Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>The difference is that at UMD it would be more unusual, IMO, than at a school in another part of the country.</p>

<p>I do agree with yabeyabe, that there is a regional component to these sentiments. I experienced it while living in MO 30 years ago. I did not feel uncomfortable daily, but I felt pretty uncomfortable every now and then. I might add that this area had a Jewish community, but I also attended grad school with some students who never met any Jewish people.</p>

<p>My younger son is in an area of the country where one might expect to come across the same situations that I had 30 years ago. He has not had any negative experiences yet. He finds his campus to be diverse and very accepting of all students.</p>

<p>Rodney - I am flabbergasted! I guess this is more pervasive than I expected. This proselytizing component of religion is just so absent from Judaism that I guess I forget that it is a tenet of many other religions.</p>

<p>We have a significant Mormon community in our suburban Maryland area and pairs of young Mormon men go house to house periodically asking if the resident would like to discuss religion. I just give them a polite but firm “no thanks” and they move on - but I still find that practice irritating as well.</p>

<p>I just find this whole issue very annoying. The presumption that one religion is superior to another and thus people must be converted is just rude.</p>

<p>Its funny and I hadn’t thought about it until today, but for me proselytizing encounters were more pervasive when I lived in NYC, it was not unusual for a complete stranger to come up to me and attempt to save me in places like Central Park, the Village, Washington Square or the “campus” of Hunter College. Maybe it was because I was young, maybe those were target locations but it never upset me, I just listened to differning point of views like a good young liberal and went on my way when i got tired of it. </p>

<p>I was nearly 30 when I moved to Texas but no one has overtly proselytised me or as far as I know either of my kids. On the other hand that High Point University speak,sounds familiar. While loyalty to faith, family and country are common themes the phrasing quoted in that High Point excerpt sounded like words from the pulpet and would make me uncomfortable about the school. It is also not unusual for the term “every religion” to refer to every Protestant demomination and Catholic with non Christian faiths not really entering some folks consciousness. What I’m saying is that my experience in the south hasn’t been so much on people trying to convert me and my family it has more been a general feeling that being Christian is synonomous with being “good” and the reverse is implied for not being Christian. I have to stress that I couldn’t have settled here if that was my usual day to day experience. I have also found this to be more the case in rural areas than in areas that are more cosmopolitan. I expect that is because so much of the social life in these areas revolves around the church. </p>

<p>I am sure there is likely to be a bit of a cultural adjustment in store for kids from large Jewish communities if they choose to go to school in the south. I think that type of experience is the kind of change my older S was craving to have when he yearned to go to school out of Texas. For him it was interesting to experience a different 'culture". As I have said before there are many many more good experiences interspersed between the episodes that are uncomfortable. I wouldn’t lump all southern schools together but I would look at these schools with an eye on the vibe for religous acceptance. There are southern schools I wouldn’t send my kids to and they have frequently been the only Jews in their publics. Yabe is right students in the south are likely to encounter much more converstation about faith and consevative attitudes. As for guns on college campuses in Texas, the letter writing campagn is on. I may have to rethink college in Texas if that one passes. To me its frightening and more people are likely to be killed by this policy than saved, I guess I’m still a Yankee at heart!</p>

<p>Updates from Penn State and Muhlenberg:</p>

<p>[Two</a> Universities Work to Bolster Hillel on Campus | The Jewish Exponent](<a href=“http://www.jewishexponent.com/article/22917/]Two”>http://www.jewishexponent.com/article/22917/)</p>

<p>I recently learned that most of the colleges on S2’s list have an AEPi chaper - CofC, Towson and JMU do and Elon is trying to start one. Given the amount of time he spends with his AZA brothers now - it does seem likely that AEPi or a similar group would appeal to him as much - if not more - than Hillel - which is where my focus has been.</p>

<p>Does anyone have a son in AEPi now or one who graduated recently? If so - what was their experience? Pros and cons? Is a Jewish fraternity different from a secular fraternity?</p>

<p><a href=“http://aepicofc.com//[/url]”>http://aepicofc.com//&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p><a href=“Lost and Found - JMU”>Lost and Found - JMU;

