Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>^ technical fix to create a working link, just click:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.adl.org/education/Myths”>http://www.adl.org/education/Myths&lt;/a&gt; and Facts.pdf </p>

<p>Both links posted above do not seem to work. Here’s the link to the main website:</p>

<p>[ADL:</a> Fighting Anti-Semitism, Bigotry and Extremism](<a href=“http://www.adl.org/]ADL:”>http://www.adl.org/)</p>

<p>I have to be honest here - my own knowledge on this topic is weak. I need to educate myself first - and then try to educate my boys. Yabe - I agree with you 110% that most Hebrew Schools seem very lacking. My own religious education experience was pretty negative - and I’m sure my boys would say the same. It is very difficult to get kids to focus on religious education for 2 hours after being in school for the entire day and knowing that homework awaits them when they leave. This is one of my reasons for looking for colleges that offer a Jewish studies minor - maybe in that setting some interest will be sparked.</p>

<p>Paying3 - thanks for posting another working link.</p>

<p>Thanks Umich, that article is a keeper!</p>

<p>RVM, I think the Hebrew schools have not adjusted to the changes of the past 20 years, where kids are now under much more time pressure from the college ratrace; the travel sports ratrace; etc and find 5-7 hours plus travel time a week for Hebrew school a boring major extra burden which they drop as soon as their parents allow them to. </p>

<p>Yes, the other ratraces are often excessive and ultimately not worth it. But I think Temples should do a much better job of focusing on teaching kids–and their parents-- the last 100 years of the Jewish experience, rather than the first 5671 years. I would rather have my children know 10 reasons why most Jews eventually escaped poverty after reaching America or 10 reasons why the Holocaust occured than know all 10 plagues and why the United States supports Israel over its many oil rich neighbors than why Isaac supported Jacob over Esau. Others may disagree.</p>

<p>Yabeyabe2-I couldn’t agree more. I remember being so disappointed that Hebrew school for my kids was pretty much the same boring endeavor I had to tolerate decades before. Nothing had changed. When I was told to get on the board, get involved, work to change it, I discovered the powers that be really weren’t looking to change anything. It was just too hard to do battle. I too am guilty of pulling my kids from Hebrew school the moment they were Bat Mitzvah.Yes, I had guilt. But, it just felt so irrelevant. Lately, I’ve taken to emailing my kids news from the Wiesenthal Center and other sources that provide some enlightenment on the modern Jewish experience. They may not read all of it, but I think I have a better shot than when they had hebrew school homework.</p>

<p>“Did your religious school teach your kids about how Hitler rose to power? Pogroms and the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire? Father Coughlin and Henry Ford? Goodman and Schwerner? The 1948, 1967 and 1973 wars? The historic exclusion of Jews from top banks, law firms and country clubs?”</p>

<p>Yes to all of the above at the Jewish Day School that my kids attended from K through 8, in addition to Hebrew as a spoken and written language, Torah, Mishna, and the Jewish experience throughout history. I can say with confidence that they did not “give up” any aspect of their education either - they had plenty of exposure to diverse populations through our neighborhoods, sports, etc. and they had an excellent foundation in the secular subjects also.
I think that we have to do it ALL - from ancient history through modern times. The only way to provide for continuity is to feel very connected to our history AND to modern events. We must enhance our Jewish educational system AND discuss this with our children, as part of stimulating their intellectual development. Modern events do relate to events in the past; to study either one in isolation is not doing justice to our heritage or potential understanding.
Interestingly, I have had a debate with our school district over the implementation of African American history as an elective course. I believe that it should broaden to African Studies and go back further in history and take a much more global perspective - to Africa, and including the entire African diaspora.
I believe that Jewish identity, and the resultant success of Jews when permitted to succeed, has everything to do with our connectedness to our history and to each other around the world.
We cannot be complacent! We need to be discussing these things with our kids. We need to be role models and read and discuss books and articles, leave them around for our kids to pick up, etc. It is not enough to “ship them off” to Jewish activities - we need to have this at the forefront of our consciousness at all times. For those people who feel that something was lacking in the earlier education of our kids - it is not too late! This is the age at which identity is a major task of development - and we have a huge opening every night at the dinner table, or whenever it is that we interact with our kids.</p>

