<p>Wow CC is busy the last 24 hours; so many waitlist calls and SO early…</p>
<p>anyway, to address a few of the things being discussed here:</p>
<p>Recs: I still think that it is important to have them on file…our guidance office sends them out to all schools, even if they do not request them; our teachers tend to write very personalized and specific recommendations about the students’ strengths, weaknesses, maturity changes and growth…I’m sure some of the schools throw them out, but they do add to the application especially in this GPA range; the numbers don’t always tell the whole story…I ALSO think that some of the guidance counselors read the recs and use some of the positive qualities displayed in their own recs…students are not permitted to see recommendations at any point in the process…</p>
<p>also, in this group of schools, you will not be penalized by sending; worse come to worse, they will be ignored…I think one of the basic reasons why they are not used anymore in certain places is because of technology; the recs come on paper in most cases; many schools applications are not submitted electronically; unless someone is assigned to scan the recs, there is no process for including them in the application online…
that’s my take…</p>
<p>QM: I think someone else on this thread was exploring Guilford at one time but maybe it was another thread (the 3.0-3.3 one maybe)…my older D (class of 2008) had a very close friend (Jewish, male) who attended Guilford as a freshman; he hated it…transferred after freshman year; it was very out of the box (for him), very small Jewish life, too small overall, etc…not a good fit on many levels…his comments to me included, “the kids were just very quirky”…</p>
<p>News from Elon: Professor of Jewish Studies has been hired for the fall…in today’s Pendulum…will post link in a minute…</p>
<p>I just learned that as of this year our school district has decided to eliminate weighted GPA from the HS transcript. For the first time GPA appears on a 4 point scale and it is unweighted. This is an average public hs in Texas. I’m interested in knowing if people in different parts of the country see this as a disadvantage for college admissions.</p>
<p>spectrum: depends on whether or not class rank is used…how will this affect UT admissions? will that mean that if students are in APs/honors they will be ranked but not get a weighted GPA for ranking?..</p>
<p>many,many schools have gone to an unweighted GPA but without ranking…those that have kept ranking have, for the most part, kept weighting…</p>
<p>one more note on this: Univ of Michigan, where GPA is the top criteria for admission, no longer recalculates GPA; they take whatever is on the transcript…the change in your district can not be a good thing for this type of admissions unless you have grade inflation in your school…same with a lot of other publics and large schools…</p>
<p>it prob won’t matter at smaller schools that know your HS or have the resources to examine the school profile…</p>
<p>Thanks for the info, rodney. The boy in question is also very “quirky” so maybe that’s why they are interested in Guilford. I will pass on the info to his mother anyway.</p>
<p>I agree with those who say that it can’t hurt to have the rec letters on file. The GC will read them and take information from the teachers that will be useful in writing the GC recommendation. When you request transcripts, etc to be sent to a given college, you can always instruct the Guidance office to omit sending the teacher recs if you’d like.</p>
<p>Always, always have your student give the recommending teacher a resume. He or she will not know the extent of your child’s involvement outside of the classroom.</p>
<p>The teacher asked does not have to be the one for which your student has earned the highest grade either. RVM son is interested in business, for example. The likely candidate is a teacher who has had him in a business-related class.</p>
<p>Many teachers take pride in writing informative recs. My son was told by a friend that an admissions rep from HYP once asked if teacher X was still around, because he writes really helpful recs. The GC may be able to clue you in on which teachers are good at this, as opposed to those who write generically.</p>
<p>Maybe this was already said but with respect to letters of rec even if you don’t need them for the main application, if you get waitlisted of deferred in the EA round, it’s nice to have an extra letter of rec to send with your update. My son sent letters of rec fron senior year teachers when he was deferred in the EA round to regular and he was accepted from all those schools in the Regular round.</p>
<p>Rodney: Yes they are still ranking and for the moment still weighting advanced classes for rank. Ranking is required in Texas. How they rank is more nebulous as I understand it. This won’t affect UT or TAMU admission. I’m thinking it might hurt people applying OOS and may hurt admission into some more competitive programs at UT and TAMU that are made by review rather than straight numbers. I guess my question refers to how this effect applications to schools that admit by review and not straight rank as they do at UT and TAMU. It not like our school’s reputation will take our students far because the vast majority of applications are in state.</p>
