Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>^^ you could always have him apply and see, if accepted, which option he is offered…</p>

<p>If my son is was told that he could not take classes in Fall, he would not go to UF. I think that if this does come to be, UF will be “cutting off their nose to spite their face”.
My son is definitely applying to UF for summer B admission but if he gets put into the “experiment” group, he will decline admission. UF gets about 6500 freshman every year. The article says they are planning to do this experiment with 2000 kids. I still think it is worth applying, even as an OOS cherryhillmomto2.</p>

<p>Rodney - Congrats on the language placement. That was a huge relief for us. My d is working full time at the JCC summer camp. As an ed major, she needs to work with kids. I like having the structure. It is interesting. Almost none of her friends worked last year but almost all are working this year. They all said that having that much free time was not good - it motivated them to look for work in earnest.</p>

<p>Rockvillemom and others interested in visiting Pitt: it is helpful to understand up front that this is an urban campus. Somehow it doesn’t feel as urban to me as NYU, BU or GW, because there is more space between buildings, but there is no gate to enter campus, no quad, and the campus is superimposed on walkable city streets with sidewalks. A Pitt building might be next to an office building, an apartment building, a house, etc. In order to get to the athletic facilities and the “upper campus” where a number of the fraternities and more housing are located, students walk up a hill past the hospitals. Students who want to hang out in an open space can do so on the large lawn of the Cathedral of Learning, or Schenley Park which has a plaza adjacent to the campus, a hill that functions as a “beach” that is really more behind CMU but Pitt students also go there, and then wooded areas with hiking trails. This park is used by the whole city, including the students. Just next to the plaza are the Carnegie Museums of Art and Natural History, Carnegie Library, and Carnegie Music Hall, and then CMU is next to that. The Jewish University Center is across the street from the museums.
You just have to be aware that you are visiting a city! But, it is a city with trees.
CMU, Chatham, and Duquesne have campuses with quads that are more separated from the surroundings. Point Park is even more urban than Pitt because it is downtown.</p>

<p>Rodney - Congrats to your daughter for placing out of the language requirement. I’m curious to see how my daughter does on her placement test. </p>

<p>Cherryhill: I’m not sure that UF is the best choice for a reach school. The few kids from my area that attended ended up transferring. I’ve heard that it’s a very tough school socially for out of state kids because they have a very small percentage of OOS. I also think that this no fall option sounds very unappealing. Is UMDCP on his list? It’s pretty similar (other than weather) but seems like a better choice OOS. I can’t remember what else you have on his list. Why don’t you post it and let us know his preferences so we can offer suggestions.</p>

<p>My older daughter flies home from Israel today. She has had an amazing time on her birthright trip. She learned a lot about the political situation in Israel. She already had a stong committment to Judaism, but I think that she now understands why Jews must support Israel. Please encourage your college age kids to take advantage of this wonderful opportunity. The application process can be aggravating, but it’s worth it to keep on trying.</p>

<p>Deborah, have to admit I have never even met a homeschooled person, at least that I know of. I’m sure many are incredibly smart. I was just stating a fact about actuaries. These are people who do calculus in their heads like it’s 2+2. That aptitude for higher math is nearly impossible to develop with time and effort. If you don’t have it in high school, you’re probably not going to develop it in college. That is to say, if math is a struggle in high school, you’re not going to be an actuary. And, in general, the kids who are getting A’s in high school calculus are usually getting A’s in most of their other classes. Trust me, the dozens of actuaries I know were all top students their entire lives. You are correct, there are reasons why some smart people may not get high grades at some times. I’m not counting anyone out. I’m just saying it’s exceedingly rare to find an actuary who was less than outstanding in high school.</p>

<p>momjr, texasmother: thanks!! she was thrilled but realized that because it was a multiple choice test for the placement, it was INFINITELY easier than her classes in HS were; she has not had a multiple choice test in any subject since 8th grade…</p>

<p>momjr: glad your daughter enjoyed the trip; when my older one came home last year, even though it was a short trip, she really felt like the US had NO historical significance/culture…thought that was an interesting reaction; she just loved Israel; would literally go back every year if she could…</p>

<p>Chardo, it sounds like the main point you want to emphasize is an actuary is going to need to have <em>strong</em> math skills. Not disagreeing at all. </p>

<p>I would suggest reconsidering this assumption, btw, based on input I’ve seen from other parents over the years:</p>

<p>“And, in general, the kids who are getting A’s in high school calculus are usually getting A’s in most of their other classes.”</p>

