Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>northeastmom thanks for the article. My son’s good friend from high school was President of Hillel at Hendrix.</p>

<p>I think it is not hard to find large schools with significant Jewish populations for the B student. It is also not as hard to find smaller schools in the east with Jewish populations. The small schools in good weather areas are the hardest to find. For many of our kids living in warmer weather areas, there is not a lure to the cold/snow belt. The exception being the Ivies and Washington University which are not for the B students anyways. (There is University of Miami which really isn’t for the B student either) That is what brought me to CC. I kept trying to see if I was missing anything. It also gave me information about colleges such as Elon and CofC which was off the radar of the Jewish population attending public schools where I live. Ironically, they were not off the radar of several of our private schools. This I learned after my d selected Elon.</p>

<p>The information sharing remains important. There are probably many people who do read this and don’t comment so the reach of information CC contributers is even greater. So thanks for all the great information.</p>

<p>HERE’S AN IDEA:</p>

<p>It seems that many of us are committed to learning about Jewish issues and Modern Jewish history. What if we started a book club? (I know this is off topic of CC, but it will help us educate our children) Once a month, we would read a book and then dial in to a number where we would discuss. The dial in number is free if you have an all inclusive phone plan or cell phone. We could pick a designated time and anyone interested in discussing the book would call in.</p>

<p>We could read fiction or non-fiction and each month one of our group can pick another topic.</p>

<p>Topics to include:
American Jewish history and immigration
The Holocaust
Zionism
Israel
Anti-Semitism</p>

<p>If you are interested, vote here and let me know what evening would be best for a discussion. I think because of west-coast time differences we would have to call in at 8:30 or 9. </p>

<p>Posting on CC would be minimal, just the announcement of the book and time for discussion, and then a reminder a few days before.</p>

<p>Please let me know if this is of interest. I am on vacation for the next week, but if enough vote before tomorrow morning, I will pick the book before I go. If not, when I get back I will choose.</p>

<p>Let’s read!! (something other than college pamphlets)</p>

<p>Samtalya: Great idea with a caveat!!! Why can’t we have the discussion on here?? or on another chat of some sort?? I think a phone chat would be more difficult to accomplish but if we did it monthly and agreed to post and go online on a certain date, might be easier??.. and our West Coast/Southwest/PNW members can join in when they can…</p>

<p>There is another book club on CC that does it like this…</p>

<p>I LOVE this idea actually; I was trying to think of a way to actually educate all of us together with this; thanks for coming up with this idea…</p>

<p>net-net: I’m in!!</p>

<p>Have a great vacation!!! sending you a PM…</p>

<p>Love the idea - and agreeing with Rodney - it would be easier to just discuss on here. So now - how about some book suggestions? Let’s try to keep it fairly short - and reasonably easy reading - Jewish topic of course.</p>

<p>“for the more secular among us, this just wasn’t an option.”</p>

<p>Actually, there were and are plenty of “secular” families at my kids’ Jewish Day School - and intermarried families too, and families from every stream of Judaism (very few Orthodox families, though, as they tended to go to a different school). Don’t automatically cross it off for your grandchildren just because you believe that you or they are “secular”!
I recently attended their annual fundraiser - the Chair of the Board is a Reform rabbi who is very close to the Bishop - and as a result the Bishop dropped in and said a few words! I found this totally amazing!</p>

<p>Samtalya - great idea!
I suggested a book a LONG time ago on this thread:
[Amazon.com:</a> Unsettled: An Anthropology of the Jews (9780142196328): Melvin Konner: Books](<a href=“http://www.amazon.com/Unsettled-Anthropology-Jews-Melvin-Konner/dp/0142196320]Amazon.com:”>http://www.amazon.com/Unsettled-Anthropology-Jews-Melvin-Konner/dp/0142196320)</p>