<p><a href=“http://sites.google.com/site/aepitaumu/[/url]”>http://sites.google.com/site/aepitaumu/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>RVM: My nephew is in AEPi at U of Chicago. He never saw himself as a frat boy, but he loves it. He’s made great friends and it has given him a fun social life at the school “where fun comes to die.” There appears to be a fair amount of drinking, but not on the “Animal House” level.</p>

<p>I think that the main difference between Jewish and secular frats is that most of the members are Jewish. They will probably have some Holiday programming and will have more mixers with Jewish sororities. I think that this matters more on a campus with a small number of Jewish students. On campuses with more Jews, many of the secular frats and sororities will have groups of Jewish students. My daughter chose not to join the one Jewish sorority at Penn because it was “too sushi.” She has many Jewish friends in her sorority, but likes having a more diverse mix. Like my nephew, she never saw herself in Greek life, but she really likes it. </p>

<p>Fraternity personalities really vary by campus, so don’t assume that your son will fit it at AEPi everywhere.</p>

<p>I doubt there is a difference between a secular frat and a Jewish one, other than some of the jokes they make and which sororities they target for parties. You may also find that, at the smaller schools, the “Jewish” frats are mixed. I would discount any parent’s assurance that Jewish frats, for example, drink less, unless there is proof beyond the assurances of her child or the decades old recollections of an alumnus.</p>

<p>Admissions staffers will often tell you that their school’s Greek scene is much more about social service projects than partying–I would not believe that either without convincing proof. </p>

<p>There may be certain secular frats at particular campuses which have particular personalities: completely Animal House oriented; all rich kids from a certain area, be it Long Island or Dallas; dominated by members of certain sports teams; popular with theater kids; etc.</p>

<p>As with Hillels, the serach for Jewish frats and sororities often yields a happy failure–the student makes friends of all religions quickly and feel no need for a Jewish affiliation–and fears that joining such an entity sends an excluding message to his or her nonJewish friends. The end result is a partially disappointed parent, but a happy child.</p>

<p>I think many parents overestimate the need for their children to have access to many Jewish students, or a Hillel. I believe this generation of nonJewish kids is much less likely to be antisemetic and this generation of Jewish kids is much less likely to place a high priority on hanging out with and dating Jewish kids because they fear exclusion less and have less of a sense of group identity. </p>

<p>In addition, through the widely used Facebook groups for incoming freshmen classes, kids can get a sense before they arrive on campus of who shares their common interests, from swimming, to heavy metal to Call of Duty 4. Freshmen orientation is also a much more extensive production than what many parents experienced. Consequently, Hillel is no longer as important a portal to finding kids with common interests.</p>

<p>On this thread, I don’t recall any parent reporting a story of a kid going to school in their home region who felt uncomfortable with the kids at their school on religious grounds (I recall a few who switched regions and felt they did not fit in).</p>

<p>Interesting - I’m just thinking the existence of an AEPi chapter would be a plus. But Yabe - you are completely right in that these are my thoughts/concerns/wishes - S2 - continues along in his perpetually unworried state!</p>

<p>RVM, you are worrying about his happiness and his group identity, which is great. And there is no sign that he wants to do the opposite jsut to spite you, as many kids do. His unworried state is a sign of his having a strong self of self, which is great. Consider whether a frat, if it emphasizes doing what the group wants to do when it wants to do it, might not be a fit if your son sets his own priorities.</p>

<p>And, although hazing at most schools is much less nasty than in prior years, there are many kids who will not react well to being told to clean the frat bathrooms’ floors with a toothbrush or walk around campus with their underwear on the outside, etc. </p>

<p>Many kids love Greek life, too; your son will find his own way. Two kids I know went to the same introducotry frat party. One’s reaction was “Not for me; too many drunks thinking they were being funny.” The other’s reaction: “Great party with lots of drunk wild girls!”</p>

<p>And your S2 also sees S1, who is very happy without any Jewish activities and a very small % of Jewish students.</p>

<p>My personal experience with Jewish fraternity life is small-as-a-sliver, but I can sum it up here: S helped start a new chapter of Sigma Alpha Mu (“Sammy”) which was friendly and satisfying to him, in addition to steady membership in Hillel. So he’s a fraternity Founding Father - I joked at him, “so young to be a Dad.”</p>

