…now they are trying to start an AEPi chapter…</p>

<p>JYM, interesting article on Wisconsin, thanks. Note that it is not proposing that UW go private, but that it stay public although not run by the same people who run other Wisconsin public universities and not be subject to as many state rules, such as salary restrictions, giving it sort of the best of both worlds–state funding with less state involvment.</p>

<p>This article has absolutely nothing to do with colleges for the “B” Jewish student. However, it is such a sad story and such a cautionary tale that I feel compelled to share it with you.</p>

<p>[Suicide</a> turns attention to Fairfax discipline procedures](<a href=“http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/02/19/AR2011021904141.html]Suicide”>http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/02/19/AR2011021904141.html)</p>

<p>The basic storyline is of a reasonably good kid at a Virginia hs who purchases a capsule of an imitation drug and the disastrous consequences that follow. I know we all are thinking that our son or daughter would never do something so foolish - but kids make mistakes. I have asked S2 to read the article - and while he rolled his eyes - he is doing so. Take a moment and look at this and share this with your kids. This family won’t be researching colleges for their son.</p>

1 Like

<p>Yabeyabe - I can’t find the article at the moment - will continue to look. It had to do with budget issues and the 18% OOS cap. Basically - Chapel Hill gets more than it’s fair share of money from the state. But - if it could admit more OOS students - that would not be necessary.</p>

<p>Rockvillemom - what a heartbreaking article. I cried while reading it.</p>

<p>mdmom - me too. My heart breaks for this family. And the thing is - while you can’t 100% blame the school for the ultimate outcome - they certainly put the wheels in motion. How differently would things have turned out had they given him a 2-day suspension and a drug awareness class? And the thing that frightens me is that we have no guarantee - not any of us - that our son or daughter won’t have a bad day and do something equally foolish. There is so much research available about brain development in teens and how the part that governs risk assessment and impulse control is not fully mature until the early 20’s - not making excuses - just saying even smart kids do dumb things.</p>

1 Like

<p>I may have misread something about the UNC system considering having Chapel Hill go private. I can’t find the article now which really bugs me. They are having tremendous fiscal issues - as are so many states. If I ever locate what I think I read - I will link it.</p>

<p>[The</a> Daily Tar Heel :: Chapel Hill works with UNC to determine impact of budget cuts](<a href=“http://www.dailytarheel.com/index.php/article/2011/02/chapel_hill_works_with_unc_to_determine_impact_of_budget_cuts]The”>http://www.dailytarheel.com/index.php/article/2011/02/chapel_hill_works_with_unc_to_determine_impact_of_budget_cuts)</p>

<p>Thanks RVM. It is very interesting–the heart of the bitter UNC/Duke rivalry has always been the public school vs. the rich out of state kid school. And if UNC went private, would NC be left without a public med school and law school, reducing its supply of doctors likely to practice in the state (they probably worry less about lawyers)? NC State would probably love to go from stepchild to flagship.</p>

<p>Going back a few days to something RVM said:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>One great suggestion I got here on CC was to have your kid set up a for-college-applications-only email, AND to have both a parent and the kid have the password. It allows the parent to then be a quiet safety net.</p>

1 Like

<p>Was reading the list of schools that are focused on making strong Jewish communities and have to agree with Rockvillemom’s list. Beautiful new Hillel at Franklin + Marshall (right next to Admissions) and Lafayette has strong Hillel and wonderful Jewish Studies dept. Davidson’s Rabbi called D2 after we visited there this summer. He offered her a job teaching religious school said the Jewish college kids get very involved in the broader Jewish community and that the synagogue often holds the religious school classes for their children on campus, “since so many of the teachers are Davidson students”. And there was a lot of good conversation here about University of Richmond. YES, they are very supportive of Jewish students. D1 is there now and loves it. She has had many wonderful opportuities. The college has held events at the Richmond Holocaust Museum and had Elie Weisel speak there last year. The Hillel is a combination of VCU and UR so they do get some “critical mass” between the 2 schools and the events rotate between campuses. And yes, Carole Weinstein is involved with the Jewish programs on campus, not just as a funder, but a thought leader and mentor. All good! We have been very impressed with Richmond’s academics and opportunities. Urge everyone to go see it personally. Lovely campus with a wonderful community feel.</p>

<p>Slithey - I was thinking about that actually after what just happened with the Elon e-mail. But my hesitation is that he is already on various mailing lists with his current e-mail address - so not sure it makes sense to set up a new account now. But for parents of 10th graders reading this - that would be a great suggestion. S2 actually forwarded the missing e-mail to me today - and it really does look like it just came through on the 17th - not on the 11th. Maybe a Comcast issue. But he has agreed to check his e-mail religiously for college stuff - guess that’s all I can do.</p>

<p>I need your help. S just took SAT practice test today and i go through the score sheet and it provides a range. 590-710. how do you know what the true score is? that is a big score difference. i just split the difference and tell my S yeah you went up, but what really is the score.</p>

<p>thanks for help</p>

<p>That is a big score range - not sure how to help you decipher - I have done more with ACT prep. The reason for the range, I believe, is just the variability of taking the SAT from one day to the next. Say for example a student had the opportunity to take an SAT on Tuesday and again on Wednesday. There would be some variation in the scores - and of course this would not be the result of additional prep or education. So - my guess is that this is why they give you a range rather than an exact score - it is hard to predict. When is he taking it for real? March?</p>

<p>We just got some good news - S1 called to say he has been accepted into the Calloway School of Business at Wake Forest. This is one of those programs we have discussed on this thread before with a secondary admissions process to actually be admitted into the business program after taking various prerequisite courses. About 40% of the applicants are accepted in this first round - so very pleased he was one of those selected.</p>

1 Like

<p>rvm congrats on s1 making in to the biz program at wake. that is awesome!!</p>

<p>i think the range of score has to do with easy, medium, hard weighted of questions and the number of students that get which correct. BUT it makes it difficult to know if there has been improvement with the tutor. S takes test in march, but now he is doing a few practice runs.</p>

<p>RVM, Congratulations!</p>