Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Re my comment above, just remembered what else the Pitt mother said: for students who are closed out of a course but are persistent, it can be possible to still get into it - ie by showing up at the first class and speaking to the professor. She said her daughter has been successful doing this at another well known large state U. Her son, however, isn’t as assertive as his sister. If he is closed out of a course, his attitude is more likely to be ‘oh, well’ and then to make do with whatever courses are available.</p>

<p>So many great comments about Pitt! But given that S2 thought Virginia Tech too large and CofC too urban - I guess it makes little sense to suggest a fairly large urban school! :slight_smile: Oh well.</p>

<p>I also want to add that the issue of being closed out of a desired course is not at all limited to large universities - S1 has experienced this at Wake Forest as well. However, they do have a pretty reasonable waitlist policy and you can also speak with the professor - so it usually works out. I used to be under the impression that one would encounter this problem more frequently the larger the school - not sure that is really the case.</p>

<p>spectrum - just want to add that S1 is a finance major. He started out as a general business major - but felt finance was more well-regarded - and he is doing well in it. He has very strong math skills - also very analytical. Please let me know if I can answer any questions for you about this major.</p>

<p>have any students on this thread considered Dickinson? It was a school my son really liked and it seemed to have an interesting, if small Jewish community.</p>

<p>Dickinson - another school I would be happy to have on S2’s list! At one point - I thought it might be too much for him - I no longer think that is the case. It does have a bit of an International focus - the business major, for example, is International Business. I think it would be a great choice for someone willing to consider smaller schools - about 2400 students. Offers early action and takes the Common App.</p>

<p>Looking at our Naviance - I’d call it more of a B+/A- student school. Most accepted students have around a 4.0 wgpa and around a 30 ACT. Would be a reach for a true B student.</p>

<p>National Naviance:</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 5033
Accepted: 2405
Percent Accepted: 47.78%
Enrolled: 658</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 30 27 28</p>

<p>In this economy, with colleges stretching faculty resources to the limit, being closed out of a course is likely to become more and more common across the board. Speaking as a prof, personal contact with the instructor can help; I’m more likely to sign an overload for a student who has taken the time to contact me directly, come to the first couple of classes even though they aren’t enrolled, and has participated constructively in class discussions. That said, sometimes even then my bureaucracy won’t let me sign the overload slip. </p>

<p>(Emailing almost never works, by the way. For my reticent child, it’s much easier, but I can tell you, it’s ten thousand times easier to reject a potential overload student via email than it is face-to-face. Have your kids make the effort to stop by the professor’s office personally!)</p>

<p>My son had extensive conversations with his regional admissions rep at Dickinson…their admissions process is extremely holistic and individualized…and for what it might be worth, my son felt that the facts that he was 1)male, and 2)Jewish, were factors considerably in his favor.</p>

<p>He thought the campus was absolutely wonderful…he loved the groups of adirondack chairs grouped all over the lawns, and he felt the campus town offered a lot more variety than he had expected. </p>

<p>The Hillel was small but in a nice little house right next to the admissions office. I think I remember the Jewish studies department being housed at the Hillel?</p>

<p>Dickinson sounds nice. We saw Gettysburg last year - S2 was not into it. I’d be thrilled to look at a few more small schools in PA - Muhlenberg, Dickinson, etc. - so far - no interest. </p>

<p>So far - Gettysburg was too small - Susquehanna is still on the list - but who knows. Virginia Tech was too big and CofC was too urban. So - when I point out to him that there just are not that many 5000-8000 student schools within driving range that are suburban campuses and have a reasonable Jewish population - I just get a shrug. Of course, Elon fits the criteria perfectly and he will be applying there. I just wish there was another school similar to Elon that would work as well.</p>

<p>But anyway - he is away on a BBYO camping trip this weekend - S1 is back at school - DH and I have an empty nest for the weekend and we are enjoying it!</p>

<p>RVM: Thanks for offering to help with information on finance and Momjr, your nephew’s path is encouraging. I would love it if my S followed a similar path. We’ve gotten lots of things to think about, now I guess I have to wait and see which way my S is inspired. Again I really appreciate all of the suggestions. It helps me see some real direction possibilites that I wasn’t seeing when I was looking at the vague Business major.</p>

<p>Have a great weekend everyone!</p>

<p>RVM: I hear what you are saying but at least you have located one school that fits all of the criteria. For us it came down to dropping either the size criteria or the distance one. There simply is no school within driving range that is small to midsized and still has a reasonable Jewish population. I am quietly glad that S chose size. Good luck, it really surprises me that in your area that is such a difficult thing to find!</p>