<p>^^applications to schools that admit by review will be fine; they will have the rigor described by honors and AP designations, and they will have the school profile…they usually unweight the GPA’s anyway with their own formula so your school unweighting really doesn’t matter…</p>
<p>Thank you for all of the teacher rec comments and suggestions. Interesting to see some different viewpoints on this. Will discuss with son tonight - I do think he should go forward with making the requests this week.</p>
<p>Re. Gap year in Israel @levirm
PAkid is going to spend 9 months there, so thanks for the advice to pack all kinds of clothes. This month has been very very stressful as we were trying to negotiate. In the end, he won and he is going. He is not sure where he is going FA12 since his top choice was a rejection, and his second choice did not let him defer since they have a rolling admission policy. He will reapply while he is abroad and maybe have a different list. It probably will be awfully hard on me trying to support him from so far but at the same time it will give him a different perspective, right?</p>
<p>Something that I don’t think has been mentioned yet. Asking for the recommendations (I vote for in person, btw) is good practice, too. Kids have spent all these years with the adults being in charge and orchestrating so much about their lives. When they go to college it’s much more on them. <em>They</em> are going to be the ones talking to the administrators and professors when things go amiss, and they are going to be the ones who need to be organized and take charge to make sure things <em>don’t</em> go amiss. </p>
<p>As a side note, this is one reason why it’s really nice when students are able, if they’re ready, to take classes at a community college before moving away to attend a university. They start getting their feet wet at being an adult when it comes to matters related to their education. </p>
<p>The way students are treated at a college is different than the way they are treated at a high school. The more they learn now how to handle some of these responsibilities, the easier it will be and the better they will be at it when they’re out on their own. Less stress for them on down the line. I think it’s really good if the kids can work on skills dealing with admin matters like scheduling and managing academic life (working with professors) now, because living out on their own, at least a lot more so than they have thus far, is a major change. That part will be providing plenty of challenge. Also, if they already understand how to negotiate the ropes with more regular stuff related to the education part, then they may be more ready to take steps like trying for grants, research opportunities, or internships.</p>
<p>D is turning in her teacher rec forms to the teachers next week. I see that it is recommended to attach a resume. Is there a template that anyone would suggest, or a source for a good format?</p>
<p>I can’t believe the list of colleges going to their wait list so early. What does everyone think that means for next years admissions. Think they will admit more, or do colleges prefer to admit less and go to their waitlists? </p>
<p>spectrum2 - unweighted gpa may hurt the applicant at some schools. I know that Indiana University said that they take whatever gpa is on the transcript that is higher, so if wgpa is on there they use it. Also helps with merit awards.</p>
<p>Also, don’t know how familiar everyone is with the Soref Initiative of Hillel - called “Small and Mighty” - trying to grow Jewish life on “campuses with emerging Jewish student life.” Their website is [SMALL</a> AND MIGHTY](<a href=“http://smallandmighty.org/]SMALL”>http://smallandmighty.org/).</p>
<p>Participating schools are:
Albion College
Albright College
Alfred University
Allegheny College
American International College
American Jewish University
Amherst College
Appalachian State University
Armstrong Atlantic State University
Auburn University
Augustana College
Ball State University
Bard College
Bentley University
Birmingham-Southern College
Boston College
Bowdoin College
Bowling Green State University
Bradley University
Butler University
C.W. Post Center of Long Island University
California Lutheran University
California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo
California State University, Chico
California State University, Fullerton
Capital University
Carleton College
Central Connecticut State University
Central Michigan University
Central Washington University
Chapman University
Clarion University
Clarkson University
Colby College
Colgate University
College of Charleston
College of Wooster
Colorado College
Connecticut College
Cornell College
CUNY, John Jay College of Criminal Justice
Curry College
Davidson College
DePauw University
Dickinson College
Drake University
Drew University
Duquesne University
Earlham College
East Carolina University
East Tennessee State University