<p>At his campus, only 10 percent Jewish, the “small and mighty” Hillel tended more to the spiritual/services/political action, while Sammy was just for social fun and bonding friendships, plus a small amount of tz’dakah/charitable service. S enjoyed both organizations for 4 years.</p>

<p>To the extent the Hillel leadership sometimes dissed the new Jewish fraternity, fearing it would compete for attention and members, he found that silly and did not pan out. There was plenty of time, and reason to be connected, to both organizations. The same kids did both.</p>

<p>Significantly, he showed me “Sammy” rules against hazing, in any form, Ever! (down to the toothbrush level…) and I believe him a lot. Yes, they drink at parties off-campus, but no they DON"T haze to initiate any new members, evah!</p>

<p>He said an advantage of Jewish fraternity membership is it’s lifelong, as compared to the friendships from Hillel. He always looks for older “Sammies” in job/internship hunt situations and puts it on his resume in case they pick up on him. During college, he contacted middle-aged fraternity brothers in the larger community when, for example, he was looking for contacts to sell Cutco knives. (LOL, they made appointments with their professional cooks to meet with him…not many sales resulted.)</p>

<p>Full disclosure: I was biased against fraternities/sororities, with older 2 kids attending private LAC’s that banned them from campus entirely. So S-2 really had to convince us this was harmless to his ethical core. Some of the Jewish fraternities go back to the 1920;s, and S-2 bonded with an uncle who had been a Sammy at Cornell back in the l960’s. Not really Animal House. </p>

<p>Jewish fraternities are no substitute for the spiritual and political/intellectual life that Hillel provides by mission statement to each campus. But I did learn they can make a good addition, if the student’s campus is driven by fraternities in general. I’d rather have him join a Jewish fraternity, in other words, than a secular fraternity IF he’s going to join a fraternity. </p>

<p>The dues were costly $500/year because they must fly a representative to a national convention to stay approved at the national level. That was hard for a brand new chapter, but they did local fundraising work to pitch in. They are also too new to own a “house.” When a few of them roomed together off-campus, that was not a “fraternity house.” I’m a real newbie to anything Greek, obviously from my post here. Still I think it was okay and I know son enjoyed and valued it, ALONG WITH Hillel.</p>

<p>What’s interesting to me - and what kind of motivates my relentless searching - is that I always felt sorry for S2 in elementary school and middle school - as he had a very small group of about 4 friends - he was very quiet and shy. I recall S1 going to 25+ Bar/Bat Mitzvahs - S2 - maybe about 3. But, he has changed so much through his involvement in AZA/BBYO - he has just blossomed - he is out every Fri/Sat night - has become so social - leadership skills have developed, etc. So - I think I am kind of hung up on the notion that he needs to continue Hillel or a Jewish fraternity at college so as to continue his social life and have a good college experience.</p>

<p>Yabe - I think he loves being part of a group. BBYO is having a big dance tomorrow night and his AZA chapter color is blue - they are all going wearing as much blue as possible - even painting their faces! I told him they will look like they are representing the movie Avatar, rather than their AZA chapter. But - he loves stuff like that.</p>

<p>LOL, AZAtar.</p>

<p>That’s very funny - I wonder if they already thought of that! DH and I want to sneak in for a moment and take pictures!</p>

<p>at some schools with smaller Jewish populations, the AEpi chapters have both Jewish and non-Jewish kids which I think is terrific!!!</p>

<p>RVM: It’s great that your son has found his niche in BBYO. He probably will enjoy a frat. He’ll also love a school with a lot of school spirit and traditions.</p>

<p>I’ve been AWOL for a while with business and family concerns, but while working my way back thru what’s gone on, I saw the post on AEPi and frats. </p>

<p>My UMich son is at ZBT, which I guess is analogous to AEPi. I’d agree with Yabe that a Jewish frat does not in any way lessen the likelihood of exposure to drinking or partying. But I do have to say that being in the company of and living with other Jewish guys has increased my son’s awareness and participation in Jewish life. It was because of it that he took one of those weekly Jewish classes we discussed here a while ago. And it provided the impetus for his Birthright trip (though he’d gone with us twice before). During holidays away he’s been invited to local friends Passover seders. I’m sure it’s where he’s meeting “nice” Jewish girls.</p>