<p>This is a fabulous book - I highly, highly recommend it even if you don’t join the “club” - AND it shows how everything that happens now, our entire culture, is based on history - it does start with ancient history but continues into modern history covering the topics that you outlined with a lot of pride-building, and puts everything into context (including how “secular” Jews are reflective of Jewish culture too.) I would take a course with this author in a minute (I think he used to be a professor at Univ. of Maryland, but is now at Emory). I’m telling you - READ THIS BOOK!</p>

<p>Another amazing book:
[Amazon.com:</a> Prisoners: A Muslim and a Jew Across the Middle East Divide (9780375412349): Jeffrey Goldberg: Books](<a href=“http://www.amazon.com/Prisoners-Muslim-Across-Middle-Divide/dp/0375412344]Amazon.com:”>http://www.amazon.com/Prisoners-Muslim-Across-Middle-Divide/dp/0375412344)</p>

<p>A book by an Israeli prison guard who befriends some of his prisoners - and he also happens to be a famous journalist so he is an outstanding writer, a Zionist who gives a very nuuanced view of the “situation”. I couldn’t put it down!</p>

<p>Day of the week: I have way too many evening meetings for our school district, but maybe Wednesdays when I can do it. I would also vote for an online format if we can’t find a time for a phone discussion.
Thanks for thinking of this idea, Samtalya!</p>

<p>Here is what I have in mind:</p>

<p>1st book- Bread Givers by Anzia Yezierka
This is a fictionalized account of a young immigrant girl/woman living on the lower east side. It is typical of the Jewish immigrant experience. You can find the book at the library or on line.
[Bread</a> Givers, (0892552905), Anzia Yezierska, Textbooks - Barnes & Noble](<a href=“http://search.barnesandnoble.com/Bread-Givers/Anzia-Yezierska/e/9780892552900/?itm=1&USRI=bread+givers+a+struggle+between+a+father+of+the]Bread”>http://search.barnesandnoble.com/Bread-Givers/Anzia-Yezierska/e/9780892552900/?itm=1&USRI=bread+givers+a+struggle+between+a+father+of+the)
It is available for Nook or Kindle and there are used cheaper copies available too.</p>

<p>The reason I am choosing this book, is to give us a perspective on the American Jewish Community before the Holocaust. When we get to the Holocaust we will have a better sense of where the “greenhorns” minds were at and give us possible explanation for their silence. Yaye made mention to this earlier.</p>

<p>Then April, we could chose from the Holocaust books, maybe Elie Weisel, and May for Israel’s Independence day something about the founding of the State. After we have a little background, then we can get pick current topics.</p>

<p>Bread Givers is is a fast read and I think a good place to start. If you are a male and would prefer to read a Jewish male immigrant story, you can choose, Call it Sleep, by Phillip Roth.</p>

<p>Levi, I read the Goldberg book and it is excellent. Maybe we can start a recommended book list and review too.</p>

<p>When I get back, Rodney, maybe you can help me to set it up as an online chat/ thread (don’t know how cc works) and we can have discussion take place over the course of a week.</p>

<p>What do you all think?</p>

<p>for those of you who want Elon admissions buzz from this cycle, head on over to the Elon thread; don’t want to steer this convo away from samtalya’s idea…</p>

<p>anyway, I think that a moderator will choose the book for the month…since samtalya is going away, lets say that we will start up with a March book for example…since she has a boatload of experience, maybe she can set up a list in order of where she thinks we should start??</p>

<p>Then every month, we have a diff book…the last week of the month whoever has gotten a chance to read, we regroup and discuss…I will help set up the thread at the end of next week (when samtalya gets back)…since March is a long month, no biggie if we get started a little late; let’s shoot for March 7th to post the book of the month?</p>

<p>does that work?</p>

<p>I decided to weigh in on the Hebrew school issue. my kids went to Hebrew school and I think we were very lucky to have a very good congregational school – with principals who reviewed curriculum and were willing to try new materials, with teachers who were exciting – my kids got what we considered an excellent Jewish education and continued in Hebrew HS by their choice. and there were still plenty of parents who complained about the Hebrew school – I think its the nature of the beast – parents will always relive their own experiences and find things to complain about.</p>