<p>There are well-rounded students and lopsided ones and places in the world for both. :-)</p>

<p>As a side note, I’m told regularly by someone near and dear to me I would make a good actuary. Wouldn’t surprise me, but I don’t think I’ll be pursuing it anytime soon.</p>

<p>For those of you with high school seniors who’ve been very involved in the Jewish community–seeing any senioritis? D1 is just tired of the whole shebang. She has a few end of year USY activities, but she’s more burned out than looking forward to this as being the end of an era. She attends a supplemental hebrew educational program, which she’s been going to since she was in 8th grade. This year, she stepped down from 3 days a week to 1; that was a wise choice, because with the rush of senior year commitments, she barely attended. </p>

<p>Time for something different for her. </p>

<p>Speaking of that supplemental hebrew program, let me vent. Our family is not big into graduation ceremonies, or at least not those that come before college :). The supplemental program does a graduation ceremony, with a reception afterwards and a DJ. Not our family’s kind of thing, and there was a cost. Given that D1 is somewhat burned out on the program, I asked if she wanted to attend–which she did. She did not, however, want to write several essays to make up for missing some parts of the program this year, so she won’t be getting a diploma. Again, no big deal, but how short-sighted of the program! If they award some sort of diploma to the graduates who attended the one-day-a-week program for 3, 4, or 5 years, why not make up some kind of diploma to hand to the kid who attended the 3-day-a-week program for 4 years, and then attended minimally the final year? Do they really think that a piece of paper is enough of an inducement to make a second semester high school senior write essays? Arghhhhh!!!</p>

<p>OK, thanks, that felt good. :)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Differentiating, sure. Integrating, it depends. ;)</p>

<p>ST: That does sound aggravating! I’m impressed that your daughter hung in as long as she did. My daughter quit Hebrew High School after 8th grade because the program was really dull. It was a shame because she really bonded with her hebrew school class during her bat mitzvah year and wanted to continue, but then hated the high school program. Some of her friends were active in BBYO, but she tried it and didn’t choose to get involved. She does have a strong Jewish identity, and only considered colleges with a substantial percentage of Jewish students, so I’m hopeful that she will have some involvement in college.</p>

<p>My kids didn’t care for the heavily social aspect of USY, etc. They were eager to be involved in the Jewish community, but wanted that commitment to have more meat on it, given that they had a lot of time constraints already. Both leyned regularly and S2 spent many, many hours doing catering for shul events. S2 and DH really bonded over all that cooking.</p>

<p>SlitheyTove - that’s really a shame - and very short-sighted as well. Why do anything that would diminish the significance of what she has accomplished? So few Jewish students continue their religious education past 10th grade - what a poor policy to discourage those who want a little bit - but not a huge time commitment.</p>

<p>In other news, our large public hs published their annual list of where the seniors are going to college today. No real surprises - most are staying in-state and will be attending UMDCP, UMD-BC, Towson, Salisbury or Frostburg. The next largest group are heading to large public universities - Penn State, Virginia Tech, James Madison, Delaware, West Virginia, Pitt, South Carolina and Georgia. I asked S2 if he had looked at the list - gotten any new ideas - what he thoguht, etc. Not much of a response. Back to the college talk moritorium for now.</p>

<p>Rockville - D and I just finished going through the list. I agree, no surprise with the number of kids going to in state schools. Does seem like a lot more are going to community college then I noticed in the past. Maybe I am just paying more attention. Last year 135 enrolled at UMDCP this year it decreased to 107. I think that’s a rather large decrease.</p>

<p>On the other hand the one thing I am surprised at is the number of students who will be attending an Ivy League school dropped by 1/2. Last year 22 enrolled, this year 11. Just wondering is the school losing favor at some of the more elite schools? </p>

<p>Otherwise, other than all of the large publics you mentioned there was a nice smattering of private schools. Noticed a number of students heading to Wake Forest University!</p>

<p>First thank you so much for the thoughts about career choices for a student with strong math and social skills. I’m sorry we’ve had company and I haven’t had a chance to log on until tonight. Chocchip, I think you are understanding where my S is coming from. So far math has come to him easily. He is a somewhat lopsided student as Deboarah describes but does well enough in everything. His greatest enemies are long tests and time constraints but such is life. From that angle though, I don’t think he would be happy or successful in a career that involved long uninterrupted hours of calculations. Being among people and creating laughter is where he shines. He just needs to figure out a way to get paid for that :).
Texasmother: Supply chain management is not a field that I am familiar with at all we need to research that one. The informational interviews that you mentioned, were those at the schools your S applied to? My S is like yours not all that interested in CS. I have also thought of trying to encourage accounting. While my image of this is dull from what I have read it seems that it is a respected major and relatively easy to branch into other aspects of business from that starting point. Finance sounds like an area that might be more immediately appealing to him. I really appreciate everyone’s thoughts and conversation about this. Especially all of the discussion about actuary science. You have given us a lot to think about.</p>