<p>For us, that school ^^^ is the University of Miami! I think that this would be a great place for my son. Now I just have to somehow get him to think that too! It is only a one hour drive, midsize, nice Jewish population, they give merit money, it is climbing in rankings and parents on CC have had very good experiences there. </p>

<p>How far is Elon from a major airport?</p>

<p>spectrum - you have hit the nail on the head! I feel he should either apply ED to Elon OR - we have to reevaluate the criteria and adjust something. Either he has to be open to smaller schools OR larger schools OR be willing to consider NY/MA/CT OR be willing to fly to Florida or another state. I am hoping that at the end of June we can sit down and make some decisions. But, I am also open to the possibility that he will still be unsure of what he wants to do - in which case - my plan is just to start with the Common App in August - do a few safety schools - Towson and so forth - and then go from there.</p>

<p>seiclan - interesting comments on Miami. If we include Florida - S2 would apply to both Tampa and Miami. They both fit our criteria well - except for the flying issue.</p>

<p>Elon is close to the Greensboro airport - not sure that is a major airport though. I guess Raleigh-Durham would be the nearest major airport. For us - it is a 5 hour drive - depending on traffic.</p>

<p>Whew! Just checking in…survived senior prom and several end of the year activities this week. Next week, awards assembly, graduation and party from us to S. And a million other grad parties too!</p>

<p>RVM: Not sure why I’m so fixated on Univ. of Richmond…maybe because our g.c. mentioned it to us early in the game and he is a personal friend and very knowledgeable, so I suppose his suggestion would be a good one…too far for us, but close enough for you??
Hope you’re enjoying your “empty nester” weekend w/o kids…we’re busy cleaning up and throwing away before big grad. party.</p>

<p>momjr: So? How was D’s birthright trip? How soon does she want to go back?:)</p>

<p>seiclan: my nephew loves UMiami!</p>

<p>chocchip - Univ of Richmond is on my list of schools to visit this fall - if he wants to do so. On our hs Naviance - he looks borderline between accept and WL - but I am certainly willing to visit - it’s only 2 hours or so away. I’m just hoping some level of enthusiasm on his part kicks in soon - or this is going to be a long process!</p>

<p>rvm if your son was not into Gettysburg I doubt that Dickinson would be worth a visit. If you are coming to PA to check out LACs I think it would be more worthwhile to visit F&M and Muhlenberg. </p>

<p>sometimes kids have an idea of what they want — until they see another school they like that is nothing at all like what they said they would like—lol</p>

<p>you may not be able to convince him to visit more schools but maybe you and his advisor can convince him to apply at least to a few more so he will have more choices than Elon- that being said, if he is high on Elon why not just apply ED and be done with it?</p>

<p>Seiclan: my DS is totally focused in Miami. Plane ride from home but only 1.5 hrs from grandma and grandpa. Now I’m looking for similar schools. From what I can tell, Tulane us one. </p>

<p>Right now though our (my) immediate focus is studying for SAT 2’s next weekend. But he’s got a group of his URJ camp friends over tonight… all but one are going with him to Israel this summer. Next time he sees them will be at the airport. So he’s not thinking about studying at the moment!</p>

<p>Sent from my ADR6300 using CC App</p>

<p>I second the recommendation of F and M (I think I may have mentioned it a dozen pages back or so). I think it has a bigger “feel” to it than either Gettysburg or Dickinson.
URichmond is a very nice choice. If your son is a strong enough candidate for UMiami, then he will be competitive for Richmond.</p>

<p>Fairly recently one of you asked if anyone would like to see a resume format that you were willing to share. I tried to find the post and PM you but I couldn’t find it. So if I’m talking about you or if you have a good format you would be willing to share please let me know. S2 will hopefully complete a resume draft this week.
Thanks!</p>

<p>spectrum2 - PMed you with a resume format.</p>

<p>RVM: I think that Elon may just be the best fit for your son. It seems to meet most of the criteria that you both have, and it felt right when he visitied. It’s also a good academic fit for him. If he still feels this way in the fall, why not have him apply ED and be done?</p>

<p>Both of my daughters had a true first choice and applied ED. Neither one had second thoughts in the spring when their friends got their acceptances. </p>

<p>Choc: Thanks for asking about my daughter’s birthright trip. She loved the trip. They travelled all over Israel and had a lot of different experiences. Some of the highlights were hiking in the dessert, sleeping in Bedoin tents, Shabbat at the Western Wall, and swimming in the dead sea. She really enjoyed getting to know the Israeli soldiers that travelled with the group. She came home with a much better understanding of the political realities in Israel, and the reasons that American Jews must support Israel. She also made a lot of new friends that she will see back at school, which is a benefit of going with a group from your college.</p>