<p>PAmom18, welcome! How great that your student is going to Israel! Is he or she going on an organized program?
My daughter only went for the entire summer twice and found it helpful to pack light. You can teach your student to do a hand wash and laundry air dries in Israel very quickly. Will your student be hosted by families? If so, you probably want to pack some gifts to bring to host families. Something light and easy to carry would be good - something “American” such as fan gear from a sports team in your area. One thing that Israelis seem to love but can’t get - Reese’s peanut butter cups - your student could pack some to give as gifts. My kids always insisted on bringing a soccer ball - I thought that it was very bulky to carry around but they found that it allowed them to make friends with Israelis instantly. Keep in mind that Jerusalem can be cold in November and December and that many buildings do not have heat - so your student could benefit from having clothes to layer.
Where is your student going to college after the gap year?</p>
<p>Just saying hello and welcome to new posters tjdad2011 and PAmom18 - nice to see some new faces! </p>
<p>So - our topic of conversation today at home is teacher recs. S2 seems somewhat shy/uncomfortable about asking. I suggested he could e-mail them first and then follow-up in person. I told him he needs to do it this week. We shall see.</p>
<p>Rockville Mom: I suggest you review your list of schools where your son is most likely to apply and then find out if teacher recommendations are required. I would only send them if absolutely required. You might want to call the schools and anonymously ask the admissions office about the necessity for recommendations. Also, if you really need the teacher recommendations, make sure your son feels comfortable asking because you want to be sure that the teacher knows him well enough to write a really good recommendation. Perhaps your son doesn’t need these teacher recommendations. Except for the schools that make it really clear that teacher recommendations are required, I think they are largely a waste of time, unless you are 100% positive that your son will get an exceptional recommendation which means the teacher has to really know him well.</p>
<p>does your school use naviance. i believe there is a section for the student to put the teachers names down that they will request. still think it has to be a personal request. as i said earlier S will not be sending any recs since elon specifically told us not to.</p>
<p>You both make a good point. The majority of the schools on his list do not need teacher recs. I do see that trend expanding - more and more schools do not need them. But, I still feel he should ask at least one teacher - just in case something changes by the fall and he is applying to a school that must have one.</p>
<p>We do have Naviance - but still are pretty old-fashioned as far as asking teachers to write - and they complete and mail a paper form.</p>
<p>I agree that it is not a huge issue. To be honest - I think his recs would be reasonably good, but not amazing. The majority of his teachers are just for this semester - so they have only known him for 3 months. And he will have a counselor rec going out with each transcript.</p>
<p>I agree with you that some of the schools - Towson, CofC, JMU - have made it really clear they don’t want teacher recs. Maybe I will give this issue more thought.</p>
<p>RVM, you are right about setting a deadline. Many teachers limit the number they will write and junior year teachers often prefer to get it done over the Summer when their time is free and their memories are fresh.</p>
<p>Note, too, that having kids ask for recs is often a good exercise in being a self-advocate, both the in person request and the filling out of the form many teachers use requiring the student to give reasons for the recommendation.</p>
<p>Finally, even a child’s current list of schools has nothing but “no rec” schools, remember that new schools may enter the picture next year–and what if the junior year teachers at that point have exhausted their quota or their fresh memories of your child. Finally, if your child hates his freshman year school, a transfer application may benefit from HS recs, especially if your child did not click with freshman teachers or went to a college with very large classes.</p>
<p>Yes - all good reasons to do it. I think Susquehanna is the only school on his list that has a teacher rec as a required item. But I agree completely with what you said - I don’t want him to be stressed in the fall because he suddenly wants to add a school that requires a teacher letter and he did not ask for one. I agree with you as well that this is a good experience for him. He needs to push out of his comfort zone a bit.</p>
<p>I find it odd that schools for 3.x kids would not ask for recs–I know they add to admissions officers’ burdens and that no child submits a bad rec–but Ivies ask for recs and you know that their admissions officers are very burdened and that every single rec they receive is that the kid is extremely smart and hardworking. I would think recs would be more helpful at the 3.x level, where they might help identify the kids who have untapped potential.</p>
<p>yabe - what I see are larger schools no longer asking for teacher recs for several reasons. Take Virginia Tech - 20,000 applicants. They just don’t have the staff to read 20,000+ teacher recs - in addition to the counselor recs that generally arrive with the transcript. There is the issue of matching the recs to the file. While some schools are submitting electronically - many teachers still mail the recs. And if the student has a fairly common name - it can be difficult to match to the file. Then there is the quality of the rec. Private schools tend to do quality narrative letters. Larger public schools - it’s a check sheet and a paragraph - it just doesn’t add that much to the file. From what I have heard lately - colleges are putting more emphasis on the essay and personal statement and less on teacher recs.</p>
<p>But all that being said, I still agree with you that S2 should ask at least one teacher for a rec and we can figure out where to actually send it later.</p>
<p><a href=“GoLocalProv | 6 Hot Trends In College Admissions”>http://www.golocalprov.com/lifestyle/6-hot-trends-in-college-admissions/</a></p>
<p>
</p>
<p><a href=“http://www.usnews.com/mobile/articles_mobile/8-big-changes-to-college-admissions-in-2010-and-2011[/url]”>http://www.usnews.com/mobile/articles_mobile/8-big-changes-to-college-admissions-in-2010-and-2011</a></p>
<p>