Eastern Connecticut State University
Eckerd College
Edison College
Elizabethtown College
Elmira College
Elon University
Emerson College
Evergreen State College
Florida Atlantic University Harriet L. Wilkes Honors College
Florida Gulf Coast University
Florida Institute of Technology, Melbourne
Fordham University
Framingham State College
Franklin & Marshall College
Frostburg State University
Georgia College and State University
Georgia Institute of Technology
Georgia Perimeter College
Georgia State University
Gettysburg College
Grand Valley State University
Grossmont Community College
Guilford College
Hamilton College
Hampshire College
Hendrix College
Hiram College
Hobart and William Smith Colleges
Hood College
Illinois Wesleyan University
Indiana University-Purdue University, Indianapolis
Jacksonville University
James Madison University
Juniata College
Kansas State University
Kennesaw State University
Kenyon College
Lafayette College
Lake Forest College
Landmark College
Lehigh University
Lehman College
Lewis & Clark College
Louisiana State University - Baton Rouge
Loyola Marymount University
Lynchburg College
Marymount Manhattan College
Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts
McDaniel College
Mesa Community College
Middlebury College
Millersville University
Millsaps College
Mississippi State University
Montclair State University
Moravian College
Mount Holyoke College
New College of Florida
New School University
Northern Arizona University
Northern Illinois University
Northern Michigan University
Norwalk Community College
Occidental College
Ohio Wesleyan University
Old Dominion University
Orange Coast College
Oregon State University
Pace University
Penn State College of Medicine
Quinnipiac University
Radford University
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
Rider University
Roanoke College
Roger Williams University
Rowan University
Salisbury University
Santa Barbara City College
Savannah College of Art and Design
School of Visual Arts
Shippensburg University
Simmons College
Southern Connecticut State University
Southern Illinois University, Edwardsville
Springfield College
St. Edward`s University
St. George’s University
St. Petersburg College, Seminole Campus
Stephen F. Austin State University
Stetson University
Suffolk University
SUNY College at Cortland
SUNY College at Oneonta
SUNY College at Oswego
SUNY College at Plattsburgh
SUNY Fashion Institute of Technology
Susquehanna University
Texas Tech University
The College of New Jersey
Truman State University
U. S. Coast Guard Academy
Union College
University of Akron
University of Alabama
University of Alabama at Birmingham
University of Arkansas
University of Hawaii Hilo
University of Mary Washington
University of Massachusetts, Boston Harbor
University of Montana
University of Nevada, Reno
University of North Carolina, Asheville
University of North Carolina, Greensboro
University of North Carolina, Wilmington
University of Northern Colorado
University of Puget Sound
University of Redlands
University of South Carolina
University of South Florida Sarasota-Manatee
University of Southern Maine
University of Tennessee, Knoxville
University of Texas, San Antonio
University of the Pacific
University of Toledo
University of Wisconsin - Oshkosh
University of Wisconsin- La Crosse
University of Wyoming
Ursinus College
Valdosta State University
Vassar College
Wagner College
Wake Forest University
Warren Wilson College
Washington and Jefferson College
Washington and Lee University
Washington State University
Wellesley College
West Chester University
West Virginia University
Western Michigan University
Western Washington University
Westminster College
Wheaton College
Whitman College
Williams College
Wittenberg University
Wofford College
York College of Pennsylvania</p>
<p>JMTC: yes, I saw that this morning as well…interesting…</p>
<p>mdmomfromli: I think that the waitlists will be around for years to come now; its a way to tweak the freshman classes and increase yield for the high fliers; for the lower tier schools it is a way to make sure they are not over-enrolled as well and a way to flush out the full payers who really want to be there from the mass of people who applied RD just because the school was on common app…</p>
<p>In fact, if this year works out as its turning out, I believe the waitlists will be used even more in the future…</p>
<p>There are some schools on the small and mighty list that have sparked my interest. Old Dominion? thoughts? as well as Georgia Institute of Technology and Boston College. BC does not strike me as a B school, but maybe I am misled.</p>
<p>Boston College is a tough admit - an “A” student school and even then many are waitlisted. I would place it with Wake Forest, Villanova and University of Richmond academically and admissions-wise.</p>
<p>Georgia Tech - I do think was mentioned recently. Might be within reach for a B+ student with strong test scores.</p>
<p>Georgia Tech: note the difference between math and critical reading SAT scores. This is because it is fabulous in engineering: ranked something like #4 in the country and very tough to get in.</p>