<p>My son had gone to Day school from kindergarten on and by the time he reached 9th grade, though he could daven, lead a minyan, read Torah and spoke Hebrew fluently, wanted very much to leave that environment to go to regular high school to take advantage of lots of things he couldn’t get in our small Solomon Schechter. During HS he seemed to go even further away from Jewish groups and events. But I think ZBT has given him a back door way of coming back. Maybe it’s because it didn’t have the stigma (in his eyes) of being a Hillel or BBYO or USY type group or of being primarily religious or culturally Jewish. But being with other Jewish boys, many of who knew less about their religion, but who had a greater feeling for it, has really I think, brought him back in many ways. </p>

<p>HS and college is a time when many kids go off in other directions to explore other modes of thought. My sister in law’s children were both very active in BBYO in HS and both had regional posts. Both went in different directions in college. It’s ironic that that my son has been coming back by way of a frat.</p>

<p>On responding to anti-Zionists: this is great dinner-table coversation with your kids! I asked my daughter how she would respond to anti-Zionist rhetoric on campus. She told me that she had already encountered “Free Palestine people” as she called them. She said that they had come to our neighborhood (the heart of the Jewish community) and had blocked pedestrians at a major intersection, saying “This is an Israeli checkpoint.” Her response to them was, “Excuse me, I don’t know what you are trying to accomplish here, but we are just trying to cross the street.” She said to me, “In fairness to the Free Palestine people, they actually think that they are doing something to help the Palestinian people. But they are not helping them at all; they are just doing more to hurt their cause. And I don’t know where they get their information - some of it is just wrong. One of them said that Palestine had been a sovereign nation before Israel - and I just told him that this was factually wrong. And, they fail to ever mention that people in Arab countries have not done anything to help the Palestinians either. Lebanon and Jordan have just kept Palestinians in refugee camps. Wasn’t Jordan supposed to be for the Palestinian people in the first place? What happened with that? And the other Arab countries just use the Palestinian people as pawns.” Another tidbit that she shared: “I don’t think that we have to worry about Egypt right now. The last thing the Egyptian military needs is a war with Israel. I think that a much more dangerous situation is the discovery of oil offshore in water that is disputed by Lebanon. That has the potential to be really explosive.” She went on to explain reasons that she believes that most Israelis have no choice but to support a two state solution.
Your kids may surprise you with what they say, too! I’d be interested to know!</p>

<p>On Jewish fraternities: my S2 recalled an incident during his freshman year when a student walked in after a very large introductory lecture had already started for the hour, wearing white robes, a fake long beard, and carrying a staff. He walked slowly up the aisle, right to the lecturn where the professor was lecturing, banged his staff on the floor, and demanded, “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” My son turned to the student next to him and said, “I know that kid! I went from kindergarten through 8th grade with him!” It turns out that “Moses” had joined a Jewish fraternity and this is what the brothers made him do!
I recently told some of the teachers at the Jewish day school where my kids (and this student) went and they howled!</p>

<p>LOL, Mhc…my H said at his college they referred to ZBT as Zeta Beta Tomato! Have you heard that before? :slight_smile: Glad to hear your S is coming back around again…</p>

<p>I’m keeping an open mind re: Frats and if my S is interested, we’ll have to explore that…my H & I were not part of Frats when we were in College, but our dads were both members of the same Frat…Tau Epsilon Pi (TEP)…it was a coincidence to learn that about them since they grew up and went to college in different states! I think that was a big Jewish frat one at that time…not sure if it’s still active…</p>

<p>RVM: As you know we are leading similar parellel lives and I have many of the same feelings re: S2 as you do…however I’m thrilled to hear that your S2 has come out of his shell and being more active…we hope to accomplish that too as our S2 works his way to upper grades in h.s.</p>

<p>Looks like everyone took a shabbat break? :D</p>

<p>Hi chocchip - we had very high winds yesterday - lost power for most of the afternoon and evening - large tree from neighbors yard fell into our yard damaging our fence and creating a huge mess and we decided today would be just the day to go to Ikea and purchase a tv stand which came in 2 large boxes with a hellish number of pieces and we are going into our 4th hour of assembly. S2 was very happy to don his blue attire and fly the coop!</p>

<p>The only upside to this ridiculous day is that I completely forgot about the ACT scores coming out on Monday for a few hours, which was a nice respite.</p>