<p>I realize that given the hot button issue of Israel on college campuses, it is easy to wish that our kids had been better taught about it in Hebrew school – but I think it is a mistake to expect Hebrew schools to focus on modern Jewish history – ie Holocaust to Israel. I think for many of us, we had parents who had close experience with the Holocaust and I know it colored how our generation was raised (eg "don’t intermarry or you’ll be helping to do what Hitler tried to do) and I saw quite a bit of backlash among the parents in our Hebrew school when their kids were covering the Holocaust in the older grades – they didn’t want the negative focus and some thought their kids were still to young for it. And when they taught about Israel, there was parent feedback expressing concern that no one political stance be advocated!</p>

<p>I think these are important issues to educate our children about – but I don’t believe we should define their Jewish experience and education by modern political history. Nor do I think it appropriate for us to try to define it for them in terms of what they may have to “defend” against. Those types of issues makes Judaism too easy to dismiss like any other political issue. I think it essential that they learn that being Jewish today is part of a tradition spanning thousands of years and to appreciate the rituals and traditions that come with that – not that they have to be told they “must” or even “should” follow all of those rituals and traditions, but that they understand them and have a comfort level with them – that they know what Judaism “is,” not just what it “isn’t.” </p>

<p>If they walk into a Hillel friday night dinner, will they come back again if they feel uncomfortable because they are unfamiliar with the prayers? Will they even try out campus services if they never learned any familiarity with the Hebrew service? What common experiences will help them to want to seek out the type of campus Jewish community many here seem to be hoping their students will find? If we want a political position on Israel to be more meaningful for them than a political position on the federal budget, I think there has to be more of a Jewish foundation before you even get to that issue.</p>

<p>No matter what type of institutional Jewish education we choose for our children – congregational Hebrew school, day school, unaffiliated religious school – that institution can’t cover everything. We as parents have to decide what else we consider important as part of our children’s Jewish education and try to help provide that throughout their lives.</p>

<p>I’d be happy to read any book that you suggest, but I am telling you that the Konner book is a TRANSFORMATIONAL book! Please, people, listen to me and read it!</p>

<p>I guess the question is - where is our starting point? Have people on this thread had exposure to the immigrant experience at that time period and the circumstances that led to immigration (pogroms, escape, etc.)? Or, are people on this thread more “blue-blood” than I am -haha. I grew up with my immigrant grandfather living with us and telling his stories and all of my grandparents were immigrants, so I think that I am pretty familiar with this part of the story, but perhaps people on this thread feel that they are unfamiliar with this. (I mention my grandfather to my kids almost every day, by the way, as a way to tie them to their history.)
If you or your kids never covered this period of history in religious school - I am flabbergasted.
For future reading: one of my college roommates and her family were expelled from Egypt in 1956 - (she was one year old) - and I’d love to read more about this. I find that most non-Jewish people have no idea about the circumstances of Jews in the Middle East and the fact that they were kicked out or made so miserable that they had to leave so many countries.</p>

<p>all of my grandparents were immigrants (blue-blood lololol)…</p>

<p>all from the same area of Russia (yes, weird but true and, no, they didn’t introduce my parents to each other but realized they knew each other later on…)</p>

<p>I think the immigrant experience is VERY different from the origins of the Holocaust; rise of Hitler etc and the modern history of Israel…I am more of an historian about the latter, than the former (I guess since, like levirm, I “lived” it rather than learned about it)…heck, my mother still lives with alot of those values and culture from the immigration/depression era…for another thread; let’s not go there…</p>

<p>Samtalya, the Wiesel books–such as “Night”-- are classics, but the choice depends on what the group wants to learn about. Wiesel writes about the experience within the camps. Others, such as Lucy Davidowicz’s “The War Against the Jews”, describe how the Holocaust was conceived and executed and still others, such as Arthur Morse’s “While 6 Million Died”, discuss the actions (and inactions) of the outside world during the Holocaust.</p>

