Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Rockvillemom, what wonderful news! Congratulations to your son!</p>

<p>the kid I know who was just admitted OOS at MSU was decidedly below the GPA stated and above the stats for the ACT/SAT…</p>

<p>Michigan State - I was surprised to look on Naviance and see we do have kids from our hs applying - mostly accepted - a few attending. Accepted students had at least a 3.0gpa and test scores were wide-ranging - 20 ACT and up.</p>

<p>college4three - that’s the one thing that bothers me a bit about this collegiate enthusiasm to recruit Jewish students. In this day and age - do people really believe that all Jews are wealthy? No Jewish families apply for FA?</p>

<p>I had a conversation with a Hillel director a few weeks back - and she was relating to me a high level conversation at her university on this very issue. She danced lightly around the Jewish wealth myth - expressing that there is the perception that Jewish families put an extraordinary emphasis on the importance of a college education for their children and will go to great lengths and make sacrifices to accomplish this goal. So - when you have an economy in distress and families reevaluating whether they should pay for a pricey private college education or just send their offspring to in-state U - who stands out from the crowd? The Jewish families do. </p>

<p>Thoughts?</p>

<p>Re Michigan State, back in prehistoric times, when I was in HS, MSu was one of the first schools to begin actively recruiting OOS National Merit Finalists and was successful at it. Its OOS profile seems to have been overtaken dramatically since then. RVM, the surprising rise in MSU applicants you saw could be related to its basketball team’s recent success.</p>

<p>Re recruiting Jewish kids, I cynically doubt how much is a pure commitment to religious diversity, as that topic almost never seems to be on the radar screen of any institution without an accompanying selfish motive. I believe there is a persistent belief that Jewish families will sacrifice more thn the norm to pay for the right college and will donate more than the norm if their child has a good experience. The one exception may be schools with a church affiliation, as I think they may have a genuine interest in interfaith dialogue.</p>

<p>I do, however, believe many schools with small Jewish populations would welcome more (but not make extra recruiting efforts) because they want to be welcoming in general. In simplified terms, I think it is similar to TV shows such as Seinfeld being able to draw large nonJewish audiences–it is not that such audiences are trying to increase their diversity of viewing, but that they are very open to a quality show even if it features characters from a religion not their own.</p>

<p>Just to add a different perspective on this topic as I occasionally do…
We just had our third visit to Juniata College in PA yesterday. Juniata has a really miniscule Jewish population. They have a Hillel group on campus and recently have a Hillel house located at the local synagogue.
My d had lunch with a member of Hillel. He actually got her interested in joining the organization as he described the activities they do together and described them as a tight knit group. (incidently, this young man’s mother is a Reform cantor) He also told her that Hillel members included non-Jews. For my atheist, raised Jewish daughter, this organization seemed very non-intimidating and I think she will actually be MORE likely to get involved with Hillel there than she would be at a larger more active Hillel chapter that she perceived to be …and excuse this phrase as I know it is off putting…“too Jewish” for her! It was an interesting experience!
I tell this story because I hate for parents/students to take some great schools off the list because the HIllel chapters are small!</p>

<p>This is very doable for students, but if someone attends a public college in Michigan, that Jewish student should be all primed and ready to interact with and rebut a wide range of political commentary about Israel and the Middle East. Michigan is home to many families of Arabic background from many nations. I assume their students cover a wide spectrum of political opinions. </p>

<p>Jewish kids - just do your homework, please! Be conversant on the history of the founding of the modern State of Israel and all the peace processes pursued since that time. Starting now, get into a daily habit of reading multiple news sources from the "net, including some good Jewish media press. Use your critical thinking, always. Be highly informed. You’ll be happier. IMHO.</p>

<p>Holliesue, how did you get your athiest daughter to lunch with a hillel member? Sounds like an accomplishment all its own!
And an excellent point that the quality of the school and the people matter much more than the size of the Hillel.</p>

<p>Holliesue - glad to hear Juniata is a good option for your D. Sounds like it fits her - might not be as good a fit for a student used to a larger Jewish community or looking for a Jewish Studies minor and so forth - but I am happy it is still in the running for her. IMO feeling comfortable and welcome is the first step - and for many - that will be sufficient - finding that they are not going to be treated like an oddity as a Jewish student.</p>

<p>paying3 - very valid point - I know that the Detroit area has a tremendous Muslim population. Would be so much easier if people could just respect each others’ opinions and get along.</p>

<p>yabeyabe2-It only happened through subterfuge…I told the adcom that she wanted to have lunch with someone from HIllel and she assumed that the admissions office arranged it on their own due to her having designated on her application that she is Jewish. But it really worked out the way I hoped it would. She saw that being associated with HIllel didn’t mean that she was going to have to be “religious” and that it could just be another group to meet people through. Oh RVM- btw- the jewish young man we met with yesterday was actually from your town! He loves Juniata. I discussed with him the fact that lots of Jewish parents/students won’t consider schools unless there is x% of Jews there…then he told me his mother was a Reform cantor (he didn’t say directly but I kind of picked up that she might work in DC) ! I was actually really surprised!</p>

<p>Hollie–great story (and good move)!</p>

<p>Paying3–sadly, I think very few Jewish students spend time researching the Israeli side of the story and, on campuses, it very easy to gain a sympathetic audience by talking of “fascist occupation”, regardless of the facts.</p>

<p>

I think they do get along interpersonally, but some Jewish college students don’t know what to say when presented with twisted factual statements, made by peers or professors, concerning the history of Israel since 1947. </p>