<p>BTW: He did speak to is Alg2 teacher who is also the BC Calc teacher about career possibilites, don’t you know, she suggested engineering for him and it seems like he is hearing that suggestion for the first time. He is giving it some thought but I don’t think he will go that way. All along I’ve been encouraging him to try to get into the B school as a freshman knowing full well his desires might change but that it would be relatively easy to switch to other majors. I know that isn’t true with engineering. Both the B schools and engineering schools are competitive to get into so I hope he sorts that out by August. I expect we will have a sense of just how strong a math student S is next year. It seems that in their conversations his teacher convinced him to take BC calc instead of AB. Its good to know she has confidence in him. He on the otherhand is craving a fun senior year. I am soooo happy we are finished with Junior year!!</p>

<p>ST: Vent away, it is just that kind of thing that would also get me going!</p>

<p>Momjr: Its great to hear that it has been a wonderful trip for your daughter. It was so long in coming.</p>

<p>Our local school district (Philly suburbs) just published a list of the top ten schools that our local high school students applied to (this is not a list of actual attendance):</p>

<p>Pitt
Penn State
Temple
Drexel
U Penn
West Chester
U Maryland
U Michigan
NYU
Tulane</p>

<p>So- I was a little surprised to see Pitt topping the list! Its become a hot school around here.</p>

<p>If anyone is planning to visit Pitt this summer, I recommend visiting during one of their special events like Ready, Set, Pitt! Since college campuses can be empty during the summer, going during a special event seems much more festive. Pitt’s event was very well attended and there were tons of “Pitt Pathfinders” (student guides) to take small groups on tours and answer questions. Plus, if you visit during one of these events, they waive the application fee.</p>

<p>PAMom-So interesting that Pitt beat out PSU for Philly suburb kids. Surprised that Penn is in top 5 also.</p>

1 Like

<p>Spectrum: Your son sounds a lot like my nephew. He’s bright and has an amazing personality. He majored in business with a finance concentration at UMDCP. He found the program to be reatively easy and put a lot of time into leadership for his frat. He got a great consulting job in DC right out of college and is doing very well.</p>

<p>It sounds like the top college choices at our HS are similar to those of RVM. A lot of kids stay in state or go to other publics on the east coast. A fair number start at our very good community college. A lot of my daughter’s male friends who are nice kids but not serious students are going to the CC. I’m not all that surprised to see Penn in the top 5 on Pamom’s list. I think that Penn gives some preference for Philly area kids, and especially for employees kids. JHU does the same thing with students from the Baltimore area. </p>

<p>Today is my D2’s last day of school! Graduation is Tuesday.</p>

<p>UF isn’t a safety for anyone. Need a high GPA, ECs (sports are big), and alum doesn’t hurt.</p>

<p>I live in FL. That school has gotten Ivy tough! You wouldn’t blv the kids who don’t get in!!
My brother is there and as much as I want to get out of state, if $$ is the issue, I hope I get in!</p>

<p>Pamom-We live in the western suburbs of Philadelphia too and I would venture that the top list that you put forth would be similar at our high school. Pitt is so popular and everyone that we have known that has gone (my daughter is hs junior), has absolutely loved it! We visited and although dd thought it was too big a school for her and did not have her BFA program, we loved the school. The campus is urban, but seems so much safer than many other urban school, it was beautiful and they really are flexible and lots of kids do double majors, which is so great. We spent most of our extra time at the art dept. and there, kids were double majoring in art and bio-psychology and art and math! I loved this. </p>

<p>We also loved Pittsburgh. Lots of colleges, decent restaurants and of course, the Strip! Dd loved CMU and we all loved the jewish student center between Pitt and CMU. I would suggest Pitt to almost every kid I know.</p>

<p>We have a cousin (Jewish) at Pitt. He loves the school spirit around sports and is happy there. One potential (minor) negative that his mother mentioned recently: as at many large/state universities, it can be hard to get into some first choice courses. Actually, this is probably true at most if not all colleges and universities. But a potential Pitt applicant might want to look into this in the context of possible major(s).</p>