<p>Unblievablem, I think you raise many fair points, I think your perspective on the difficulties Hebrew schools face pleasing everyone mirrors the difficulty many Hillels face pleasing everyone. You are sincerely concerned about students not not attending Hillel because of lacking knowledge of the prayers; others are sincerely concerned about students not walking into Hillel because, although they learned the prayers, a focus on prayers is what turned them off about Hebrew school and why they lack interest in Hillel.</p>

<p>It is similar to the reactions to an article linked long ago in this thread by an observant student unhappy with his small Hillel because it was more reform/conservative than orthodox: it is very hard for a Hillel to please both the more religious and the more secular. I would not, however, equate the inability of Hebrew schools to please every parent with a conclusion that most Hebrew schools do a good job or that modern Jewish history should not be taught because some parents will still complain.</p>

<p>I think you can teach about both the first 5671 years of Judaism and the last 100; and about what Judaism is, as well as what Israel is. Similarly, although I understand that a few parents might fear teaching about the Holocaust is scary (although Abraham sacrificing his son; the flood wiping out the world; and the enslavement by Egyptians are not much happier topics), that does not mean it should not be taught.</p>

<p>King David is part of Jewish tradition–but so is David Ben Gurion. There is an important ancient Jewish tradition, but there is also an important American Jewish tradition, from Haym Salomon helping fund George Washington, to penniless immigrants working in sweatshops, to Michael Schwerner and Andrew Goodman dying for African American civil rights to Sandy Koufax not pitching on Yom Kippur. I think failing to teach that leads to less kids wanting to walk into Hillel than unfamiliarity with prayers would, but respect your principled disagreement.</p>

<p>levirm - thank you for mentioning the Konner book again - I was thinking about it today and trying to figure out how to find it on this long and winding thread. So - thanks for reading my mind.</p>

<p>Samtalya - thanks for getting the book project underway so quickly - I love your suggestions and the way you have outlined the first few months! I am 100% in.</p>

<p>yabe, I think we should read both types of books. I think we should start with fiction and personal accounts, so those not used to reading more scholarly sources can ease in to it. It has been a while since many of us have been in school. I have read dawidowicz, gilbert, morse, wyman and all the original authors of zionism. still have them on my shelf with all my college notes. studied with some of them.</p>

<p>But I think we should start light and then like you suggested, pick a moderator for the next month and that person will pick the next theme.</p>

<p>I have to go pack, so i will let you all decide. i may have access to the internet, but unless it rains, i am going to try very very hard not to be on the computer.</p>

<p>have a great week everyone.</p>

<p>Related to this book discussion, just wanted to throw out there a suggestion that I really enjoyed and some of you may find equally engaging: Lost: A Search for Six of Six Million by Daniel Mendelsohn. I read it back when it came out ('07?) and it touches upon a lot of issues mentioned on this thread - including the experience of Jewish immigrants to the US prior to the Holocaust, Eastern European Jewish communities over the last 2 centuries, Israel and the development of the country/Zionism, the Jewish diaspora, etc. It’s all just hard to put down (yes, I’m a nerd who read it in one sitting!).</p>

<p>[Amazon.com:</a> The Lost: A Search for Six of Six Million (9780060542979): Daniel Mendelsohn: Books](<a href=“http://www.amazon.com/Lost-Search-Six-Million/dp/0060542977]Amazon.com:”>http://www.amazon.com/Lost-Search-Six-Million/dp/0060542977) </p>

<p>

[quote=From Publishers Weekly:]

As a boy in the 1960s, Mendelsohn could make elderly relatives cry just by entering the room, so much did he resemble his great-uncle Shmiel J</p>

<p>How about this - we start with “Bread Givers” for the month of March as first suggested by Samtalya. When we get to the end of March - we will start a new thread on in the Parent Cafe for the book discussion group. And we can take turns picking a topic and book for the following month. We can tweak this as we go along, of course - but it sounds like a fun and educational idea.</p>