</p>
<p>It seems that strong recs can never hurt. My experience with recs is that it is not just a matter of how wonderful the student is but also how well the teacher experesses their message. S1 had recs from both a math and English teacher. This is not to say that math teachers don’t write good recs but the quality of the two were exponentially different and this was not because the quality of the message was so different but I think more that the English teacher as expected was more skilled at using words and thinking like a writer. This compounded by the expectation that students will only send good recs has made them less valuble to some schools. I would however expect that a rec that allows the school to see a new strength in the student could only help.</p>
<p>spectrum - I agree that a good rec can’t hurt and maybe it will help. We do not get to read the recs at our hs - I suspect that this is the case at most places. At a hs with 650 kids in a class - I just imagine the recs are pretty generic and nothing too exciting - at least in most cases. I agree that an amazing rec could be the tipping point for a borderline admit. But an average rec on a form letter - I don’t think it is going to make any difference one way or the other. I happen to agree with colleges phasing out rec letters - this is one variable where students at private high schools or small public schools have a big advantage - so it’s not really a fair criteria.</p>
<p>Rockville - your S should ask his teachers as soon as possible. I know one of D’s teachers will only do a limited number of recs, she told me over break that she already spoke to him about it and he agreed to write one for her. He wants her to turn in the form to him next week. She also asked another teacher who agreed to write one. </p>
<p>I think he should have them lined up. As you said another school or two could get added to the list.</p>
<p>I think we have some Michigan parents and or alumni on this thread. If you wouldn’t mind answering a few questions could you send me a pm? I have some logistical questions regarding getting there. Thanks!</p>
<p>I certainly understand that schools with tens of thousands of applicants will not look at recs. In state publics, also have the issue that whenever they stray from pure numbers, politicians can get involved or discrimination can be suspected.</p>
<p>I am much more surprised when smaller schools, with more manageable applicant pools, do not. </p>
<p>I also think the utility of recs is limited by schools not being clearer about what they are interested in–if there were a Common App form for recs, with a few pointed questions, it would make recs more useful.</p>
<p>I believe this is also a reflection of the “arms race” in admissions–colleges use consultants and mass emailings to increase their number of applicants, to make themselves seem more selective. To encourage kids to use “priority apps”–bogus though they may be–they forego essays and recs. Other schools, having boosted their app numbers and not wanting to hire additional admissions staff, forego recs, but not essays.</p>
<p>Parents, fearful of those artificially inflated selectivity percentages, tell their kids to apply to more schools–thus boosting the number of applications further, and tempting schools even more to avoid the burden of reading recs.</p>
<p>Paents may want to think of recs as “supporting evidence” for an issue they are dealing with in an essay for a kid whose application has certain weaknesses. For example, the kid who suddenly improved as a junior will benefit from a teacher giving a rec which shows that the kid worked hard to improve junior year–otherwise the college may think he just had an easy teacher that year. The kid who wants to major in a particular subject who receives a rec saying he was not just an ordinary A student that year, but a true superstar, should also benefit.</p>
<p>RVM our HS was about the same size as yours when S1 graduated but some teachers chose to give students a copy of the letter. That was their personal decison not policy. I agree that a form rec isn’t really going to do much one way or the other and I also agree with the phasing out of required recs.</p>
<p>Rockvillemom: this is important! Your son should give the teachers a resume when he asks for the recommendations. This is especially important because, according to you, he is quiet (even so quiet that he won’t ask for recs!) and the teachers are less likely to know about his involvement.
Some teachers may refuse the resume, saying that this is not what their rec should be about. But most teachers will be grateful for it.
Also, he might consider asking his BBYO advisor for a rec, again sharing his resume, in case he wants to bolster his application with an extra thing. This might be pertinent to a small school like Elon. Or, he could ask now if this person might be willing to do a rec IN CASE he needs it- and then use it in case of an ED or EA deferral - and then submit it after the deferral.
Good luck!</p>
<p>Also, Rockvillemom, if the 11th grade teachers do not know him well and he is likely to turn over a new leaf in 12th grade and become more verbal and outgoing in class, it is fine to ask a 12th grade teacher for a recommendation after a month or two of class. Sometimes 12th grade teachers are less burdened by recommendation requests.</p>
<p>Another thought on the teacher rec. Does it have to be a teacher rec? With the trend of moving away from the teacher rec, but still having the guidance rec how about thinking outside of the box and using the BBYO adviser as a rec?</p>
<p>Rockville has mentioned her S2 thriving with this outside activity, I think that might be encouraging and make him stand out.</p>
<p>Does anyone know anything Jewish-wise about Guilford College? I have a lot of info about the academics, but nothing on its possible fit for an involved Jewish student. This is for a friend…her son is a bright, shy, socially rather awkward boy. He is a high B student. Any comments?</p>
<p>I agree that RVM’s son should ask the BBYO advisor for a recommendation, as well as a teacher. If he asks now, he will probably need to follow up with the teacher in the fall. We found that the common ap and most of the colleges had a recommendation form that the teacher had to fill out. Those forms might change, and the updated applications probably won’t be available until August. My daughter waited until school started to ask teachers for recs. She then gave them a cover letter, a copy of the form for each school, a copy of her resume, and an envelope addressed to each college’s admissions dept.</p>