1 Like

<p>Jewish Day Schools are clearly better than traditional after-school Hebrew Schools for educating our kids about history, ancient and modern. But, for the more secular among us, this just wasn’t an option. Hebrew Schools just don’t have to be as lacking as I found them to be. FWIW, I found the reform congregations’ schools much better than conservative religious schools.</p>

<p>Umich and Vitrac highlight a good resource for current issues–the various advocacy organizations–Jewish Antidefamation League; Simon Wiesenthal Center; American Jewish Committee–all routinely issue concise summaries. Even small donations will generate subscriptions for you and/or your children.</p>

<p>I imagine their websites contain them as well.</p>

<p>Speaking of Wiesenthal, I suspect most of our children do not know who he–or Adolph Eichmann-- was.</p>

<p>Very interesting dialogue about the importance of being well educated in 20th-21th century history, especially as it relates to modern antisemitism, the holocaust, the founding of Israel, and other significant events since the end of WWII. With a little encouragement, I think my Ds would be very interested in all of this - but they wouldn’t necessarily think to do their own research, especially given the competing demands for their time. So I think it’s time that we make a commitment as a family to educating ourselves. </p>

<p>RVM, congratulations to your son. It sounds like his experience bears out the truth that when one door closes, another one opens up: attending WF seems to be serving him well.</p>

<p>On the matter of full pay Jewish families who will make major sacrifices for education, we certainly fall within this group. Our family has put education ahead of other possible ways of spending money (no second home, diminished retirement savings, etc.). Though with one D at a ‘most expensive’ private U, I’ve begun to wonder whether second D ‘needs’ a private college experience, especially if she may end up going on to graduate school. My H will gladly work to the utmost in order to pay for his daughters’ educations. I’m very involved in the care of an elderly family member and have not been able to contribute to the degree that I’d like to.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’m not so sure that this isn’t linked to the geographical distribution of Jewish families (e.g., in the Northeast / major metropolitan areas), where the overall concept of paying for a pricy private college education is more appealing than in-state U. Because I gotta tell you, go to any Big 10 state school and you’ll find more than enough Jewish kids for your tastes.</p>

<p>An article that may be of interest on this topic^:</p>

<p>[Explaining</a> the Boom - Campus - New Voices](<a href=“Campus & Community Archives | New Voices”>Explaining the Boom | New Voices)</p>

<p>Pizzagirl - agree there are plenty of Jewish students at Big 10 schools. The point of my conversation with the Hillel director is that the university is looking into the future - where to best focus their recruiting efforts - and one of their conclusions was to continue to target Jewish families as they are more likely to value a private university education for their children.</p>

<p>Peonies, I understand your dilemma. I note that a number of posters, such as northeastmom, have found that–even for nonstellar students–merit aid at privates often narrows or eliminated the cost gap, depending on the instate tuition level, which varies a lot among states.</p>

<p>Pizzagirl, you will find plenty of Jewish kids at the northeastern publics, too. Sadly, a major reason why there are not even more is that kids who go to Big 10, etc schools for bigtime football games will not find them at northeast publics, except for Penn State and Pitt and, very recently, Rutgers and UConn. </p>

<p>In addition, a northeastern student equating achieve independence with going to school over an hour’s drive from home will not be able to do that in the northeast because the states are much smaller than Midwestern states. </p>

<p>Combine the 2 factors and you get the huge amount of Jewish NJ, NY and New England kids going to OOS publics such as Penn State, UMD and Delaware (second tier in football, but big crowds) as well as Syracuse, Tulane and Miami, privates with big football.</p>

<p>I am not sure how the actual percentage of Northeastern Jewish kids shooting for prestigious privates compares to, say, the Chicago area kids. I think CC distorts perceptions, as many parents sending their kids to their instate public, whether northeastern or not, Jewish or not, will not feel a need to post (and perhaps be happier for it).</p>