<p>I agree with RVM that it should be a new thread on Parents Cafe, rather than “highjacking” this thread! I am sure there will be plenty of interest in it from people who would not be looking for it under the title colleges for the Jewish B student. I would suggest starting the thread now so that we can post what the book is so people interested can start reading now!</p>

<p>I think Hollie is right, both to gain more readers and to preserve this thread for its important primary mission</p>

<p>yabeyabe – I was not suggesting that any of these issues not be taught – I was pointing out that no matter what a Hebrew school chooses to teach, some parents will find reason to complain. Hebrew schools simply can’t do everything and be everything to all students. But first and foremost I think they have to help students find a meaning to what Judaism is for them – many of the examples you give would be included in that – but, if that is limited to a political identity, it is too easy for it to be undermined if they are faced with information that makes them question the political conclusion. It is not always easy, for example, to be able to articulate that you support Israel even though you disagree with a policy of the Israeli government (I know many Jewish adults who struggle with this, let alone teenagers) – it is easier if you have a more fundamental appreciation for why you support Israel and how that is tied to your religious identity beyond issues of current politics or recent history. </p>

<p>And you are right that many Hillels have that same problem regarding not being able to be everything to everyone – wherever a given Hillel chooses to focus its resources, there will be some students who wish their allocation of resources was different.</p>

<p>That is why I also think it is so important to not just look at the existence of a Hillel, or percentage of Jewish students, but at what the specific school’s Jewish community has to offer and whether it meshes with what a given student is looking for. For some students, it will be a strong religious community. For others, it will simply be the chance to socialize with other Jews. For others, the chance to do social action projects under a Jewish umbrella. Etc., etc. At some schools with larger Jewish communities, there may be multiple points of entry (eg. Chabad AND Hillel; services AND social; services for multiple denominations; etc.) At smaller Hillels, there is more likely to be choices made regarding priorities. And those priorities can change over time in response to students or even changes in professional staff. </p>

<p>I will just throw out the following – when I was looking at schools, there were many situations in which I spoke to parents at my synagogue whose children were at schools we were considering. I often heard that their child wasn’t involved in Hillel because it was “too religious” – and these were often kids who’d been active in our synagogue and strongly identified with their Jewish heritage. Well, when we then went to many of those schools and spoke with people at the Hillel, we were often shocked at how little religious aspect there was to the programming offering (which in fact was something MY kids were looking for) – eg. there were weekly bagel brunches on Sundays, but no weekly religious services. There was one school where a parent warned me that the only people involved in Hillel were “Orthodox,” and we got there to discover quite the opposite was true. Quite honestly, the conclusion I reached was that too often kids don’t even try the Hillel – but rather they believe what they fear may be the case or offer their parents an excuse that they think will strike a chord with the parents. Hopefully the knowledge shared on this thread will help many parents to help their student to find schools where the Jewish community will be the right fit for them or at least get them to explore the real nature of the community available.</p>

<p>Unbelievable, I agree with much of what you say and the rest we can just disagree on.
You are very right that many kids use “too religious” as an excuse for without ever visiting Hillels. </p>

<p>Being activie in a synagague in HS is not always a sign the kids enjoyed it. Often kids dutifully go, in accordance with their parents’ wishes, to a Hebrew school they find boring, burdensome and irrelevant. Many also decide–but do not express–that the many hours spent in Hebrew school and BBYO, etc made them anxious to spend no more time in a Jewish-only environment–sort of “Been there, done that; what’s next.” Once in college, they rebel against their past experience without giving Hillel a chance to prove them wrong. Others simply feel they need not prove they are proud of their heritage through formal activities and, since they like the kids they met early on in their dorm, need not specifically seek out potential Jewish friends.</p>

<p>It reminds me of my long ago college days, when a disproportionate number of the wildest girls on campus were the ones from strict all girls Catholic schools–I suspect the Newman Center and Hillel directors have a lot of similar “What more can we possibly do to get them to give us a chance?” frustrations.</p>

<p>Peace</p>

1 Like

<p>The book club sounds like a great idea! I’d like to participate as well (and will now finally begin to experience that great unknown: the parent cafe :))</p>