<p>The Jewish kids I speak to at Temple, home on college breaks, say they feel badly that they “don’t know what to say” to defuse the rhetoric (e.g., “fascist occupation” - perfect example). They’re rockin’ proud to be Jewish, but say they need more historic facts when talking across cultures with peers.</p>

<p>Yabe and Paying3 - agree with you both. I think BBYO and Hillel both focus on social events and some religious/cultural events - and not so much on Israel. Same with Hebrew School education - a lot of repetition of ancient history from thousands of years ago - modern Israeli history - not so much. I think the media tends to depict Israel in a poor light whenever there is an incident and that is unfortunate as well.</p>

<p>holliesue - great story - glad it worked out so well.</p>

<p>Agree with RVM, yabe and p3t - we need to do a better job of educating our kids about the situation in Israel today and in the recent past, before they go off to college. why do you think we don’t? and by we, I mean collectively and, in particular, the organizations like BBYO, USY and NFTY that work with high school kids. D just came home from the NFTY biennial convention and from what I can tell the programming was fabulous, but I don’t know that there was any learning about Israel. (we only talked briefly on the way home from the airport and now, of course, she is fast asleep!)</p>

<p>holliesue - great story! and RVM - belated congrats on S1’s acceptance!</p>

<p>I’m trying to catch up on all the news after a few sunny days in Sarasota. Now I see why so many kids want to go south for college.</p>

<p>RVM: Congratulations to your son. It’s great that he was accepted to the business program.
I was very sad to read the story about the boy from Fairfax. It does put a lot of the things we worry about into perspective. </p>

<p>I agree that most Jewish kids don’t really know how to respond to anti-Israel rhetoric I think that Birthright works on this.</p>

<p>RVM makes an excellent point–I would much rather have Jewish religious education focus on the last 100 years than on the bible and Hebrew put together. I think most kids not only know little about the history of Israel; I think they know little about the history of Jews in America and the origins of the Holocaust (including what the American Jewish community and FDR knew and what they did about it).</p>

<p>PRJ, if NFTY is not teaching about Israel, what are they teaching about? With what is going on with Iran’s nuclear program; the fall of Mubarak; etc, what deserves higher priority?</p>

<p>As for Birthright, I suspect the kids who need the education the most do not participate in it. </p>

<p>Paying3, any kid who says they wishes they knew how to respond to antiIsraeli propaganda is simply lazy–let them skip one Facebook session and look it up on Google. </p>

<p>I feel parents have a responsibility to discuss these issues with their children, but part of the problem is that religious school uses up many kids’ willingness to discuss Jewish topics. Did your religious school teach your kids about how Hitler rose to power? Pogroms and the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire? Father Coughlin and Henry Ford? Goodman and Schwerner? The 1948, 1967 and 1973 wars? The historic exclsuion of Jews from top banks, law firms and country clubs?</p>

<p>End of rant.</p>

<p>Yabe, I don’t think students who feel they don’t understand a complex issue well enough to give a proper response are being lazy. I think more likely they want to do a good job but aren’t sure how.</p>

<p>When people use loaded words it’s very upsetting, but in forming a response you have to think about what you want to accomplish. There are choices to be made. Snap back? Respond calmly and attempt to educate? A little of both? Something else entirely?</p>

<p>RVM: Wonderful news about your S getting into the B school at Wake and how much things can change in a couple of years time.</p>

<p>RVM, PRJ, Paying3, Yabe and anyone I have missed in the discussion about the lack of knowlege about the establishment of Israel and the limited ability many kids have to hold their own in a discussion about the Arab-Israeli conflict. You all make a great pont. Over dinner I asked my S about what he understood about the history of the birth of Israel and the conflict and its seems that despite years of religious school,URJ camp and NFTY he knows very little about modern Jewish history. While these programs have done a wonderful job in helping to cultivate a love of Judiasm and Israel this gap is disappointing. I really hadn’t given this much thought until reading this discussion. So it seems that the educating is my job. But Yabe, you are right there is a limited amount of discussion kids want to have. I would really like to find to brief easy to read articles that could be used as a springboard for some discussion. If any of you have any suggestions it would be great if you could post them. </p>

<p>Deborah T, I agree, I think they do want to do a good job and aren’t sure how. It would be great if we can collectively find some tools to at least help our kids with this.</p>

<p>Yet one more thing to teach this year before he goes out into the world beyond our home.</p>

<p>Deborah, I think the starting point is self-education. I simply do not accept that college students do not know how to research a current events topic that is the subject of innumerable articles in major newspapers and magazines, most of which are available for free online, and many books. I would not tell the student they are being lazy, but I would say that they should research it the way they would research anything else they have an interest in.</p>

<p>How to phrase the response to an attacker of Israeli policy is more complex, as it depends so much on the circumstances, but the starting point is knowing the facts. I took the question to refer to a student who feels they do not know the facts well enough to respond. </p>

<p>Unfortunately, I think many students (and adults) do not take the trouble to research some issues and many use “not having all the facts” as a reason for not engaging in an uncomfortable debate. But we all know that “the only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.” If the only voice heard on campus is that of well-financed, well-trained, unscrupulous students referring to Israeli “occupation”; “aggression”; and “atrocities”, who will the undecided students come to believe?</p>

<p>I forwarded this to my S1 in the fall asking him to read it when he will spare the time. I wanted to get it onto his computer, and will be reminding/encouraging him to read it this summer before going away to college:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.adl.org/education/Myths[/url]”>http://www.adl.org/education/Myths&lt;/a&gt; and Facts.pdf</p>

<p>…or that time…</p>

<p>Just copy the whole link and paste it rather than click on it.</p>