<p>Ok - so we will get the thread started on the Parent cafe shortly and open it to all who are interested - not just readers of this thread - and we’ll link it here as well so that everyone can find it. I already ordered my copy of Bread Givers on Amazon along with the Konner book recommended by Levirm. </p>
<p>Can anyone come up with a catchier name for the new thread?</p>
<p>RVM, it is not catchier, but I would be tempted to call it Jewish History Book Club, which makes its purpose clearer (e.g., no Portnoy’s Complaint; Exodus; or The Chosen).</p>
<p>Just glanced at the last 3 pages or so. Would love to be part of a book club. I don’t mind reading books about the holocaust, but not my first choice. My mom is a survivor, so I grew up with stories. I haven’t read the book by Daniel Mendelsohn, but I grew up with him and his brothers. His brother Eric is a film director. Nice to see some local boys do so well! </p>
<p>Please post here when the thread gets started on the parents cafe. I have never looked over there, so I wouldn’t see it.</p>
<p>Regarding the Jewish education of our kids. I really don’t think we have it down right, no matter how you look at it. Sending the kids to Hebrew school for hours after secular school is tough. I have some very strong opinions about Day schools and I’ll just say I considered it, but at the time I didn’t believe it was the right place for my kids. I still feel that way. And I have friends whose kids went to the local day school and my kids have friends who go to the Day school. It will take a greater mind than mine to figure out the right thing though. I do have some friends in the field who are working on it! LOL!</p>
<p>There are so many ways to forge Jewish identity in our children. One of the things I have been enjoying about this discussion is listening to everyone’s ideas.</p>
<p>The one thing I love about being Jewish is that no matter what synagogue I walk into I feel at home. The prayers, torah reading, the community spirit…just love it. I don’t go to shul all that often, but when I do, I enjoy it.</p>
<p>I’m looking forward to joining the bookclub.</p>
<p>I agree that Jewish education needs some improvement. It’s really tough for kids to go sit in a class room for two hours after a full day of school. Some reform temples just have the kids go for 4 hours on Sunday, but that isn’t really enough time to learn Hebrew and all the prayers. As others have mentioned, you need to learn the prayers to feel familar in Synagogue, but the process isn’t much fun for most kids. </p>
<p>My kids had an okay experience at our Conservative hebrew school. They enjoyed the social aspects, and I think it helped make them feel connected to our local Jewish community. We had a wonderful principal who was also their Bat Mitzvah tutor. Working with him really enhanced their experience. The Hebrew High School program was terrible, and both girls quit after a year.</p>
<p>I missed a lot here this week as I’ve been enjoying the Florida sunshine. Back to NY today, then off to St. L for biz tomorrow.</p>
<p>Just want to add that I would love to join the book club too! Hopefully, I will have time to hit the library tonight and find the book so I can read it on the plane tomorrow.</p>
<p>Several thoughts about Hebrew school, but don’t have time to add them all now.</p>
<p>My DD is a Jewish studies minor - it will be interesting to see what she’s going to be learning. Right now, lots of Jewish ideas/philosophies (and she says a lot of it is already familiar to her).</p>
<p>Looking forward to getting involved with the thread again next week.</p>
<p>Regarding the issue of students learning more about Jewish political issues – I can’t recall if the following program has already been mentioned or not – [url=<a href=“http://panim.bbyo.org/]PANIM[/url”>http://panim.bbyo.org/]PANIM[/url</a>]
Not specifically Israel political issues, but in general addresses Jewish advocacy in the political process. I know some kids who participated in various Panim programs and they absolutely LOVED them.</p>
<p>I have expressed previous concerns regarding the suitability of HPU for a Jewish student. Would like to share a quote from the current issue of High Point Magazine written by the university president Nido R. Qubein:</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I recognize that he says all religions are honored - but I guess atheists and agnostics need not apply. Frankly, this quote makes me feel even more strongly that this really is a Christian school.</p>
<p>Very vocal faith and patriotism have always been part of Southern culture. I would not be surprised if similar sentiments were expressed by many at Vanderbilt, College of Charlestown or Elon–or outside the South at Georgetown (although “country” does not get extolled much lately), all of which attract many Jewish students. </p>
<p>This sentiment was expressed widely well beyond the South in the past. One of the best known Yale songs, Bright College Years, written in 1871 but sung even when I was there (although with some smiles and winks in the crowd), concludes “For God, For Country and For Yale”.</p>
<p>But do you think that is an appropriate expression today? Would you see phrasing like that coming from Vanderbilt, CofC or Elon in 2011? I recognize that many students may feel that way - and that’s fine - but coming from the university president? It just made me uncomfortable.</p>
<p>^^ depends on who the university president is…they set the tone for the school in many cases, especially in the smaller ones…</p>
<p>I think many a college president would be very hesitant to use phrasing like that posted…unless they were speaking at a prayer gathering of some sort…</p>
<p>and btw, the “shout it from the mountaintop”?..stolen from MLKjr speech possibly??</p>
<p>just from the brief passage that RVM posted, this president almost sounds like she is a preacher…maybe that was her background…</p>
<p>Thanks for sharing Rockville! Hopefully someone will let him know and (yes, wishful thinking!) but how nice would it be for him to respond here :)</p>
<p>RVM: I reacted the same way you did. I was curious about HPU, so I checked out their website. I think the biggest problem is that they are proud to annouce that their Jewish population has increased to 75 students. That would never have met my family’s preference for at least 10%.</p>
<p>It does look like a beautiful campus with state-of-the-art facilities. A friend who visited described the campus as “Disneyesque.” Her son loved it, but his father (a college professor) was skeptical about some of the faculty credentials.</p>
<p>This thread is very long so I don’t know if someone already posted this, but Rutgers has a Hillel, although I don’t know how active it is. In their brochure they listed it as one of the top student activities.</p>
<p>It is not all language that attracts me (although I am fervently patriotic and a strong believer in social and individual responsibility) and I understand your concern, but I doubt it is unique to Highpoint, or an unusual sentiment in some parts of the US. For a related example, right now in Texas, there is significant support for a bill to allow professors and students to carry guns on campus (depending on your point of view, this is either despite, or because of, school shootings dating back to Charles Whitman using a Texas university ID to bring a rifle on to campus and shoot over a dozen people from a bell tower). This would not happeny in Oregon or Connecticut, but is not unique to Texas, either. </p>
<p>I suspect many northeastern students attracted to southern schools because of the nice weather and friendly folks will encounter much more vocal faith and conservative attitudes than they are used to, which will be a broadening or uncomfortable experience–or both. Take a look, for example, at the enormous disparity between the % of Southern and Northern white Democrats who supported Kerry and not Obama.</p>
<p>Regional differences aside, I frankly have no idea what the Presidents of, for example, Yeshiva, Notre Dame, St. Josephs, Brigham Young, Southern Methodist or Texas Christian say on opening convocations or holiday observances.</p>
<p>^^ on a similar note, do not assume you’re not going to get this at a school that HAS a significant Jewish population; a colleague just told me yesterday that her daughter at UMD-College Park was approached by a group of girls trying to “get her to see the error of her Jewish ways”…</p>
<p>The daughter in question was certainly not expecting that there…</p>