<p>peonies - I do feel the financial issue is playing a greater role in the college list I have developed with S2 than it did with S1. I am more aware of what is and is not possible with regards to need-based FA and am more willing to draw a line in the sand and say that while our sons’ education is extremely important to us - we have to be able to eat! Willing to make sacrifices - yes. Willing to have constant financial stress for 8+ years - not so much. S2 is not applying to any $50,000+ schools - and that is a decision our family feels works well for us.</p>

<p>RVM, it is reassuring to know that others are wrestling with the cost issue. We are still working on coming up with the magic list of colleges offering rewarding academic and extracurricular opportunities that would meet our D’s interests while also striking a reasonable balance in terms of cost/value.</p>

<p>interesting article, northeast mom…thanks for sharing.</p>

<p>Hopefully by increasing the jewish presence at these small southern colleges, it will also increase awareness and possiby help to alleviate some common stereotypes over time. One can only hope!</p>

<p>umich…thanks for article too…I just printed out all 48 pages so all of us in our family can read through it.</p>

<p>My boys go to a hebrew high school in which they are learning about Israel’s past, present & future, but it’s good to have them aware enough to hold a decent conversation, which is likely to happen on a college campus. Another reason that I hope to send them on Birthright program and any other programs that tie in to their heritage.</p>

<p>I don’t think Jewish families value private vs. public anymore than anyone else. I think colleges believe that Jewish families are willing to stretch to make college possible; that Jewish grandparents, aunts and uncles are willing to contribute if necessary; and that Jewish kids have significant social support in getting to college and graduating with a degree. I have many non-Jewish colleagues whose attitude once the kid gets to college is, “I do my part by paying tuition. He needs to do his part by going to class-- or not- and I just can’t tell him what to do anymore”. I didn’t tell my kids what to do once they got to college- but we made the expectations very clear that we would do whatever it took to keep them in college, and they needed to do whatever it took to make the most out of the opportunities in front of them.</p>

<p>Colleges that believe that all Jewish families are full-pay are in for a rather nasty surprise!!! Makes me smile to think about it!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Makes me smile too and reminds me of a story a non-Jewish friend, married to a Jewish woman, told many years ago. He was a banker, and in a marketing strategy meeting, someone suggested they try to find more Jewish clients because “they have lots of money.” My friend paused for a second and then said “Darn! I must have married the only poor one!”</p>

<p>Wow did I miss a lot yesterday.</p>

<p>Yabe, thanks for the provocative thoughts. </p>

<p>I studied modern Jewish History in college and grad school and you bring up things I studied, but feel most don’t know or think about. I am a zionist, have been to Israel 20 times, have spent 3 summers with my children living on a kibbutz, and have hosted Israeli students in our home. Yet, I am sure my kids would not be able to handle questions on Israel. They have a deep love for Israel and they have traveled the whole country, but still don’t know how to respond.</p>

<p>I did teach at a Jewish day school and there was nothing like this covered. Perhaps, we as parents can appeal to NFTY, BBYO, and USY to help us educate our children.</p>

<p>The ADL article is great. CAMERA is also a good reference for accuracy in middle east reporting:
[CAMERA:</a> Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America](<a href=“http://www.camera.org/index.asp]CAMERA:”>http://www.camera.org/index.asp)
AIPAC often has meetings on campus, but it is doubtful on smaller campuses.
[AIPAC</a> - America’s Pro-Israel Lobby](<a href=“http://www.aipac.org/]AIPAC”>http://www.aipac.org/)</p>

<p>I think you have brought to light an issue that we should all discuss with our children before going to college and we should all support birthright and encourage our children to go and their friends.</p>

<p>Sometimes I think college is wasted on the young!</p>

<p>I would love the opportunity to take some of these classes. On my bucket list for when I am retired and able to take some college courses for fun.</p>

<p>[The</a> Minor—College of Charleston’s Jewish Studies Program](<a href=“http://spinner.cofc.edu/~jwst/pages/minor.html]The”>http://spinner.cofc.edu/~jwst/pages/minor.html)</p>